Did ya'll see the Horsecollar?

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by cowboyfreak, Sep 2, 2005.

  1. cowboyfreak

    cowboyfreak Member

    499 Messages
    3 Likes Received
    Did ya'll see the Horsecollar that Shanle performed. It wasn't called.
    It looked like a textbook horsecollar to me. An immediate jerk down of the ball carrier-outside the tacklebox-by pulling on the back of the shoulder pads.

    There is so much grey area in this assinine rule that I feel that only Roy Williams will draw this stupid flag. Has there ever been a time when 1 player footed the bill for the NFL's stupidity? :mad:

    Wait.. I know the answer to that...yes.
    Emmitt, EWilliams, MIrvin, KSmith

    You know its like they say:

    "What goes around...doesn't always come around"
  2. TX_Yid

    TX_Yid Well-Known Member

    1,567 Messages
    460 Likes Received
    Looked to me like he had hold of the shirt up there but not the actual pad itself, is that still a horse collar?
  3. Gibby!

    Gibby! Pom Pom Waving Shill

    1,511 Messages
    13 Likes Received
    They explained it a little during the game, if the player is inside the tackles, and/or lets go before (either the player hits the ground or the tackle is finished) its not a penalty, or something like that, I didn't really pay attention.

    But during the replay it looked like it was all jersey to me anyway so I don't think it should have been called.

    FRDRCK DeWare94

    970 Messages
    9 Likes Received
    its only a horse collar if the hand is inside of the collar
  5. Doomsday101

    Doomsday101 Well-Known Member

    88,514 Messages
    11,548 Likes Received
    Reeves almost got one as well, as he was chasing the RB down field the back stiff armed him and he started to grad the back by the collar but last second he was able to grab hold of the RB around the waist to make the stop. I can see how difficult this rule will be on defenders if the back is stiff arming you while you are tying to make the tackle.
  6. DBoys

    DBoys New Member

    4,713 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    He had his jersey not pads

    FRDRCK DeWare94

    970 Messages
    9 Likes Received
    somebody grabbed julius' collar on his touchdown run vs the texans im just glad he's too fast for whoever it was that grabbed him
  8. TobiasEagle77

    TobiasEagle77 Member

    887 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    The rule has hardly been enforced this preseason, and so far very inconsistently. I agree with the intent of this rule, but I don't think it's very practical. I don't think I agree with it.

Share This Page