Sign AJ McCarron

Cowfan75

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,960
Reaction score
7,769
This is such bull...god this is annoying.
Cowboys want the best QB they can have and to think they don't is asinine.
Dak right now like it or not is the best we can get. The Dak hate is unreal...it really is. I've never seen someone so hated for winning 2 NFCE titles in 3 years and leading his team to having the second best record aside from Tom Brady since he's joined.

Don't wet yourself there. Did I say I hate Dak? I'm simply saying they will want zero controversy after signing Dak to a deal. You actually believe if Cooper or whoever outplayed Dak by a mile in preseason (following a deal) that they would start whoever gave us the better chance to win? In a perfect world, maybe. Not here, not now. They would give the entire season to Dak before they even thought about starting someone else.
 

iceberg

rock music matters
Messages
34,131
Reaction score
7,416
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
But did you demand the same to bring in quality competition during the Romo years?
it didn't come up that much. but if an opportunity to sign a top quality backup came along, i'd be for it . if romo OR ANY QB can't beat who we sign off the streets then i'd just as soon know.

wouldn't you?

but again - if in the course of conversation someone were to ask me in the romo years if we should sign the best available talent, i'd say yes. sounds like you would not say the same. fine, i just disagree and am moving on from this pointless discussion now.
 

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,054
Reaction score
46,962
What's amazing is that after 5 years in the league of mostly suckage, someone still thinks Mccarron is even decent. Dude sucks.
 

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,384
Reaction score
22,322
McCarron has been on 3 teams and is looking for a 4th. He is the definition of a JAG. No idea if he is any better than the current backups but he has not shown much in 4 years that would indicate he is.
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
This is such bull...god this is annoying.
Cowboys want the best QB they can have and to think they don't is asinine.
Dak right now like it or not is the best we can get. The Dak hate is unreal...it really is. I've never seen someone so hated for winning 2 NFCE titles in 3 years and leading his team to having the second best record aside from Tom Brady since he's joined.
But adding McCarron is not a slam at DAK..IMO.

Rush and White are non-factors.

We could do much better.
 

Brax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,350
Reaction score
6,988
He could actually compete for the starting spot if he did come here.
there is no way Jerry is bringing in anyone that might make Dak look bad or compete against him, Dak is the new apple of Jerry's eye. In Dallas it's Dak or bust.
 

Flamma

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,795
Reaction score
18,663
There's a lot of cheap backup QB options still available. McCarron is one of them, but Geno Smith, Trevor Siemian, and Brett Hundley also make sense for this team. All have similar play styles to Dak, can move the offense in a pinch, and failed enough as starters to not create a QB controversy here.

Geno Smith? The dude is trash! Might as well bring back Mark Sanchez.
 

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,767
Reaction score
46,269
it didn't come up that much. but if an opportunity to sign a top quality backup came along, i'd be for it . if romo OR ANY QB can't beat who we sign off the streets then i'd just as soon know.

wouldn't you?

but again - if in the course of conversation someone were to ask me in the romo years if we should sign the best available talent, i'd say yes. sounds like you would not say the same. fine, i just disagree and am moving on from this pointless discussion now.
For the record, I was one of the few who for years demanded in the old official Cowboys Fans Forums for top quality QB competition for Romo year in and year out, but I would get blasted/attacked by the majority of posters which led to getting suspended there repeatedly just to please the masses of Romo lovers. You are actually communicating with the 1 most vocal poster for top QB competion.
 
Top