Hypothetical Dak Trade To Dolphins

MyFairLady

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,373
Reaction score
6,518
On the Break they discussed Dak to Dolphins for Dolphins 2 first round picks this year and Tua for Dak. I believe one of the picks is the third overall. Of course they would not do the trade because they are all Dak Homer's pulling the Jerry company line. I happen to know a group of Dolphins fans so I asked them if they would do it. They did not seem very high on Tua and actually said they would do it. Perhaps Dak is valued higher by other fan bases than ours. I definitely found it interesting and thought I would share it. Personally I do not know enough about Tua but can you imagine if he was serviceable. You would get a young QB on the cheap. You could pick 3 times this year in the first round and you could spend Daks 40 million on free agents. IMHO this is how you build a winner. Dak is very good but IMHO he is not untouchable like a Mahomes or Rodgers.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
66,924
Reaction score
84,287
On the Break they discussed Dak to Dolphins for Dolphins 2 first round picks this year and Tua for Dak. I believe one of the picks is the third overall. Of course they would not do the trade because they are all Dak Homer's pulling the Jerry company line. I happen to know a group of Dolphins fans so I asked them if they would do it. They did not seem very high on Tua and actually said they would do it. Perhaps Dak is valued higher by other fan bases than ours. I definitely found it interesting and thought I would share it. Personally I do not know enough about Tua but can you imagine if he was serviceable. You would get a young QB on the cheap. You could pick 3 times this year in the first round and you could spend Daks 40 million on free agents. IMHO this is how you build a winner. Dak is very good but IMHO he is not untouchable like a Mahomes or Rodgers.


I’d do it in a second.

In fact.. I mentioned it after the season and my thread was moved.

https://cowboyszone.com/threads/trade-dak-for-tua.471688/
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
74,177
Reaction score
69,136
So I’d actually do this.
But I understand why some smart people wouldn’t. When you have a quarterback you don’t trade him. You just don’t. I’m a guy that likes having draft picks. But I also think it’s stupid to trade a quarterback if you think you have one....
 

Future

Intramural Legend
Messages
27,566
Reaction score
14,714
On the Break they discussed Dak to Dolphins for Dolphins 2 first round picks this year and Tua for Dak. I believe one of the picks is the third overall. Of course they would not do the trade because they are all Dak Homer's pulling the Jerry company line. I happen to know a group of Dolphins fans so I asked them if they would do it. They did not seem very high on Tua and actually said they would do it. Perhaps Dak is valued higher by other fan bases than ours. I definitely found it interesting and thought I would share it. Personally I do not know enough about Tua but can you imagine if he was serviceable. You would get a young QB on the cheap. You could pick 3 times this year in the first round and you could spend Daks 40 million on free agents. IMHO this is how you build a winner. Dak is very good but IMHO he is not untouchable like a Mahomes or Rodgers.
DUHHHHHH

Cowboys fans are the only group of people who don't think he's elite.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
66,924
Reaction score
84,287
There are Dolphins teammates who don't think Tua can play. They are very unimpressed.

Dak isn't going anywhere.

I mean.. Players thought Josh Allen wasn’t good too.

Tua is going to be fine.

30 TDs and 9 picks like Dak would be no problem for him and he’s a much more gifted passer.

Easy trade.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
66,924
Reaction score
84,287
DUHHHHHH

Cowboys fans are the only group of people who don't think he's elite.


I never see other fans or commentators thinking he’s elite.

You may get the guy that says you have to pay him but most acknowledge what he is as a player. He’s a standard for the QB position. About like Kirk Cousins.
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,563
Reaction score
12,263
On the Break they discussed Dak to Dolphins for Dolphins 2 first round picks this year and Tua for Dak. I believe one of the picks is the third overall. Of course they would not do the trade because they are all Dak Homer's pulling the Jerry company line. I happen to know a group of Dolphins fans so I asked them if they would do it. They did not seem very high on Tua and actually said they would do it. Perhaps Dak is valued higher by other fan bases than ours. I definitely found it interesting and thought I would share it. Personally I do not know enough about Tua but can you imagine if he was serviceable. You would get a young QB on the cheap. You could pick 3 times this year in the first round and you could spend Daks 40 million on free agents. IMHO this is how you build a winner. Dak is very good but IMHO he is not untouchable like a Mahomes or Rodgers.

No
 

Hardline

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,657
Reaction score
36,182
Having the Dolphins 3rd overall pick in the draft would get you Zack Wilson or Justin Fields regardless if Tua is involved in the trade at all.
With that other Dolphins first round pick at 18 you could possibly get Jaycee Horn or Christian Barmore.

I would just consider Tua as extra bonus.

I would pull the trigger on this deal in a heartbeat.
 
Top