Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Lazyking, Oct 5, 2012.
+ Manning, + Schuab
Top 5 just to piss off some people.
Which Manning? Eli has an argument, but Peyton hasn't really looked good at all since 2010. Schuab is not even on the same planet as Romo. Schuab has the benefit of the best run game and defense. Tony doesn't.
He's top 10. And I don't believe he's 10, 9 or 8. So...Top 7.
Guys I would definitely put over Romo are (in no particular order) Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Peyton, Ben, Eli... Guys I would put in Romo's league are Rivers, Stafford, Ryan... I would put Romo above Flacco, Vick and some others... So that would make him a #7-10 QB. And that isn't just this year. He's always been a 7-10 QB. Only homers would have him top 5.
Romo shouldnt break the top 10. There are rookies who are playing better than him and he is behind Cutler.
No, Cutler has the mentality of a child and he's even more prone to mistakes then Romo imo .I also would say Tony is physically tougher then him too..
And the question disregards rookies if you read my op.
Do you honestly expect anyone to take your opinion seriously with such a ridiculous comment?
6. Big Ben
7. Matt Ryan
8. Tony Romo
9. Matt Stafford
10. Philip Rivers
I'll get some grief for putting Ryan above Tony but I am going on play as of today. Matt Ryan is absolutely looking like he will be a top QB for the rest of his career.
I'd put him in the top 5-7 range.
You will most likely get grief for Ryan over Romo. However, If I could redo my list I would rank Ryan over Romo as well.
What has Ryan done to be ranked over Romo? Not a damn thing. He doesn't even have a playoff win to his name. At least Romo has that. He's played better through four games so what? It's still early and Ryan at least has a consistent run game and an NFL caliber offensive line. Oh and receivers who aren't mentally incompetent.
I'd have to give Ryan the year to put him over Romo.. no playoff win though and I'd keep him below esp since they should probably only lose to two teams in the NFC.
3. Manning, Eli
5. Manning, Peyton
Even as recently as the middle of last season, I wouldn't have considered putting Flacco ahead of Romo. But Flacco has now shown me some darn impressive passing acumen, and so his playoff resume gives him the edge (perhaps not fair because he gets the Ravens D, but it is what it is).
No grief from me, Ryan is lighting it up this year. I honestly won't be surprised if he's in the MVP running.
Against 4 good teams, too.
Broncos - speak for self
Chargers - ^
Panthers - Cam, division
Chiefs probably the only "easy" one.
Panthers and Chiefs are good since when? :laugh2:
The Chargers haven't made the playoffs the last few years. The only good team is Denver. Like I said its still way too early, he hasn't won a single playoff game in his career, and he has a far superior and more consistent supporting cast than Tony does. There's no way in hell Matt Ryan is a better football player than Tony Romo.
Ryan is clearly playing better than Romo as of right now. Even with the o-line struggles, it's fair to admit that Ryan is better this season.