PFW draft value chart - Dallas Cowboys Forum

gimmesix · 04-13-2007

Nolan Nawrocki writes that it is created with "considerable feedback from NFL teams" (whatever that really means), and it's interesting to see the value of some players Cowboys fans have discussed.

For instance, Reggie Nelson is an early-second round value, according to the charts, while Usama Young (a corner Dallas brought in that I thought was a late-round prospect) has a late second-round value.

http://www.profootballweekly.com/PFW...alue041007.htm

theogt · 04-13-2007

I like how they do that. That's about how I imagined Jeff Ireland's board to look like.

the kid 05 · 04-13-2007

wait, troy smith 3c whats that mean? late third round talent?

gimmesix · 04-13-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by theogt

I like how they do that. That's about how I imagined Jeff Ireland's board to look like.

The way Ireland talked about it a few weeks ago, I'd think so. It seems that he has the draft picks grouped in tiers like that, so Dallas valuing one player over another when it picks might not be the case. It might simply be the Cowboys picking from a group of players they consider similarly valued like this.

(I don't like, however, that the players I want most in the first and second rounds are valued ahead of where we pick.

)

gimmesix · 04-13-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by the kid 05

wait, troy smith 3c whats that mean? late third round talent?

Correct.

the kid 05 · 04-14-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by gimmesix

Correct.

my how the once mighty have fallen then

BLT · 04-14-2007

maybe its just me but i love the thought of trading down... im so glad i keep hearing about us trading down to get 2 2nd rounders... because basically i think that a late 1st and an early 2nd are basically the same thing in this years draft

theogt · 04-14-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by the kid 05

my how the once mighty have fallen then

He hasn't fallen. That's about where he was always projected.

the kid 05 · 04-14-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by theogt

He hasn't fallen. That's about where he was always projected.

are you cereal? i thought he was 2nd round not 3rd

BLT · 04-14-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by the kid 05

are you cereal? i thought he was 2nd round not 3rd

what i thought he was day 2... i know hes rated behind Kolb Edwards Stanton and other QBs hes probably even behind Palmer since Palmer has the mechanics and the Carson connection... i wouldnt be pissed if we took Palmer in the 5th.

theogt · 04-14-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by the kid 05

are you cereal? i thought he was 2nd round not 3rd

Quote:

Originally Posted by BLT

what i thought he was day 2... i know hes rated behind Kolb Edwards Stanton and other QBs hes probably even behind Palmer since Palmer has the mechanics and the Carson connection... i wouldnt be pissed if we took Palmer in the 5th.

Yeah, it's all fuzzy in that area. He could go late 3rd all the way to 5th round. He's certainly not now, nor has he ever been, a 2nd rounder.

ZeroClub · 04-14-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by gimmesix

Nolan Nawrocki writes that it is created with "considerable feedback from NFL teams" (whatever that really means), and it's interesting to see the value of some players Cowboys fans have discussed.

For instance, Reggie Nelson is an early-second round value, according to the charts, while Usama Young (a corner Dallas brought in that I thought was a late-round prospect) has a late second-round value.

Thanks for posting this. It's interesting.

**MichaelWinicki** · 04-14-2007

That is well done.

mmillman · 04-14-2007

I would like to see Dallas spend a late pick on Smardzija

Wimbo · 04-14-2007

Here is another similar compilation. I think these make handy reference guides on draft day.
http://www.newerascouting.com/index.php?c=9