Biggest bust draft pick in your opinion(Past 5 years)? - Dallas Cowboys Forum

1Ware1 · 04-17-2006

I myself is going to go with Alex Smith QB San Fran.

His perfect wanderlict test isn't going to help him in the NFL.I can't see this guy being a viable backup.If he was to enter this years draft he might at best be a 4th round pick.I can remember the SanFran coach(Nolan)saying he wanted to put a face on the franchise.I myself fell that Schobel(ATL) or Charlie Frye(CLE) will turn out to have more prosperous career's than him

gbrittain · 04-17-2006

Little early to call the guy a bust dont you think. I would give that award to Charles Rogers as of right now.

CrazyCowboy · 04-17-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1Ware1

I myself is going to go with Alex Smith QB San Fran.

His perfect wanderlict test isn't going to help him in the NFL.I can't see this guy being a viable backup.If he was to enter this years draft he might at best be a 4th round pick.I can remember the SanFran coach(Nolan)saying he wanted to put a face on the franchise.I myself fell that Schobel(ATL) or Charlie Frye(CLE) will turn out to have more prosperous career's than him

Let's give that guy a chance........way too early IMO.

Sitting Bull · 04-17-2006

I'm ready to say Charles Rogers right now.

Cornish83 · 04-17-2006

Well If you are talking about the biggest busts you should probably give a player 2-3 years to develop. Charles Rogers is a good pick but I think he could still be a good player IF he gets his act together. It just isnt fair to consider someone who has been in the league for 2-3 years a bust unless they are already out of the league.

AbeBeta · 04-17-2006

How can you say Alex Smith - after 1 year? playing on a crap team? come on.

peplaw06 · 04-17-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1Ware1

I myself is going to go with Alex Smith QB San Fran.

His perfect wanderlict test isn't going to help him in the NFL.I can't see this guy being a viable backup.If he was to enter this years draft he might at best be a 4th round pick.I can remember the SanFran coach(Nolan)saying he wanted to put a face on the franchise.I myself fell that Schobel(ATL) or Charlie Frye(CLE) will turn out to have more prosperous career's than him

Good lord people... How many Number 1 overall QBs came out and lit the world on fire?? I guess Aikman was a bust too. First ballot HOF, 3 SBs, etc. etc. 1-15 first year though. Definitely a bust.

I think there should be a new rule, you can't label someone a bust until they've played in the league 4-5 years. So saying the biggest bust over the last 5 years would be pointless. Then we could do away with threads like this.

Dayton Cowboy · 04-17-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1Ware1

I myself is going to go with Alex Smith QB San Fran.

His perfect wanderlict test isn't going to help him in the NFL.I can't see this guy being a viable backup.If he was to enter this years draft he might at best be a 4th round pick.I can remember the SanFran coach(Nolan)saying he wanted to put a face on the franchise.I myself fell that Schobel(ATL) or Charlie Frye(CLE) will turn out to have more prosperous career's than him

I l ike most so far go with Rogers..

That being said, Atlanta's backup QB is Matt Schaub not any of the Schobels