Vic Carucci's Top 5 Defensive Ends

Discussion in 'Draft Zone' started by WoodysGirl, Mar 7, 2005.

  1. WoodysGirl

    WoodysGirl Everything is everything... Staff Member

    70,257 Messages
    11,658 Likes Received
    May have missed this posted, but I thought was interesting....
    (Feb. 23, 2005) -- One man's ranking of the top five defensive ends in the NFL draft:

    1. Erasmus James, Wisconsin

    Positives: Intensity, discipline, anticipation of snap, speed, variety of pass-rush moves, long arms, change-of-direction skills, closing burst to quarterback … Solid senior season erased doubts created by a hip injury that caused him to miss the 2003 season and put him in a position where he should be a top-10 choice.

    Negatives: Lower-body strength, holding his own at the point of attack vs. the run.

    2. David Pollack, Georgia

    Positives: Overall strength, quickness, agility, explosiveness, intensity, work ethic, change-of-direction skills, tackling … Although his lack of height (6-foot-2) is a bit of a concern, Pollack's incredible competitiveness and drive -- to go along with his other high-end qualities -- should put him somewhere in the middle of the first round.

    Negatives: Height, speed, less-than-ideal arm length.

    3. Dan Cody, Oklahoma

    Positives: Anticipation of snap, explosiveness, toughness, leverage vs. the run, upper-body strength, closing burst to quarterback, work ethic … Shows enough playmaking promise to be selected in the bottom half of the first round by a team willing to wait at least a year before he is ready to start.

    Negatives: Lower-body strength, change-of-direction skills.

    4. Shaun Cody, USC

    Positives: Upper-body strength, change-of-direction skills, anticipation of snap, instincts, intensity, inside pass-rushing ability, use of height (6-4) to knock down passes … Figures to be selected in the bottom half of the first round by a team with a defensive scheme that could take full advantage of the strong contribution he can make as an inside pass rusher.

    Negatives: Outside speed, weight (292 pounds) makes him a little too small to play tackle (his college position) and a little too large to be a highly effective end.

    5. Matt Roth, Iowa

    Positives: Power, intensity, aggressiveness, use of hands, pursuit, tackling, instincts … Solid enough player to be a late first-round pick.

    Negatives: Lower-body strength, speed.
  2. Cowboy from New York

    Cowboy from New York Well-Known Member

    1,744 Messages
    76 Likes Received
    How is Marcus Spears not included on his list?
  3. Portland Fanatic

    Portland Fanatic Active Member

    4,459 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    I agree...major oversight.
  4. ddh33

    ddh33 Active Member

    4,934 Messages
    2 Likes Received
    The whole list kind of surprises me. I would like to see Gil Brandt's.

Share This Page