He looked really bad in the big moments. The philly game was my breaking point. Forget the turds he laid against New Orleans, NYJ, Buffalo, and NE. He couldn't lead this team to a single TD against a team he torched the previous month. What was the difference? Its a mental thing and you can't change that impulse to shrink in the big moments. Qbs like Montana and Brady weren't the most physically gifted, but they played better in the big moments when a single play can win the game. Mahomes has that quality. Wilson has it. Rodgers has it. Brees has it. Dak does not.
I know we have no better option in 2020, but for god sake don't marry the team to him for the next 5 years paying him as if he was among those guys. He doesn't deserve to be a top 5 paid Qb.