Goose - "I'd be surprised if the Cowboys DON'T go DL"

Discussion in 'Draft Zone' started by marchetta, Feb 28, 2012.

  1. 28 Joker

    28 Joker 28 Joker

    7,878 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    Why way overpay in free agency when DeCastro and Glenn are solid, safe, economical values at 14 and meet a huge need? Phillip Blake in round 2 or 3...The Cowboys have scouted him heavily according to Mosley.

    I'm not paying Scott Wells (31 and undersized) 11.5 million dollars guaranteed. Who are all these great guard options? The top 2 will be very, very expensive. Dallas needs 3 interior offensive line players, anyway.

    I sure don't want to draft some overrated NT from Memphis. Let someone else take that risk. Who was that overrated DT from Kentucky in 2003?
  2. 28 Joker

    28 Joker 28 Joker

    7,878 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    Gosselin sure did praise the Eagles for drafting an OG in round 1 last year, didn't he. The Cowboys are seriously hurting for players in the interior offensive line. Nevertheless, Gosselin advocates passing over the solid, low risk value that matches a dire need (interior offensive line), in favor of drafting an extremely high bust rate position (defensive line).

    Let's look at the Philadelphia Eagles first round investments in the defensive line:

    1997: Jon Harris DE
    2000: Corey Simon DT
    2003: Jerome McDougle DE (pick 15)
    2005: Mike Patterson DT
    2006: Brodrick Bunkley DT (pick 14)
    2010: Brandon Graham (pick 13)

    Here are two of Andy Reid's 2nd round defensive linemen:

    2008: Trevor Laws (pick 47)
    2007: Victor Abiamiri (pick 57)

    The Eagles are supposed to be draft geniuses, but look at their drafting in the defensive line. Where was the Eagles' reward? This is a perfect example of how very risky defensive line picks are in the NFL.

    On the other hand:

    1998: Tra Thomas (1st round; pick 11) ( 3x Pro Bowl and 1x All-Pro)
    2004: Shawn Andrews (1st round; pick 16) (2x All-Pro and 3x Pro Bowl)
    2011: Danny Watkins (1st round; pick 23) starter

    Andrews' depression was the root of his short shelf life, but when fully healthy, Andrews was a dominant force and an All-Pro.
  3. burmafrd

    burmafrd Benched

    43,820 Messages
    3,379 Likes Received

    show me a good guard that Dallas has picked since 1994 outside of the 2nd rd.
  4. jswalker1981

    jswalker1981 Fact > Your Opinion

    2,616 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    And remember that they added Jenkins and Babin in the offseason last year after seeing Graham only get snaps in a rotation.
  5. Deep_Freeze

    Deep_Freeze Well-Known Member

    8,341 Messages
    2,110 Likes Received
    Well 41gy#, I understand what you are saying, its just that you haven't even presented one thing to improve the D. I want to improve both, not just one side of the ball. You mention the busts on D, there are busts everywhere, we have drafted alot of them. If you want to say there are low round picks representing our OL, that is exactly what your asking to happen to the D at a time when they are already not playing well.

    If you want to help Romo, you also have to provide help for Ware. If we lose either one, our season is over. The Texans were able to get past Mario's injury cause they had other rushers, we have none. Talented big men are hard to find, pass rushers too, and we have failed in the past at trying to get them. This doesn't mean we should give up.

    Cause of bad drafting on D, I can understand how most just wanna go all offense, after all, we picked offense first in the last 3 drafts that we had a 1st round pick with some success. There is risk with any draft pick, and you tore down pretty much all the D players cause there is risk. Poe, for example, is torn down cause he rose with a great combine......Ware wouldn't even be on this team if it hadn't been for his combine.

    We could break down them all, including the ones I actually like, but the point is we can't expect for Ware to be all by himself on D, while we build a wall around Romo. I'm all for protecting Romo, and upgrades are needed even if it is in FA dollars. Nicks is a top 3 guard in the league right now, but if we want Mario he is twice as much money as Nicks and its debatable if Mario is top 3 at his position. You just have to understand that OL isn't in the same demand as DL/pass rusher, the draft and the money should make that obvious.

    Sure there is risk, but the rewards could be huge also. Sure you draft a OL high, he has a higher chance of success and front 7 guys are harder to find. But thats also the reason the Giants keep drafting them, and of course they got shiny things on their fingers and no probowl guards.

    An offensive powerhouse will make you a solid team and will win ballgames as a defensive powerhouse will do the same. But balance will win you multiple rings.
  6. CCBoy

    CCBoy Well-Known Member

    26,356 Messages
    7,467 Likes Received
    Sorry, I don't know...and he is exactly what all of us time bidders have been wanting to be able to run the classic 3-4. I even like the ability to move him to the defensive end position with either Jay or Brent at the nose. Heck, throw Lassimore in at the nose as well, and you have a front of Ratliff, Poe, and Lassimore...and pressure.
  7. Teague31

    Teague31 Defender of the Star

    9,122 Messages
    5,187 Likes Received
    cue the crickets...
  8. stasheroo

    stasheroo Well-Known Member

    32,063 Messages
    16,960 Likes Received
    No kidding, right?

  9. Dough Boy

    Dough Boy Seldom Seen

    2,147 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    I really hope Arkin is that guy. With one full season under his belt; a full offseason with the Wocieck (sp). I really hope Callahan can develop him and Wocieck can build him.

