All fair analysis with the exception, I think, of the statement on upside. IMO, RG3 has more upside then any QB in this draft. However, upside is just another word for potential and RG3 may or may not reach that full potential so the question of upside is a gamble. It does not guarantee success but I don't believe that there is any question, RG3 has more upside then does Luck. I would still take Luck though and I would never look back.