Discussion in 'Off-topic Zone' started by kristie, Jan 15, 2014.
the group round, which was featured in last night's episode, was dramatic as usual.
Harry Connick, Jr. Legitimizes this show.
May be too late though.
He is by far the best judge to date.
totally agree with you there.
from tonight's show:
I don't really follow them until live performances. I do hope both of those guys from Alabama get in though.
glad this gal made it:
What a screw up for Idol.
Pick the damn top 20, don't string 5 people out and then sabotage the other ten into nerve raddled out of breath crap. Not one performance was on the money.
i know! i thought it was insane. i mean, the 5 who got cut didn't deserve to. they should've let all 15 ladies perform!
What a crock, most of them girls sucked and the ones left out were better. Rush week, this isn't a Greek affiliation and not letting 5 sing is stupid.
Jessica Meuse is my odds on favorite to win for the females. She is original, believable and writes her own songs, not sure why the judges were harder on her. That girl who sang Katy Perry's "Roar" should be embarrassed and just quit, it was atrocious. The girl who sang the Rolling Stones song(Jena?) was decent, the rest were awful.
I can't wait until Elton John and Motown week again
Alex Preston is my favorite singer and I love what Harry Connick brings to the show
You don't like Majesty Rose? I thought she was the best of the girls and I liked the girl from Austin Jessica Meuse had to sing off against to get into the top 30 better than Jessica, but what do I know?
Rose was ok but didn't like the song choice. She certainly is not atrocious but was expecting more I guess.
And yes, Jessie Roach(Austin) should have been in the top 15 along with Jessica, liked her a lot.
You know about as much as me I suspect, nada
i agree with you on those two, & they happen to be my favorites among the girls who are left. my other favorite, jillian, got cut & didn't get a chance to sing.
the top 13:
I don't see why they keep saying that is the best they have had since very early. It seems pretty weak to me with not much talent there. I don't see a star/idol in the bunch.
i think one will emerge as the show goes on. it's still early.
as far as who i think is the best top 13 in the show's history, i say season 7's top 13 was the best IMO. that season was loaded with talent, & one of my favorite winners, david cook, emerged from that season.