These threads counter-productive as they create strife between those who are biased for either of these QBs. As you can tell my by username that Troy is my favorite player. Both QB's have/had their strengths and weaknesses...just as Montana and Young did. The rings are a strong component of greatness, but where do those such as Marino and Tarkenton rank? I think we are very fortunate to have had three All-World QB's within the fifty or so years that the team has been around. I'm not going to argue who is better. I'd take Aikman as of today because of, not only the rings, but also his ball security.