    He is not there yet, but I hope (for the sake of the team) he and Nagy are both keepers.
  10. Gaede

    Gaede Well-Known Member

    10,990 Messages
    3,842 Likes Received
    So convenient that you 'randomly' picked 1994. You know, the year we picked possibly the best guard in the history of the NFL in the second round.
  11. stasheroo

    stasheroo Well-Known Member

    32,063 Messages
    16,960 Likes Received
    How many years back is enough?

    Is 18 not far enough to show their clear failure in this area?

    I think 10 years is more than enough honestly.

    Anybody who can't see that this team has failed in this area is simply blinding themselves to the fact.
  12. RoyTheHammer

    RoyTheHammer Well-Known Member

    13,938 Messages
    841 Likes Received
    Um.. i think that's exactly why he picked that year. Because we picked a great guard that year, but his point was to show how long its been since we've drafted a guard who was any good.

    That being said, im not sure what point it serves in this discussion. Again, i think this thread is simply just alot of overreaction. If you asked Goose who he would take, im betting he'd say DeCastro if he's there. This is just a discussion starter, it was a rational argument of why it may be better to take a stud DL if there is one available over a stud OG at 14. He's simply saying, if we go this route, that there is a much better chance of getting a quality OG and CB in the later rounds than there is of taking OG at 14 and getting a quality DL in the later rounds.
  13. Gaede

    Gaede Well-Known Member

    10,990 Messages
    3,842 Likes Received
    But that's the flaw in his argument. We picked maybe one of the best OL in the history of the sport in the second round. So that somehow is supposed to justify spending a high 1st on a G? One that isn't even remotely similar as a talent? One that can't even play tackle or center?

    My point is, that these players ARE available outside of the top 15 picks.
  14. InmanRoshi

    InmanRoshi Zone Scribe

    18,334 Messages
    79 Likes Received
    And it's more a point of the Cowboys mis-evaluating and not developing talent at an NFL level when it comes off offensive line. Other teams do it. That's the real disease that needs to be cured, not throwing more good money after bad.
  15. Hoofbite

    Hoofbite Well-Known Member

    35,097 Messages
    4,370 Likes Received
    It's not like great players can't come from 14.

    By no means is it impossible but its far from guaranteed you get a guy that's good. Revis is a rarity. Like Ed Reed or Polamalu. More often then not, DBs are okay at best.

    Here's a list of DBs taken from the 2005 - 2009 Drafts, picked 20th or higher.

    There wasn't a DB taken in the 1st round in 2010 and it's too early to say anything about 2011.

    How many guys on that list would you call playmakers or difference makers?

  16. Chocolate Lab

    Chocolate Lab Run-loving Dino

    33,928 Messages
    2,894 Likes Received
    Yup. So many people claim we have to take OL to be help Romo, but how does it help Romo to have to play from behind all game every week?

    And someone asked what decent guard we'd drafted since 1994... Andre Gurode was a pretty good guard.
  17. RoyTheHammer

    RoyTheHammer Well-Known Member

    13,938 Messages
    841 Likes Received
    That's a fair point, but his point counters by showing how hard it is to hit on a top level OG if you don't take them early. In this draft, there is one guy who is clearly the top prospect at the position and is projected by almost everybody to be a multiple time Pro Bowler and All Pro. Then its a crapshoot as far as the rest of the interior OL prospects.. even though there are good ones who i think will be available in the 2nd and 3rd rounds.
  18. Dough Boy

    Dough Boy Seldom Seen

    2,147 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    Agreed. Dallas needs to have a higher hit rate on drafted OL. No question about that. I think back to Jacob Rogers and Peterman. Fairly high picks that we missed on.

    One way to get a higher % of hits; draft better players. Generally, the higher you pick them the higher you had them ranked.

    But I agree 100%, we need to develop the 3rd, 4th rd linemen. Nicks and Evans were not 1st round picks. The Arkins, and Brewsters of the world, we need to hit on guys like that. Dallas has to get better at developing the OL in-house. Typically speaking, OG is a position that you can grow in-house. See NO; they have two pro bowlers that were not 1st round picks.

    With all that being said, I really like DeCastro and he is one of five players I would take in the 1st round.
  19. InmanRoshi

    InmanRoshi Zone Scribe

    18,334 Messages
    79 Likes Received
    Exactly. Want to keep Tony Romo healthy? We all do. How about pairing him with a defense that doesn't insist that he drop back and chuck the ball around 50 times a game, while defenders get to pin their ears back and tee off on him, because we're always in shoot outs? Wanna take the pressure off of Romo? I agree. How about pairing him with a defense where a 90 QB rating is a good enough performance to win a game instead of a flawless 140 QB peformance with no margin for a single bad read or errant throw?

    Everyone talks about all this difference Harbaugh had on Alex Smith and helping him turn the corner this year. The 49ers offense was 31st in the NFL in pass attempts. They were 29th in passing yards per game. They hardly ever asked Alex Smith to carry the team to win the game in the way Romo is asked to every week. Making the 49ers defense a dominant force was the most "QB Friendly" thing that franchise ever did in Alex Smith's career.
  20. Dough Boy

    Dough Boy Seldom Seen

    2,147 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    Subpar guard, very good Center...

    Its a the chicken or the egg. Which do you build 1st? The skill position or the line. No right answer. Generally if you take the best player on the board (don't miss too many) then over the course of a few years you should field a good team. Reaching for either (skill player or lineman) is never the right answer.

    Dallas methodology for the offense line was to build through free agency not the draft. That was the problem I had. There are some good Offensive lineman that Dallas placed a 2nd round grade on. The two linemen from SF come to mind. Upatti (sp) and Davis. No way either should have had a 2nd round grade.

Share This Page