When does Philbin get the axe?

[TheDude]

All This coaching talk is somewhat white noise.

However, to me, the unit that objectively underperformed as the season went on was the oline.

Yes, the lead RB is about as agile as Mr Creosote. Yes th QB holds the ball too long sometimes. yes the C and RG may be below avg.

That said, therr were too many missed blitz pickups, stunt confusion, and holding calls. I mention the holding callas as Green Bay was supposed to be innovative in their techniques to hold and keep it uncalled. This was a major topic after 2014 and 2016 playoffs. Philbin wasn't even there for that, though

The line seems talented enough, but just looked out of sorts too often. Philbin seems to be a McCarthy family member, otherwise I don't see anything he has done since 2011 that warrants retaining him. He has pretty much washed out everywhere

 

[Risen Star]

A thousand percent this. He has to go. It should have happened already.

 

[Denim Chicken]

Should have already been gone.

Mike Munchak is the popular name for a replacement.

 

[Aven8]

It’s needs to happen and the new Oline coach is hopefully a run game coordinator as well

 

[Coogiguy03]

WE'RE HAPPY WITH THE GUYS WE HAVE

 

[AKATheRake]

Should have already been gone.

Mike Munchak is the popular name for a replacement.

We get that guy, then Philbin be gone. Otherwise get him a draft pick to develop. CW leaving means less Carrot guys.

 

[glimmerman]

Dang you. I saw the title and thought it said he got the axe. Don’t drink during the work week but was going to party tonight..

 

[Aven8]

I thought he coached well last year considering the whole Oline got hurt. This year it fell apart.

 

[BrAinPaiNt]

Wish they would let him go but I doubt they will.
Just like they kept Greg the maybe all year when it was clear he had issues.

 

[G2]

Monday.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Damn maybe I dreamed this happen. I thought he already was fired lol.

 

[quickccc]

Should have already been gone.

Mike Munchak is the popular name for a replacement.

OL coaches in consideration:

- Munchak - well reknown OL coach

- Marc Columbo - team finished 2nd in NFL is Fewest sacks allowed and 5th in NFL in rushing in 2019 his last year in Dallas. ...

- James Campen (McCarthy's ex-Packer OL coach) ... currently pending Houston Texans next coaching staff. ..

But i'd really like to get that OC role replaced and re-handled as well.

 

[75boyz]

All This coaching talk is somewhat white noise.

However, to me, the unit that objectively underperformed as the season went on was the oline.

Yes, the lead RB is about as agile as Mr Creosote. Yes th QB holds the ball too long sometimes. yes the C and RG may be below avg.

That said, therr were too many missed blitz pickups, stunt confusion, and holding calls. I mention the holding callas as Green Bay was supposed to be innovative in their techniques to hold and keep it uncalled. This was a major topic after 2014 and 2016 playoffs. Philbin wasn't even there for that, though

The line seems talented enough, but just looked out of sorts too often. Philbin seems to be a McCarthy family member, otherwise I don't see anything he has done since 2011 that warrants retaining him. He has pretty much washed out everywhere

Excellent post. The 2021 list of reasons for second half decline is definitely to include this group.
Coaching definitely matters.

 

[TheDude]

I thought he coached well last year considering the whole Oline got hurt. This year it fell apart.

I throw away 2020. We were 6-10. No 1000yd rusher, got Dalton killed, started DiNucci once, Gilbert once. Everyone got a mulligan for 2020.

However, this year was as bad as Nolan early last year...at full strength

 

[Gaede]

He needs to go. The OL cratered when it had all its starters healthy. There's no excuse.

 

[ClappingCarrot]

This is the problem you encounter when you hire a bunch of your buddies.

Cowboys have a huge "my guy" problem, and this is another example.

 

[TheDude]

OL coaches in consideration:

- Munchak - well reknown OL coach

- Marc Columbo - team finished 2nd in NFL is Fewest sacks allowed and 5th in NFL in rushing in 2019 his last year in Dallas. ...

- James Campen (McCarthy's ex-Packer OL coach) ... currently pending Houston Texans next coaching staff. ..

But i'd really like to get that OC role replaced and re-handled as well.

Munchak is the get, but I do like the fact that Columbo won't hesitate to tombstone piledrive someone on a moments notice...Dallas included

 

[glimmerman]

OL coaches in consideration:

- Munchak - well reknown OL coach

- Marc Columbo - team finished 2nd in NFL is Fewest sacks allowed and 5th in NFL in rushing in 2019 his last year in Dallas. ...

- James Campen (McCarthy's ex-Packer OL coach) ... currently pending Houston Texans next coaching staff. ..

But i'd really like to get that OC role replaced and re-handled as well.

Would like to see Colombo. He knows the power blocking and scheme we used before that had us running the ball.. And he brings fire and nasty..

 

[exciter]

All This coaching talk is somewhat white noise.

However, to me, the unit that objectively underperformed as the season went on was the oline.

Yes, the lead RB is about as agile as Mr Creosote. Yes th QB holds the ball too long sometimes. yes the C and RG may be below avg.

That said, therr were too many missed blitz pickups, stunt confusion, and holding calls. I mention the holding callas as Green Bay was supposed to be innovative in their techniques to hold and keep it uncalled. This was a major topic after 2014 and 2016 playoffs. Philbin wasn't even there for that, though

The line seems talented enough, but just looked out of sorts too often. Philbin seems to be a McCarthy family member, otherwise I don't see anything he has done since 2011 that warrants retaining him. He has pretty much washed out everywhere

Jerry is in negotiations to have a gullitine constructed as we type. It’s a process!!!

 

[TheDude]

Jerry is in negotiations to have a gullitine constructed as we type. It’s a process!!!

That would boost ratings