Have the Browns passed the Cowboys in roster talent?

jrumann59 · Mar 14, 2019

The browns have had tons of talent, all of it was on the field and less than zero on the sidelines.

Stash · Mar 14, 2019

Bobhaze said:
In the midst of the offseason, and even before the 2019 draft, the Cleveland Browns are emerging as a serious contender in the AFC for 2019. I’m not a big Odell Beckham fan but I recognize the guy has talent and the Browns trade to get him has certainly raised some eyebrows.

And the Browns should have a lot of talent. When you colossally suck for over a decade you have a chance to add some talent in the draft.

So here’s my question Cowboys fans....have the brownies passed us in the chase for NFL talent? If we matched up with them now, who would have the edge? Are the Browns closer to a SB than Dallas? I’m not going to do every position- just the positions we are looking at locking up long term as our top talent compared to the Browns.

Let’s look at the Browns top talent compared to ours:
Position Which team has the edge?
QB- Baker Mayfield vs. Dak Prescott (Cle)
RB- Nick Chubb vs. Zeke Elliott. (Dal)
WR- Odell Jr. vs Amari Cooper. ( Cle? Push?)
Pass Rusher-Miles Garrett vs Tank Lawrence (Push?)

So what say you Cowboys fans....are the Browns passing us in talent?

I think we might have a significant edge at linebacker and a few offensive line spots, but overall?

Yeh, I'd have to say that I think the Browns have more talent right now overall.

That hurts to say.

Falco78 · Mar 14, 2019

The Natural said:
They have better RB depth, better receivers, and better tight end.

We have a better QB, better starting RB, better LB, better secondary so I'd say we have a strong edge over them

Stash · Mar 14, 2019

LatinMind said:
QB Dallas
RB Dallas
WR browns, but with baker? idk
TE Dallas
OL Dallas
DL Dallas was top 10 sacks and top 3 vs the rush
LB not even a matchup
CBS dallas
S Browns.

get over the shiney new toy, this much turnover this team is going to be a mess this yr.

Tell me more about "Dallas being top 10 in sacks" and "top 3 vs rush"?

The Natural · Mar 14, 2019

Falco78 said:
We have a better QB, better starting RB, better LB, better secondary so I'd say we have a strong edge over them

I'd say it's a homer's perspective to think we have a strong edge in collective talent over the Browns.

Diehardblues · Mar 14, 2019

The Natural said:
I'd say it's a homer's perspective to think we have a strong edge in collective talent over the Browns.

Since when do we look to the cheerleaders to provide an accurate analysis?

Diehardblues · Mar 14, 2019

Browns went from 25-1 to 14-1 odds to win Super Bowl.

Cowboys are 20-1.

fansince68 · Mar 14, 2019

The Browns ownership seem to have a better focus on football not conquering the profit margins of the world. Coaching is an overall tie.

MichaelWinicki · Mar 14, 2019

The Browns offensive line is not good. And their linebackers do not compare to those on the Cowboys.

MichaelWinicki · Mar 14, 2019

fansince68 said:
The Browns ownership seem to have a better focus on football not conquering the profit margins of the world. Coaching is an overall tie.

The Browns have been a horribly mismanaged team up to this point... One of the worst in the NFL which also "rewarded" them for their incompetence.

I'd wait for the season to play out before I'd go framing the Browns as the model franchise.

Bowdown27 · Mar 14, 2019

Bobhaze said:
Thread didn’t say we didn’t have any talent or incapable of winning. It was just a question- do the browns have more talent on their roster than us?

And answer I believe is no.

glimmerman · Mar 14, 2019

Look at how many high first round picks they have had in the last 150 years. They should.

LatinMind · Mar 14, 2019

stasheroo said:
Tell me more about "Dallas being top 10 in sacks" and "top 3 vs rush"?

