Is warner HOF material?

Discussion in 'NFL Zone' started by Tio, Aug 5, 2004.

  1. Tio

    Tio Armchair QB

    5,180 Messages
    49 Likes Received
    This topic made my head hurt. If you had the vote, would you vote kurt warner in the hof?
  2. Doomsday101

    Doomsday101 Well-Known Member

    85,812 Messages
    8,533 Likes Received
    No I don't think so, He did have a couple of great years but a couple of years in my opinion should not get you in the Hall Of Fame
  3. Rocco

    Rocco Cozy in Colo

    339 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    I don't think so. He had a couple of great years and then really nothing after that. Injuries killed him. To me, an extended period of greatness is necessary for HOF consideration..
  4. Yeagermeister

    Yeagermeister Active Member

    47,590 Messages
    17 Likes Received
    No....a two or three year run doesn't not make you a HOF'er unless you played for the 70's Steelers.
  5. Tio

    Tio Armchair QB

    5,180 Messages
    49 Likes Received
    Yah, but those few years were unbelievable...I guess not, but if the class is weak...maybe...
  6. joseephuss

    joseephuss Well-Known Member

    23,848 Messages
    2,540 Likes Received
    No.

    His career is incomplete at this point. When he was on, he was one of the best, but three great years is not a career.

    Heck, over the last two seasons, he has been outplayed by a drugged up Quincy Carter. :D (I am a big QC fan, so no one better get offended.)
  7. Double Trouble

    Double Trouble Well-Known Member

    8,496 Messages
    265 Likes Received
    I went back once and compared his 3 great years to other HOF QBs best 3 yrs, and few if any others stacked up to Warner's 99-01 seasons.

    But, IMO, 3 yrs just isn't enough. I think there's too many players getting in now. I think only the elite (the Reggie Whites, Emmitt Smiths, and Dan Marionos) should be in.

    For example, I love Darren Woodson, but again, IMO, he was never an elite player that should be in the HOF. He was a very good player and an integral part of the team of the 90s, but I think only a couple of players each year should get in.
  8. dbair1967

    dbair1967 Arch Defender

    30,783 Messages
    1 Likes Received
    This is a joke right?

    David
  9. Big D

    Big D Well-Known Member

    2,339 Messages
    161 Likes Received
    umm ..... No!
  10. blindzebra

    blindzebra Well-Known Member

    10,368 Messages
    1,877 Likes Received
    He falls in with Davis of Denver, great for a short time. It worked for Sayers when the number of players were less, but I think that there is too much competition to get in today.
  11. Danny White

    Danny White Winter is Coming

    12,352 Messages
    4 Likes Received
    Is there a Hall of Flashes in the Pan?

    Seriously, however, if he can somehow ressurect his career in NY, and put up another 4-5 years of solid numbers he might have a claim. I don't think that'll happen, however.
  12. kmp77

    kmp77 Active Member

    5,945 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    Hahahahahahaha...no! But I bet his wife will demand it and make a fuss over it.
  13. Chuck 54

    Chuck 54 Well-Known Member

    10,667 Messages
    1,233 Likes Received
    No way....he's not even close....he won't even make the ballot, imo.

    Now, let him make a come back, play 4-5 more years, turn the Giants around, keep Eli on the bench and win another SB or two? Then he's a candidate for sure....right now he was just the trigger man on the "greatest show on turf" with the RAMS.

    Name me a QB who couldn't be successful with the WR's and RB on the RAMS.
  14. Double Trouble

    Double Trouble Well-Known Member

    8,496 Messages
    265 Likes Received
    Quincy Carter. Chad Hutchinson. Clint Stoerner. Ryan Leaf.
  15. Yeagermeister

    Yeagermeister Active Member

    47,590 Messages
    17 Likes Received
    Tony Banks, Anthony Wright

    ummm I notice a pattern :D

Share This Page