Is this even a question? Like really? It's Peyton and it's not even close at all. Way more consistent. Eli has not done anything other than the 2 Super Bowl runs. Peyton has also been to 2 Super Bowls but he also didn't disappear in his other seasons. He consistently had his team a contender and one of the best in the league. Eli can't say that. When I think of best QBs in the league, Eli doesn't even enter my mind.