Oh no, always room for healthy debate! I think the Barber situation was rather different. Barber had a short life span due to his style, he was always suited for the closer role. Murray is very similiar to Adrian Peterson in my opinion. At least in styles of running. The thing about Murray is that he hasn't even had a good OL until now, and last year our OL was OK. If we properly utilize him behind the OL, he will have identical numbers to AP. I truly believe Murray can be elite if he is given the chance. You have to remember we never ran the ball when we should of last year, and Murray had a very high YPC. Barber was a TD machine, where Murray is more of an actual RB imo.