If you had to choose only one to extend?

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Eskimo, Nov 12, 2012.

  1. Eskimo

    Eskimo Well-Known Member

    12,821 Messages
    496 Likes Received
    If your salary structure dictates that you could only extend one of Bruce Carter or Sean Lee, which one would you extend?

    My own choice would be Carter because he shows similar skills but more speed and explosiveness and his injury history is much less suggestive of weak connective tissue. I think Lee has now had four such injuries and has missed significant time with injury in all 3 of his years in the league.

    Right now I'd be thinking hard about inking Carter before he truly blows up - 5 years $35M sounds about right as an EXTENSION with $15M guaranteed. That may be enough future security for the player to get everyone's name on the line. The kid could blow out his knee in the next game and have to live off his second round bonus while trying to learn a trade.

    Once we have Carter in the fold I'd consider signing Lee to a smaller bonus deal with a lot of incentives based on production/health that could put him in the $9M/yr range if healthy and producing.
  2. Risen Star

    Risen Star Likes Collector Zone Supporter

    39,028 Messages
    46,931 Likes Received
    Yeah, Carter. Lee has been hurt too much.
  3. Sarge

    Sarge Red, White and brew... Staff Member

    24,771 Messages
    9,742 Likes Received
    I'd extend them both and get rid of Spencer.
  4. Star4Ever

    Star4Ever Well-Known Member

    7,023 Messages
    1,271 Likes Received
    Not an either or with me. Both. Any other move would be stupid on a level not yet seen.
  5. Hagman

    Hagman Put Niland and Green in the ROH

    1,274 Messages
    20 Likes Received
    Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding. We have a winner.
  6. dadymat

    dadymat I'm kind of a Big Deal

    6,022 Messages
    1 Likes Received
    it would be a devestating decision to have to make...but me, i keep Lee, if he stays healthy he could be IMO great on a historic level...HOF type player, plus the leadership element that this team has needed for years...while Carter is very good and may be great one day, players like Lee are rare
  7. AZ_Cowboys_Fan

    AZ_Cowboys_Fan Active Member

    592 Messages
    55 Likes Received
  8. Joshmil53

    Joshmil53 Well-Known Member

    2,565 Messages
    34 Likes Received
    If both showed signs of being consistently healthy, Carter.

    His athleticism for a MLB is otherwordly.
  9. M'Kevon

    M'Kevon A Love Supreme

    3,753 Messages
    683 Likes Received
    This. Why the hell is this an either/or choice?
  10. TheCoolFan

    TheCoolFan Well-Known Member

    8,808 Messages
    1,293 Likes Received
    Throw in Sensabaugh too and we've got a steal!
  11. RS12

    RS12 Well-Known Member

    21,725 Messages
    8,870 Likes Received
    Or Free, or Scandrick, or fill in the blank bad contract
  12. links18

    links18 Well-Known Member

    13,353 Messages
    4,914 Likes Received
    "Weak connective tissue"? Is that an actual disease entity?
  13. theogt

    theogt Surrealist Zone Supporter

    45,816 Messages
    5,733 Likes Received
    I'd have to go with Lee if only because he's shown he can do it over multiple seasons. I'd assume Bruce will only improve, but there are plenty of one season wonders in football (though usually not at the LB spot).

    PAINFROMUKRAINE Well-Known Member

    349 Messages
    315 Likes Received
    Lee is not a Rare Talent. He is Injury-Prone and does not deserve a Contract Extension unless it is VERY reasonable. Our defense has not missed a beat since his injury. He has played 3 years and he still cannot play a full season. Carter is a Beast who Thumps everybody who has the Ball. He is way better than I expected. Butch Davis boasted about Carter's Talent on Draft Day and Butch was not putting smoke up our butt. Great Draft Pick so far by Garrett because everybody knows "Jerry can't Pick a Blue Chip Talent if it smacked him in the Face".
  15. AZ_Cowboys_Fan

    AZ_Cowboys_Fan Active Member

    592 Messages
    55 Likes Received

    I understand what you're saying but the guy is not only a great player but he's a team leader. You do not let those types of guys go under any circumstances
  16. Risen Star

    Risen Star Likes Collector Zone Supporter

    39,028 Messages
    46,931 Likes Received
    How about Sensabaugh's tackle attempt on Brent Celek on the Eagles first pass of the game?

    That guy has to be one of the least physical safeties I've ever seen.
  17. blackbull

    blackbull Well-Known Member

    1,284 Messages
    206 Likes Received
    Peprah, a walk on free agent is a godsend. That speaks volumes about Gerald.
  18. blackbull

    blackbull Well-Known Member

    1,284 Messages
    206 Likes Received
    I wouldnt pay Lee until he proved he could stay healthy for a full year. Like someone said, the d hasn't fallen off without him.
  19. Hook'em#11

    Hook'em#11 Well-Known Member

    2,971 Messages
    365 Likes Received
  20. CanadianCowboysFan

    CanadianCowboysFan Lightning Rod

    17,861 Messages
    1,803 Likes Received
    yep, keep both of them

Share This Page