Tied for 8th in sacks'
sorry they were 5th vs the run.

run for the hills theyre bad

Dre11 · Mar 14, 2019

coult44 said:
I never thought I'd see the day when Cowboys fans were good with moral victories. Satisfied with winning seasons, or division titles. The things that we used to crucify Commander, Eagle, and Giants fans for when they'd throw those types of achievements up when we were winning REAL Championships. It's a sad day.

That's not the point, YOU said they had no more success than Cleveland, and that's asinine and ridiculous to say

Stash · Mar 14, 2019

LatinMind said:
Tied for 8th in sacks'
sorry they were 5th vs the run.

run for the hills theyre bad

Yes. You stated two things that were untrue. Way to be accountable.

kento40 · Mar 14, 2019

Cowboysheelsreds053 said:
WOW! Never thought about that, makes it even worse.

But, I thought we were better than the Pats somehow? I know I read that somewhere.

conner01 · Mar 14, 2019

Bobhaze said:
In the midst of the offseason, and even before the 2019 draft, the Cleveland Browns are emerging as a serious contender in the AFC for 2019. I’m not a big Odell Beckham fan but I recognize the guy has talent and the Browns trade to get him has certainly raised some eyebrows.

And the Browns should have a lot of talent. When you colossally suck for over a decade you have a chance to add some talent in the draft.

So here’s my question Cowboys fans....have the brownies passed us in the chase for NFL talent? If we matched up with them now, who would have the edge? Are the Browns closer to a SB than Dallas? I’m not going to do every position- just the positions we are looking at locking up long term as our top talent compared to the Browns.

Let’s look at the Browns top talent compared to ours:
Position Which team has the edge?
QB- Baker Mayfield vs. Dak Prescott (Cle)
RB- Nick Chubb vs. Zeke Elliott. (Dal)
WR- Odell Jr. vs Amari Cooper. ( Cle? Push?)
Pass Rusher-Miles Garrett vs Tank Lawrence (Push?)

So what say you Cowboys fans....are the Browns passing us in talent?

They may have the most complete roster in the league
If they don’t make the playoffs it won’t be because of the talent they have

Verdict · Mar 14, 2019

xwalker said:
See the Giants the year they gave out over 200M in contracts to Vernon and others. They appeared to be stacked with talent.

It turns out a roster full of big names often doesn't make for a great team.

That's true but they did gel pretty good for that one year before the wheels fell off. I think Eli is the biggest rusty wheel.

PJTHEDOORS · Mar 14, 2019

Bobhaze said:
In the midst of the offseason, and even before the 2019 draft, the Cleveland Browns are emerging as a serious contender in the AFC for 2019. I’m not a big Odell Beckham fan but I recognize the guy has talent and the Browns trade to get him has certainly raised some eyebrows.

And the Browns should have a lot of talent. When you colossally suck for over a decade you have a chance to add some talent in the draft.

So here’s my question Cowboys fans....have the brownies passed us in the chase for NFL talent? If we matched up with them now, who would have the edge? Are the Browns closer to a SB than Dallas? I’m not going to do every position- just the positions we are looking at locking up long term as our top talent compared to the Browns.

Let’s look at the Browns top talent compared to ours:
Position Which team has the edge?
QB- Baker Mayfield vs. Dak Prescott (Cle)

No, Dak over Mayfield. Dak showed last year with Cooper, and still not much pass protection what he is.

PJTHEDOORS · Mar 14, 2019

Manster_Mash said:
And better QB.

No they don't.

Have the Browns passed the Cowboys in roster talent?

jrumann59

Well-Known Member

Stash

Falco78

Well-Known Member

Stash

The Natural

Well-Known Member

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member

fansince68

Well-Known Member

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"

Bowdown27

Well-Known Member

glimmerman

Well-Known Member

LatinMind

iPhotoshop

Dre11

Well-Known Member

Stash

kento40

Well-Known Member

conner01

Well-Known Member

Verdict

Well-Known Member

PJTHEDOORS

Well-Known Member

PJTHEDOORS

Well-Known Member