Okay, first of all I said "AS OF RIGHT NOW". 5 touchdowns and 8 Interceptions is not a top 10 QB. Second...Um...The Giants secondary are the ones who made Rex Grossman look like an elite QB, not ours. We beat Washington both times last year, the Giants did not. Clearly, I do not know what I'm talking about. Also, like I said...THE GIANTS WENT 9-7 LAST YEAR. How on earth does that translate into a far superior TEAM than Dallas? They won 1 (one) more game than we did and it just so happened to be the one that mattered the most. Playing your best football when the most is on the line matters to me; it might not matter to you and it might not be your measuring stick of what makes a good QB but to me, it matters. Troy Aikman NEVER put up big numbers, he only threw for 20 or more TDs in a season ONCE! Yes he had Emmitt to throw hand the ball off to, but he did not put up superstar numbers by any means. Troy, however, was lights out in the postseason. He won went it mattered the most and so does Eli.