A Case for Redball

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Matts4313, Dec 3, 2012.

  1. Matts4313

    Matts4313 Well-Known Member

    344 Messages
    266 Likes Received
    Hey all - I wrote this for another forum that I am part of. Part of the reason I wrote it though is due to all the crazy negativity I read here this morning. I thought I would share this with you guys - feel free to rip apart.

    Also - PS - Adam, if you are reading this - WOULD LOVE TO SEE SOME CAP ANALYSIS!! What kind of shape are we in for next year????

    A case for Garrett:

    So - As many of you know, I am a supporter =>OF THE DIRECTION<= the franchise is going under Garrett. I emphasis those words to make a point. I do think Garrett as a coach and play caller has some significant deficiencies. Namely, the game day management of the offense and the perpetual problem with penalties (side note, 2003 was the last year we had under 6 penalties a game. We have been in the bottom 10 almost every year since then).

    So Matt, why do you like Garrett? I think he has brought something that we have sorely lacked for far to long. He brought an identity.

    Identity, who cares about that? All that matters are W/L.... Right? Sure - Wins are all that matters. But to build a franchise that can have continued success, you need to have an identity. For some teams that is "Smash Mouth"', "Defense" or "Passing Attack". Others it is simply "fundamental/Smart". But look at the teams that have continued success and they have a coach that embodies the identity of their team. Those coaches are in place for a significant tenure and mold a culture that breeds success.

    Well then Mr. SmartyPants - What is our identity? RKG. Right kind of guy. Listen to Garrett talk about any roster move and you will hear this phrase. You will hear it more than once. Its our hope for the Dallas Cowboys, our future. Its a mentality. Its a type of player. Its a type of person. Its the culture that Garrett has started to implement.

    Lots of hyperbole there, still didnt define RKG. Well, I can give you what MY definition would be. Not sure if it is Garretts. To me, it means a person with good character. A player who has passion for the game. A scrappy fighter who will give it 100%. Its people who will put in the work. An ode to the old school in that sense - football means more than money or fame. A team full of players that all have the heart of Jason Witten.

    Thats cute, but I see an 8-8 team. Wheres the proof? I am impatient. I NEED A SUPERBOWL NOW!! You're right - we are an average team right now. There is no reasonable thought process that says otherwise. But that doesn't mean we are not improving. I posted this in another thread, but take a look at this:

    Alright, so we've transformed ~60% of the starters in 2 years. We are still AVERAGE, you said it yourself. Sure, I said it. I think we are average for a few key reasons:
    1. We are young in a lot of places
    2. Even with all the turnover, not all positions have been appropriately addressed.
    3. We are injured... Very injured.

    Injuries are an excuse. Besides, we drafted injury prone players, what can you expect? We should be able to overcome *some* injuries. But the truth is we are not talented enough to overcome multiple injuries at key positions. When Garrett took over, he had ~5 great players, ~5 good players, ~5 good enough guys and about ~35 guys who wouldn't make it on most NFL rosters. We know this because we have cut them - and most are buried on a depth chart or not on a team at all.

    As for being injury prone, I don't buy into that for MOST NFL players. You want to say Glass Hammy Austin is injury prone? Okay, fine. But to say a guy who breaks a hand one year and then a toe the next year is injury prone is false (in my opinion). He is simply unlucky. Those are two very different injuries that have absolutely nothing to do with each other.

    Ok, so what if I bought into your theory? Redball comes in, rebuilds the bulk of the team under our noses, all while giving us some entertaining competitive football to watch. When should we expect playoff success? Good question. Tough to answer. I think it would be fair and accurate to say that this offseason is highly critical to the future of Garrett. I do not think you put Garrett on the "Hot Seat" for all of next year. But I do think there needs to be some internal conversations with Garrett that 2013 needs to be a significantly more disciplined team. I think it should be made very aware to Garrett that the amount of boneheaded mistakes our team makes is beyond unacceptable. If it were me, I would let Garrett know that he be relieved of the offensive coordinator title. As a young Head Coach, he needs to surround himself with smart people who can help him right the ship.

    TLDR version: Garrett has planted the seeds of our new identity. He deserves at least one more year to see the fruits of his labor.
  2. BAZ

    BAZ Drunken Mick

    4,829 Messages
    2,659 Likes Received
    People that talk to themselves are not to be trusted.
  3. rocboy22

    rocboy22 Active Member

    1,606 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    Well written post
  4. Novacek84

    Novacek84 Well-Known Member

    1,491 Messages
    390 Likes Received
  5. TTexasTT

    TTexasTT Well-Known Member

    1,926 Messages
    737 Likes Received
    Agreed, he has had a wonderful impact. Thankfully the carzies that actually think Payton will be here are wrong.
    I embrace JG for our HC for atleast a decade.
    There are haters, true.
    We gonna act like this O-line insnt horrible?
    We gonna act like our ProBowl NG is injured?
    Two big time ILB arent hurt?
    What about the safety, where is he?

