How many of our defenders would you say are above average for their position?

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by MarionBarberThe4th, Jun 14, 2014.

  1. MarionBarberThe4th

    MarionBarberThe4th Well-Known Member

    13,681 Messages
    1,637 Likes Received
  2. Cebrin

    Cebrin Well-Known Member

    1,308 Messages
    811 Likes Received
    Who knows until they get some chemistry and what we hope is good coaching.
  3. jday

    jday Well-Known Member

    6,566 Messages
    6,575 Likes Received
    We should probably table this question until we've seen at least 1 regular season game. Right now, it's anybody guess what we have.
  4. MichaelWinicki

    MichaelWinicki "You want some?" Staff Member

    41,518 Messages
    14,412 Likes Received

    Too many question marks at this point.

    There aren't going to be nearly enough "above average" guys for a top-10 defense.

    But there may be enough to escape the bottom 1/2 dozen teams of the NFL. However at this point we just don't know who they are.
    jday likes this.
  5. perrykemp

    perrykemp Well-Known Member

    9,975 Messages
    6,314 Likes Received
    I'll take a swing:
    • Melton is far above average for his position if removing injury from the equation
    • Scandrick is top echelon nickel back (which is where I think he'll end up this year)
    • Barry Church is a slightly better than average SS
    That's it based on what we know TODAY.
    jday, BigStar and MarionBarberThe4th like this.
  6. MarionBarberThe4th

    MarionBarberThe4th Well-Known Member

    13,681 Messages
    1,637 Likes Received

    Haha thanks for answering at least sheesh. Why don't we table all discussions until the season starts guys ?

    So you think claireborne fights for his spot back then? That'd be such a bonus. I've kind of written him off bc he isn't any good but corners are fickle so who knows maybe the light comes on.

    And idk about Melton I really forgot he was still In the league tbh. He very well could have a big season.
  7. Tawney88

    Tawney88 Well-Known Member

    1,640 Messages
    631 Likes Received
    None are above average until they prove otherwise. We had the worst defense in team history last season and I didn't see it markedly improve this year.
    jnday likes this.
  8. PA Cowboy Fan

    PA Cowboy Fan Well-Known Member

    8,226 Messages
    11,660 Likes Received
    Lee when he's healthy. That's about all. There's a few average players and a lot of below average ones.
    AKATheRake and jnday like this.
  9. Idgit

    Idgit If you food, you gonna be ate. Staff Member

    45,960 Messages
    32,569 Likes Received
    Lee, Melton, Scandrick

    Then we've got a handful of guys who have a little bit of experience and might have the ability to be above average this season: Carter, Wilcox, Claiborne, Crawford, Lawrence.

    We've got some other players I'm looking forward to watching develop, but it'd be too soon to expect anything much from them right now. It's a pretty bare cupboard on defense this season.
    BigStar likes this.
  10. boyzjunkie

    boyzjunkie Active Member

    295 Messages
    83 Likes Received
    With the offense I imagine, we don't need above average defenders. If they are all just average we will win out over the gnats, girls and skinnies.
  11. Toruk_Makto

    Toruk_Makto Well-Known Member

    10,256 Messages
    11,291 Likes Received
    This defense was top 10 in takeaways. The defense is better than last year.
  12. Toruk_Makto

    Toruk_Makto Well-Known Member

    10,256 Messages
    11,291 Likes Received
    You forgot Carr
    CowboyFan74 likes this.
  13. BigStar

    BigStar Stop chasing

    7,261 Messages
    3,701 Likes Received
    Good rundown but I feel Church is average in that he is a liability in the passing game. We seem to give him a pass being undrafted and turning himself into a player (starter). Ideal third safety. Lee would lead the group if healthy.
  14. Howboutdemcowboys31

    Howboutdemcowboys31 Well-Known Member

    2,537 Messages
    2,775 Likes Received
    When healthy:

    Lee (superstar)
    Melton (low end pro bowler)
    Church (definitely above avg)
    Carr (20-25th best cb so above avg)
    Scandrick (top 3 slot corner and above avg outside corner)

    Just my 0.02
    StarBoyz83 likes this.
  15. xwalker

    xwalker Well-Known Member

    28,490 Messages
    21,120 Likes Received
    They have a lot of players with the potential to be above average. That has not always been the case. Years like the one where Alan Ball was the projected starting safety, there was really no chance that he was going to be above average as a Safety.

    Church - On a good defense he could be very similar to Seattle's Kam Chancellor.
    Wilcox - High upside.
    Other Safeties: Several with really good physical ability.

    Carr: He's done it before.
    Scandrick: Above average as a Nickel CB. Would need to have better ball skills to be above average on the outside.
    Claiborne: Probably already above average as a 3rd CB. Needs to become above average as a starter.

    Carter: Was good in 2012 and has as much physical ability as just about any LB in the league.
    Holloman: Was above average for a late round rookie. Has a high upside.
    Wilber: Interesting combination as a SLB with pass rushing experience and better than average size. Measureables are almost identical to Seattle's starting SLB.
    Hitchens: Leading tackler in conference at a big college.
    Durant: Would be above average backup or OK starter.

    Lawrence: One of the most well developed DEs in the draft. Not as good of an athlete as guys like Barr, but a more developed football player.
    Melton: Was one of the best just a couple of years ago. Still young.
    McClain: Appears to have the required physical ability and has significantly developed as a player since his rookie year (2011). Defensive star of OTAs.
    Selvie: At least average last season.
    Crawford: Everybody in the Cowboys organization thinks he has it.
    Backup DL: Many young guys with really good physical ability for possible above average depth. Spencer and/or Okoye could add to the mix if healthy.
    CowboyGil, BigStar and Kaiser like this.
  16. StarBoyz83

    StarBoyz83 Well-Known Member

    9,951 Messages
    4,527 Likes Received
    Carr loved the signing played great his first year imo but he'll step up this yet big time.
    scandrick been a fan for years
    church been a fan for a while plus coolest jersey on dallas lol
    lee when healthy
    melton depending on how he plays after Injury

    eager to see all the rookies and im hoping for a healthy spencer because I noticed him as much or more than ware over the years. I know his stats dont say that but dude is disruptive!
  17. CowboyFan74

    CowboyFan74 Cowboys Analyst

    16,676 Messages
    3,002 Likes Received
    I'd add Carr to the mix, he's not all world but he's a couple notches above average...
  18. Chris in Arizona

    Chris in Arizona I am Death

    6,621 Messages
    4,203 Likes Received
    Free Safety situation is amongst the worst in the league.
    Strong Safety - I would say Church is slightly less than average. Incredibly overrated on this board.
    Corners - Man, I had high hopes for this group but they have got to show something this year. On paper, Carr, Claiborne, and Scandrick should be as good as any trio in the NFL.
    Linebackers minus Sean Lee has also got to be one of the worst units around.
    Defensive Line - Hopeful about Crawford, Melton, and Lawrence but serious, serious question marks here.

    It's a good thing Romo can put up a lot of points because he is going to need to. Hopefully, less turnovers from Tony and a grind-it-out run game behind this O Line and we can keep the defense off the field as much as possible.
    sbark and BigStar like this.
  19. jnday

    jnday Well-Known Member

    8,622 Messages
    3,171 Likes Received
    For good reason.
  20. Bwareinrings94

    Bwareinrings94 Well-Known Member

    1,078 Messages
    585 Likes Received
    Church. I can't even pretend there's anyone else as we start the season. Maybe by the end.

Share This Page