How would you rank Meredith, Staubach, White, Aikman, Romo?

Zordon

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,126
Reaction score
45,614
After last week's performance, I moved Romo up on spot.

1. Staubach
2. Aikman
3. White
4. Romo
5. Meredith
 

SDCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,561
Reaction score
22,477
It depends what the rank is for. In terms of pure talent: Romo>Staubach>Aikman>White>Meredith. If you're going to factor in team accomplishments into equation: Staubach>Aikman>Romo...and White/Meredith are interchangeable.
 

Lodeus

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,625
Reaction score
2,119
It depends what the rank is for. In terms of pure talent: Romo>Staubach>Aikman>White>Meredith. If you're going to factor in team accomplishments into equation: Staubach>Aikman>Romo...and White/Meredith are interchangeable.

Seems about right.
 

Gameover

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,649
Reaction score
3,389
1. Aikman don't like him but he is the third greatest post season QB of all time.

2. Staubach a few years ago I watched that classic steelers SB and Staubach made a couple of decisions that would've gotten Quincy carter run out of town.

3. Meredith Only because the great randy galloway has often said Meredith is the best QB the cowboys have ever had.

4. White the QB I grew up with. Took one of the greatest moments in sports history to keep him from going to the SB.

5. Pelluer I always felt he got a raw deal. What a talent!

Honorable mention: Quincy carter - all he did was win games!
 

CanadianCowboysFan

Lightning Rod
Messages
24,459
Reaction score
7,525
1. Aikman don't like him but he is the third greatest post season QB of all time.

2. Staubach a few years ago I watched that classic steelers SB and Staubach made a couple of decisions that would've gotten Quincy carter run out of town.

3. Meredith Only because the great randy galloway has often said Meredith is the best QB the cowboys have ever had.

4. White the QB I grew up with. Took one of the greatest moments in sports history to keep him from going to the SB.

5. Pelluer I always felt he got a raw deal. What a talent!

Honorable mention: Quincy carter - all he did was win games!

imagine if Romo fumbled like White did to end the game?
 

SDCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,561
Reaction score
22,477
1. Aikman don't like him but he is the third greatest post season QB of all time.

2. Staubach a few years ago I watched that classic steelers SB and Staubach made a couple of decisions that would've gotten Quincy carter run out of town.

3. Meredith Only because the great randy galloway has often said Meredith is the best QB the cowboys have ever had.

4. White the QB I grew up with. Took one of the greatest moments in sports history to keep him from going to the SB.

5. Pelluer I always felt he got a raw deal. What a talent!

Honorable mention: Quincy carter - all he did was win games!

So you don't like Aikman and you don't even have Romo top 5? ROFL.....
 

NYFan

New Member
Messages
15
Reaction score
4
Based on talent-
1) Romo
2) White
3) Staubach
4) Aikman
5) Meredith

Romo either owns or will own every Cowboys passing record when he's done. Danny White was a great QB that beat most of Staubach's records but is labeled like Romo. Staubach was named Captain Comeback for a reason and our best running QB. Aikman never put up great numbers but his accuracy was second to none and he had more help than any other QB. Aikman teams had the #1 offense with the help of the NFL's leading rusher Emmitt Smith, and the #1 Defense, so a lot of QB's could have played on that team and did ok.
 
Top