PFW'S TE ratings. (something wrong here)

Discussion in 'NFL Zone' started by windward, Jun 11, 2005.

  1. windward

    windward NFL Historian

    16,568 Messages
    1,990 Likes Received
    I picked up a copy of Pro football weekly's nfl preview mag and their Tight end ratings seem somewhat skewed:
    1.Tony Gonzalez
    2.Alge Crumpler
    3.Jeremy Shockey (!)
    4. Antonio Gates
    5.Todd Heap
    6.Randy McMichael
    7. Bubba Franks
    8. Jim Kleinsasser (he of the one game played last season)
    9. Jason Witten
    10. Marcus Pollard

    At minimum, Jason should be no lower than fourth on the list.
  2. EveryoneElse

    EveryoneElse Active Member

    3,877 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    I'd say no lower than 6th on that list. Who cares tho? Let em rank him low. Pretty soon he'll be #1 on that list and they'll feel stupid.
  3. big dog cowboy

    big dog cowboy THE BIG DOG Staff Member

    67,975 Messages
    24,366 Likes Received
    While that is somewhat disappointing, it's not surprising either. Mediots. Consider the source. We know he is gonna rock!
  4. Rockytop6

    Rockytop6 Well-Known Member

    2,076 Messages
    84 Likes Received
    Why should anybody be surprised? Witten is a Cowboy!
  5. HanfordDixon

    HanfordDixon Please, Call Me Shirley

    306 Messages
    37 Likes Received
    Actually not true. The Cowboys are ranked pretty high in PFW.
  6. dargonking999

    dargonking999 DKRandom

    11,935 Messages
    396 Likes Received
    you either love them or hate them, and it looks like they hate them
  7. Reed

    Reed New Member

    544 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    In Yahoo fantasy rankings, JJ is ranked 12th overall, and Witten is the second highest rated TE after Gonzalez.
  8. Future

    Future Intramural Legend

    17,914 Messages
    3,069 Likes Received
    How is Shockey so high? He cant even catch the ball. I think Gates is too high, right for last year, but he will maybe be half as good this year. Hes more or less a glorified reciever...I think that this year teams will just put a LB under and safety over him and he wont be nearly as effective.
  9. AdamJT13

    AdamJT13 Salary Cap Analyst

    16,225 Messages
    3,614 Likes Received
    Gates' rating notwithstanding, Pro Football Weekly's rankings are always skewed away from players who are early in their careers. Very few players in their second or third seasons are even rated, let alone rated highly.
  10. percyhoward

    percyhoward Research Tool

    12,745 Messages
    12,076 Likes Received
    I like it. I hope Witten tapes it up in his locker, and reads it before every game of his 1,000-yard season.
  11. stag hunter

    stag hunter Hater

    603 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    My list:

    1.Tony Gonzalez
    2.Alge Crumpler
    3.Todd Heap
    4. Antonio Gates
    5. Jason Witten
    6. Marcus Pollard
    7. Jeremy Shockey
    8. Randy McMichael
    9. Bubba Franks
    10. Jim Kleinsasser

    Gates is the real deal
  12. Juke99

    Juke99 ...Abbey someone

    22,271 Messages
    4 Likes Received
    One look at where they have Shockey rated and you know there is zero crediblity...
  13. Billy Bullocks

    Billy Bullocks Active Member

    4,096 Messages
    21 Likes Received
    Gates is pretty nasty. Sure he's a glorified WR, but he can play. With LT in the backfield, Vincent Jackson and McCardell, they wont be able to key in on him so easily. San Diego is good, but I dont see them going 12-4 again. Gates is the next Tony Gonzalez.

    I agree that Shockey is too high though...he's still banking on that very impressive rookie year. He's getting a potential pass, because when he's on, he is scary.
  14. silver

    silver Well-Known Member

    6,416 Messages
    1,139 Likes Received
    i stopped caring about PFW since Joel Bauchbaum (sp) passed away. Nowadays it's all New York New York for those guys.
  15. HanfordDixon

    HanfordDixon Please, Call Me Shirley

    306 Messages
    37 Likes Received
    Adam makes a good point. PFW ratings are the most intelligent out there. The editors take the position that anybody with one great year is downgraded. As long as they're consistent I don't have a problem with it. Newman is rated 13th, while Sheppard is rated 22nd or thereabouts. Dallas players are rated consistently well across the board because we have veteran players. Allen/Rivera are both in the top 10 at gaurd. Glover is 3rd at DT I believe. There's no bias against the Cowboys. With another good year, I would bet that Witten is in the top 5.
  16. burmafrd

    burmafrd Benched

    43,820 Messages
    3,379 Likes Received
    Shockey's NUMBERS were not that much off from his rookie year- but he was nowhere near the threat he was then. And he dropped way too many. Now of course he had half the season with a rook QB, but he still did not impress me. He is not even top 10 in my book.
  17. tyke1doe

    tyke1doe Well-Known Member

    33,995 Messages
    11,184 Likes Received
    Has any other player lived off one year of hype like Shockey? :eek:
  18. Hostile

    Hostile The Duke

    119,480 Messages
    4,198 Likes Received
    Well his agent did say they wanted him to be the male version of Anna Kournikova. He's got the all hype down.

    Both have skills, but neither seems to reach their potential.

    I love calling him Anna Shockey.
  19. cowboygolfer

    cowboygolfer New Member

    232 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    I think with another year under Witten like last, and all these polls will have recognize him. Heck they are already showing him breaking into the top groups after his rookie season.

    He did play better than many ahead of him on that list, but he has to do it again, and again, and again.

    But just wait and see if he doesn't, my money is on him for a long time.
  20. 5 Super Bowls

    5 Super Bowls Member

    415 Messages
    0 Likes Received
    I'd like to Shockey Anna.

Share This Page