Hypothetical Draft Situation w/ Peterson

Discussion in 'Draft Zone' started by Jake0, Mar 16, 2007.

  1. Jake0

    Jake0 Active Member

    639 Messages
    92 Likes Received
    Wow, someone finally gives a constructive reply. Well now I think this thread could be getting somewhere actually after seeing that rumor with Detroit/Cleveland. Pretty much no reason for Cleveland to want to trade up if it's just going to take Peterson. Cleveland could be impressed with Quinn and take him, which means Peterson drops. Since Crenell is close with Weiss he could get tons of inside info. I don't see how someone could put their life on Cleveland taking Peterson, although I did get a good laugh out of it.

    All I made the thread for was to see if people would want to take action if Peterson dropped down to the 8-10 range and instead the replies were riddled with nothing but Peterson is going at #3 trash.

    To me, our 1st, 2nd, Julius, and a couple of 2nd day picks to move up to the 8-10 spot or whatever to get Peterson is a deal I'd easily do. If it costs more I probably wouldn't be for it. I've always been a Julius fan, and he's pretty good, but Peterson is better. I do kind of want to see what Julius would do behind our new line and under a new coach but if the opportunity is there, I think we're in a good position to do this kinda deal.

    p.s. is it just me or does it seem like the majority of posters here just read the topic, click the link and go straight to the reply button without even bothering to read 2 paragraphs?
  2. dboyz

    dboyz Active Member

    818 Messages
    101 Likes Received
    AP is a special player. I don't think I'd make a move even if he fell to 8, unless Houston was a pretty motivated seller. Now if he dropped to 10-11-12, I'd consider swapping firsts, plus JJ and a 3rd this year or maybe a second next year, at the very most.

    With our line, I think a back like AP could be terrific. However, our combo of JJ and Barber is nothing sneeze at, so I wouldn't be wanting to give up the farm as it's not exactly as if we are bare at the position now.

    You should draft the same way you should buy a car or a house. Don't fall in love with a particular model. Let the draft come to you. If AP drops I'd be interested, the same if Calvin Johnson dropped (of course won't happen) Gaines Adams or a number of other players.
  3. big dog cowboy

    big dog cowboy THE BIG DOG Staff Member

    67,290 Messages
    22,614 Likes Received
    Nothing personal, but I am very glad you are not our GM. One starting player and 4 draft picks to move up 18 spots or so is far to much.
  4. jobberone

    jobberone Kane Ala Staff Member

    49,619 Messages
    12,396 Likes Received
    We have a potential SB contender. We are not in need of a RB IMO. This is a deep draft. If we keep still we will get a starting FS, CB, or another starter.

    Peterson is a good pick IMO for someone in the 8-20 range who needs a RB.

    And you're right. This draft has so much depth there will be several teams wanting to trade down.
  5. AsthmaField

    AsthmaField Outta bounds

    16,864 Messages
    13,679 Likes Received
    AP is a very good back. I might start thinking of going and getting him if he slid out of the top 10. However, I don't think that'll ever happen. If it does, then I'll be the first one to start thinking of going and getting him.

    Won't happen though, IMO.

    Just like Emmitt meant a whole lot to our team, a back like AP could be a guy like that. Someone who takes the team from competitive to dominant. He might not though, but he has that kind of talent if he stays healthy.

    We moved up from #21 (I think) to number 17 to get Emmitt. I doubt anyone thought we gave up too much for that trade, regardless of what we traded.
  6. DallasEast

    DallasEast Cowboys 24/7/365 Staff Member

    33,517 Messages
    8,336 Likes Received
    That's my personal viewpoint also. Indianapolis just won a Super Bowl with Joseph Addai in the back field. One could argue that:

    Addai > Julius Jones

    Addai > Marion Barber

    ... but few could, imo, argue that Addai is greater than the combination of Jones and Barber, two young running backs. That's what we have right now. The strengths of this upcoming draft can be mined in areas other than running back. Or, at least, not in the upper top half of the first round.
  7. AbeBeta

    AbeBeta Well-Known Member

    28,567 Messages
    3,118 Likes Received
    But they didn't win with just Addai in the backfield. In fact, Addai ran the ball less than Rhodes in the SB.

    During the season, Addai went 226-1081 (4.8 YPC). Rhodes went 187-641 (3.4 YPC). Addai had 40 receptions and Rhodes 36. During the post-season, Rhodes went 62-306 and Addai 76-294.

    What does this tell us? Unless you have a superstar RB, and there are only a couple it in the league....

    Two running backs good.

    One running back to handle the entire load bad.
  8. DallasEast

    DallasEast Cowboys 24/7/365 Staff Member

    33,517 Messages
    8,336 Likes Received
    Good points. We don't have a superstar running back (unless it's buried deep within Jones/I know, but I can still hope). We do have two good, not great, but good backs. And we still haven't tapped their full potential yet.
  9. Chuck 54

    Chuck 54 Well-Known Member

    11,438 Messages
    2,181 Likes Received
    If Peterson dropped all the way to 20 or so, I might consider giving up a day 2 pick to move up and get him, but I have no interest in dealing any of our day 1 picks for him...zero.

    It's probably just my hatred for everything Oklahoma, but I don't think he's going to be a superstar in the NFL.
  10. Chuck 54

    Chuck 54 Well-Known Member

    11,438 Messages
    2,181 Likes Received
    That's crazy, imo...no way I'd give up two 1's for the guy.
  11. lostinomiya

    lostinomiya Member

    534 Messages
    0 Likes Received

    an interesting enough original post which was unfortunately met by the glib and rude thought police in the first few posts.

    if you are not interested in the post, move along, dont make the effort to post insults, go away.
  12. Jake0

    Jake0 Active Member

    639 Messages
    92 Likes Received
    I feel bad for bringing this thread back up, but this just intrigues me too much. Were you not the guy that had to take a leave of absence from the board for some stupidity you said at the end of last season?

    Betting your life would be ******** of course, but how about betting your e-life? If Peterson drops past 3 for whatever reason, you go and find yourself another cowboys forum to partake in. If he is taken top 3 I will do the same.

    ABQCOWBOY Moderator Staff Member

    41,339 Messages
    6,117 Likes Received

    Might be ******** but I'd be right there with HH. I just don't see it. He is too talented to drop. It would be interesting indeed if he did and nobody would be happier then I. He is the biggest wish in this draft for me but it's not even something I consider realistically. He's just not a guy we are ever going to see in the draft IMO.

Share This Page