Fired as an NFL HC - what would you do?

goshan

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,656
Reaction score
888
Got fired as an NFL head coach? The way you approach your next job opportunity will determine if you ever get another head job again.

McCarthy. Fired from GB. Rogers said he was an idiot. Sat out a year. Re-invented his personal brand by saying he hung out in his barn, watched every single game, and had a renewed focus on analytics and modern football. Hired as HC of Dallas Cowboys.

Quinn is run out of atlanta. Blown leads. Loser. Takes D-coordinator job at Dallas. Dallas D improves greatly, and he is one of the hottest HC options. Followed the McCarthy script - re-invented his personal brand after getting fired based upon 'studying himself' and re-tooling his defensive thinking to be far beyond the ''legion of boom'

Garret run out of Dallas. Mr 500 but overall his reputation was ok. Takes O-coordinator job for Giants. O is terrible. Gets fired. He will never get a head job again and probably not an OC job. Should he have sat out a year and re-invented his thinking and personal brand? I think he should have. Even though I think he sucks, I think its 50/50 he would have gotten a HC opportunity if he would have sat out a year and created a 'computer and stats football lab' in his basement and re-packaged himself in a fresh way. He is way too stubborn to do that tho...

Of all the coaches who just got fired, what should they do? Take coordinator jobs? Obviously it's case by case. But I think you have to think hard about sitting out and creating a new story about urself, especially if you have had enough success as a HC.

What would you do?
 
Last edited:

RoboQB

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,604
Reaction score
9,659
Wow! Never get a head job again!?! Ever?
Poor Garrett.
 

jchap

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
Reaction score
1,809
giphy.gif
 

Hardline

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,657
Reaction score
36,180
Hope a Division I college team makes me an offer.
Take the job and make just as much money as an NFL coach.
 

CowboysDrew

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,406
Reaction score
5,688
I mean, me? I'd retire. The mental pressure and stress of a HC job isn't for me.

But if I didn't want to do that and it was, yeah, it'd be coaching rehab or a step down. If an NFL coach can recruit, college could be calling.

If I were Garrett I'd go back to his old mentor Saban and get into one of his "advisor" slots where he's rehabbing fired coaches. I think with the further tutelage of Nick Garrett's process might actually work in college as opposed to the pros. He was always tied to the concept of beat your man with superior talent, and that's what college ball is all about, but who knows.

But yeah "rehab" seems to be the answer in most cases. For a few others it might be just sticking to what you do well, see Wade Phillips.
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
56,526
Reaction score
34,778
Your first job as an NFL head coach may determine if you’ll ever get a second chance. No assurances that if you fail your first time around that you’ll ever get another opportunity. Some don’t and end up going back to being a coordinator or take a job with a network in the studio or in the broadcasting booth.
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,060
Reaction score
25,885
What I WOULDN’T do is go to a place with no QB in place.

You have two years to win now as a HC.

I have no idea if it's impatience, fan pressure in the age of instant gratification, or what....

Even if you do well in your first year and play a fourth place schedule, and inspire your team to an upset or two, jeez you'd better improve on that in year two or teams seem to find it best to move on.

I guess that's the best way to sell hope and that's kind of what it's about....

I mean, it may have been time for a team like Minnesota to go in a different direction, but it's going to take devine intervention more so than a guy like Kellen Moore to win with Kirk Cousins.
 

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
31,869
Reaction score
36,326
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Got fired as an NFL head coach? The way you approach your next job opportunity will determine if you ever get another head job again.

McCarthy. Fired from GB. Rogers said he was an idiot. Sat out a year. Re-invented his personal brand by saying he hung out in his barn, watched every single game, and had a renewed focus on analytics and modern football. Hired as HC of Dallas Cowboys.

Quinn is run out of atlanta. Blown leads. Loser. Takes D-coordinator job at Dallas. Dallas D improves greatly, and he is one of the hottest HC options. Followed the McCarthy script - re-invented his personal brand after getting fired based upon 'studying himself' and re-tooling his defensive thinking to be far beyond the ''legion of boom'

Garret run out of Dallas. Mr 500 but overall his reputation was ok. Takes O-coordinator job for Giants. O is terrible. Gets fired. He will never get a head job again and probably not an OC job. Should he have sat out a year and re-invented his thinking and personal brand? I think he should have. Even though I think he sucks, I think its 50/50 he would have gotten a HC opportunity if he would have sat out a year and created a 'computer and stats football lab' in his basement and re-packaged himself in a fresh way. He is way too stubborn to do that tho...

Of all the coaches who just got fired, what should they do? Take coordinator jobs? Obviously it's case by case. But I think you have to think hard about sitting out and creating a new story about urself, especially if you have had enough success as a HC.

What would you do?
Quinn didnt reinvent himself. He is running the same scheme he has always run. He just has better talent
 
Top