    Garrett has playersout there pouring everything into the game.
    Our RB limps out to the field for the opening drive.
    JG has a HOF TE out there trying to play with a lacerated spleen.
    Ernie Simms could be working at Starbucks but JG has him on the field making plays.
    Oh yeah? Remember that headcase, gangbanging, draft bust, thug, scrub? Thats the same guy that is making plays the almost no other athlete can make. Dez Bryant is running over, running past and dominated the opponents.

    Really, would Landry, Lombardi, Chesty Puller, Red Auerbach or Joel Osteen have this team playing better. Absolutely not.

    I look forward to a long time Jason Garrett era. Having this team ring six wins is something of a miracle.
    All the Payton, Gruden, Holmgren and Bill Cowher dreamers should probably just come to terms and bow down to the new Cowboy Coaching Overlord, a new era is upon us.
    LOL at you suggesting she has any idea she knows what shes talking about. You do understand she is the laughing stock of the local media, right?
    "She seems to get it" HAHAHAHAHAMLAHFGOIHA
  6. Novacek84

    Novacek84 Well-Known Member

    1,491 Messages
    390 Likes Received
    She may be a laughingstock but it doesn't mean she's wrong about this topic.
  7. TTexasTT

    TTexasTT Well-Known Member

    1,926 Messages
    737 Likes Received
    Sure, lets just cherry pick topics that we happen to agree with. To heck with the source.

    In other news the Enquirer reports that Brad Pitt will be giving birth to a dinosaur that has the cure for cancer.
  8. Section444

    Section444 Well-Known Member

    5,725 Messages
    1,828 Likes Received
    I'm willing to give the guy another chance, I'm kind of tired of the coaching-carousel.
  9. Novacek84

    Novacek84 Well-Known Member

    1,491 Messages
    390 Likes Received
    What topic would you like me to address when the column is about Garrett? And the source is just fine. I don't live in TX. So sorry I didn't follow Jen all those years at the StarTelegram when she apparently wrote a lot of unreasonable columns. Lets cherry pick the rants we make only against writers we don't like. C'mon man.
  10. TTexasTT

    TTexasTT Well-Known Member

    1,926 Messages
    737 Likes Received
    Someone is watching Monday Night Countdown!

    Im messin' with ya, bud. There are many others who agree with her.
  11. jgboys1

    jgboys1 Well-Known Member

    4,129 Messages
    236 Likes Received
    Same here. Lets see what happens next year. Get some help in the trenches in the offseason and you can see a much improved Cowboys team next season.
  12. Idgit

    Idgit That sounds really boring Staff Member

    45,182 Messages
    29,531 Likes Received
    I don't care with JFE pretends to think about anything, honestly. She's only a sensationalist, so her opinions don't matter.

    As to Garrett, I think this post does a nice job of expressing just what I think about the guy. He's underdelivered under some tough circumstances. He had one impressive half-season, then underperformed expectations badly the last 5 games of last season, and has been up and down this season.

    The salary cap and, this year, season-ending injuries to defensive starters have been challenging. Those aren't excuses for the team, but they should factor into the evaluation of the job the coach has done. He's also still alive this season, and a lot of people are reacting as if we've been eliminated since the WAS loss.

    I think the guy deserves and gets another year. I think--despite the record--the team is actually pretty close. I think we have a good roster, overall, too, though we're limited in some areas and we've gotten smacked right in our limitations this season (C, S, WR, and, with the multiple injuries, ILB). I know that the tone and the attitude of the team has changed, and that we've gotten rid of a lot of players who weren't bright and weren't the types of guys I personally like to see on my team. I know we've assembled an impressive coaching staff (thought I agree that Rob Ryan is slightly overrated). I love that our players seem to love him, too--at least the leaders like Romo, Witten, and Ware.

    I understand, too, why some fans are disappointed or think they just haven't seen enough. As long as they're expressing that in a context of how hard this job actually is and how much work is needed, I don't have any problem with that. It's only the constant hindsight second-guessing of play calling and the straight up unfair criticisms like those aimed at our challenge history or that try to not credit him for anything that goes well and everything that goes poorly that I really ever object to.

    He's a smart guy who conducts himself like a professional who hasn't won as many games as he could have these last two seasons. Not the end of the world, but not what we demand and expect yet, either. I give him another season and let him implement his plan fully and see where we're at. I think most fans, in their hearts of hearts, believe this is what's going to happen, too.
  13. GloryDaysRBack

    GloryDaysRBack Well-Known Member

    11,935 Messages
    4,019 Likes Received
    RKG is not a teams identity.

    This team has no identity
  14. goshan

    goshan Well-Known Member

    2,007 Messages
    109 Likes Received
    RKG is not an identity and we are no more RKG than any average team
  15. Novacek84

    Novacek84 Well-Known Member

    1,491 Messages
    390 Likes Received
    Never miss it!!
  16. sbark

    sbark Well-Known Member Zone Supporter

    5,091 Messages
    1,124 Likes Received
    I'll agree........but I want to see steady improvement and consistency from JG. Just as JG wants to see from his players on a daily weekly, seasonaly basis.

