Hindsight is always 20/20, haven't mentioned what draft picks you are even talking about yet, if they are starting for lack of a better option, or if they are even above average if they are starting for their respective teams. To answer your question, would I rather have the 3 potential average starters or one potential all-pro, I'll take the all-pro at a premium position. I assume if your getting 3 players in the first 2 rounds, your talking about some tradedown where you don't even know if the teams were interested in trading with you or how it would've affected where players you want would've been available. Problem is, alot of times people look at draft results without considering what happens during a draft. You can't just move anywhere you want and get exactly which player you want at the slot you want. But its alot easier to do that in hindsight though.