Yes, but add Mariah. She doesn't add anything worthy to most contestants. Randy is just Randy but he is a staple and knows what he is doing. I get tired of hearing "dawg" or whatever but I like him. I can't stand Nicki or Mariah(but I respect her singing). Time to go back to three judges or pack it in IMO, along with keeping Ryan. Idol is hurting because of the format. They let a bunch of weirdos and whackos audition. Yes, it may add to some funny highlights but it gets old. There is no logical reason those ppl should even try to audition. The Voice has it right, only the best get to sing blind at the start. Their voting process is better too.