    I want to see him react with improvment in game mngt/clock mngt sits, I want to see him be creative with scheme to help put players in position to succeed. Let him reward the rooster with in-season moves (Parnell vrs Free and OTree)

    Other teams have weakness's this time of year.......I want to exploit them via scheme just as they do our positions with injuries, players with warts........I dont want TNEw to appear All Pro on Sunday--isolate and get after him.
  17. Novacek84

    Novacek84 Well-Known Member

    1,491 Messages
    390 Likes Received
    I'm curious. What makes you think you will see this improvement if JG stays? He certainly didn't learn from the FG fiasco in AZ last year because it was repeated this year in BAL. I've been expecting to see improvement of the process this year and since I don't its why I want him replaced. I want coach stability but not if the guy can't prove his "process" actually is working.
  18. sbark

    sbark Well-Known Member Zone Supporter

    5,091 Messages
    1,124 Likes Received
    No guarantee's there........maybe those impovements have to come via him giving up the Off Coor duties...........it is a process JJ has to go thru also.
  19. Eskimo

    Eskimo Well-Known Member

    12,821 Messages
    496 Likes Received
    Idgit, I agree with much of your post.

    However, there is one factor that I think people constantly discount when assessing Garrett's job with this team and the roster he inherited. I think few would argue that he inherited a lot of dead weight, entitled, underperforming and disinterested vets who got theirs and were looking to relax at Club Cowboys under Wade and Jerry. These guys had to be let go right away and Garrett turfed all of them right away but this created two years of cap hell to deal with all of the repercussions. Then he inherits $10M of bogus cap penalty from the league and so gets cap hell squared.

    Now the second part of the roster he inherited was the BP guys who were brought in from 2003- 6. These guys were the heart and soul of the team and contained some very good but now expensive players like Romo, Ware, Witten, Austin and Ratliff. So again these guys are our core but they are entering the downside of their careers in many cases where their productivity has peaked and now started to decline. So while these guys are good they probably are no longer bargains on the roster compared to productivity but you need vets like this to have a quality of team and maintain culture so no problem with this group right now. But we will soon have to prepare for some possible cap hits (Rat and Austin) and an expensive re-signing and the best player of all may be in decline from chronic neck injuries (Ware). So there are problems that may be arising soon that we have to get ready for.

    Now the last group of players he inherited was the group that should be ascending to their peak and forming the new core of this team (2006-9). In this group there are a few good players like Spencer and Hatcher. After that there is Jenkins who hasn't played much this year recovering from injury, Felix has been banged up all year recovering from shoulder injury and then injured both feet. The only other player of significance may be the worst starter on the team, Dough Free. This is the "doughnut" core of the roster and if we cut Free and let Spencer, Jenkins and Felix walk all but Hatcher will be gone. This is the doughnut core of our roster that is causing our problems. This is why we have to do very well in player acquisitions and FA just to stand still as a franchise. The only trick is that we have cap hell squared to deal with so we mostly have to shop from the bargain bin to fill our needs.

    Finally there is the new group of players 2010-12 who includes the last draft class Wade produced and Garrett's first two draft classes that will form the next core: Lee, Dez, Tyron, Murray, Carter, Claiborne, Crawford, Lissemore, Costa, Killer and Brent. Here we see the embodiment of the new vision for the Cowboys and I do like the newcomers and see a chance for them to form a nucleus going forwards and they mature and reach their peaks and pull us forward into the future.

    I think Garrett's job at rebuilding and remoulding this roster is a far more daunting task than anyone truly appreciated. After all, he was taking over one of the most talented rosters in the league - the one that had just gotten off to a 1-7 start and two back to back blowout losses including one to the hapless Jacksonville Jaguars and a shellacking by the Giants.
  20. Idgit

    Idgit That sounds really boring Staff Member

    45,182 Messages
    29,531 Likes Received
    Yes. I've seen you post this before, and I think it's exactly right. And, when I'm saying Garrett's underperformed expectations in some areas, that doesn't necessarily mean that the expectations were reasonable or accurate. But only that that context matters because it affects how his performance is viewed.

    One of the reasons I'm sure JG's safe this offseason is that the team clearly had to understand what the cap situation was two seasons ago, and they clearly embarked on a plan that was going to take longer than this season to implement. I believe they're on or ahead of schedule in most areas in terms of assembling the talent and changing/improving the culture. They may be behind somewhat in the quality of the game day coaching, but even that's hard to see when you can tell how hamstrung he is as a play caller. You just need to look at how differently Rob Ryan's game plans look now that he's absent a handful of players to realize how much personnel factors into a game plan.

    Jerry's been around long enough to understand that good things take time to build, and he's smart enough (yeah, I said it) to have his own success measurements that include wins and losses as well as whatever myriad other details which matter a lot but we're not privy to. He's got to be careful about how and where the demonstrates his outrage in order to do what he can to affect fan perceptions, but the guy wants to win. It's good business for him to win. He'll stay the course if he thinks its the right course, at least until it gets a lot more painful that it's going to get this off season.

Share This Page