Dak Is/Isn’t A Franchise QB Thread

Pessimist_cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,872
Reaction score
15,223
Winz are a team stat.

Garrett has the same record as Dak over that span, is he a good coach?

Jeff Heath has the same record, is ge a good starter?

We could do this all day.

Since that 13 and 3 season, Dak has been 500 as a starter and he had a top 10 defense for most of that stretch.

His Winz include ganes like the Saints when our D balled out and the Raiders game with the Derek Carr fumbke at the goal line..

That is all.
I’m seeing something I haven’t seen in a while. the Cowboys haven’t had a losing SEASON yet with Dak. And 9-7 , 10-6 , 6-7 is not a 500 record. It also says a lot that at 24/25 years old Dak has a playoff win. He’s definitely good enough to win with. With a new staff in place and some fresh juice he can be really successful. Garrett has been here 10 years he is what he is. Don’t compare a HC to A QB. A better HC would have got the Cowboys to at least the NFC Championship game in 2016. Garrett was 1-11 without Romo. So no he’s not a good coach. He should have been fired then in 2015. Dak’s wins include @ GB @ Pittsburgh , he’s 5-1 vs the Eagles and beat Seattle in the playoffs. And he was a huge part in all those big wins.
 

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,474
Reaction score
20,153
I’m seeing something I haven’t seen in a while. the Cowboys haven’t had a losing SEASON yet with Dak. And 9-7 , 10-6 , 6-7 is not a 500 record. It also says a lot that at 24/25 years old Dak has a playoff win. He’s definitely good enough to win with. With a new staff in place and some fresh juice he can be really successful. Garrett has been here 10 years he is what he is. Don’t compare a HC to A QB. A better HC would have got the Cowboys to at least the NFC Championship game in 2016. Garrett was 1-11 without Romo. So no he’s not a good coach. He should have been fired then in 2015. Dak’s wins include @ GB @ Pittsburgh , he’s 5-1 vs the Eagles and beat Seattle in the playoffs. And he was a huge part in all those big wins.

Embarrassing. Just stop.

He's Alex Smith - he's a guy who you always want to upgrade from, he's not the answer. This is why our fan base gets routinely mocked.
 

Pessimist_cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,872
Reaction score
15,223
I wish he had Kurt's accuracy to start with.
Dak is worse by far if you throw in his panic pocket presence and all the rest of the stuff he supposedly getting better at.
Thank the heavens that even Jerry sat tight and did not give this inept QB a new monster deal.
There’s not a single GM that would take Kirk Cousins over Dak. That dude is soft. Everyone knows it, he a joke in the league. The Vikings even know it if you watch the way they design their game plans. It’s to take the ball out of Cousins hands the most efficient way possible. If they have to rely on him they know they’re screwed. Don’t be surprised if the Vikings draft a QB in the 1st round.
 

Beast_from_East

Well-Known Member
Messages
29,420
Reaction score
26,446
But you did lose to the jets, who are only 1 game better than the dolphins because you couldn’t beat them. Does that mean you get banned too?

Neither the Cowboys or the Eagles deserve to be in the playoffs.

The league should change the rule about auto seedings, if you dont have at least 9 wins you dont go to the playoffs. Going to the playoffs at 7-9 or 8-8 is more of an embarrassment than an accomplishment.
 

Pessimist_cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,872
Reaction score
15,223
Embarrassing. Just stop.

He's Alex Smith - he's a guy who you always want to upgrade from, he's not the answer. This is why our fan base gets routinely mocked.
I never called Dak elite. I said he’s good enough to win with. Did you read? Let’s see him with a new staff in place. You’ll have no choice, it’s coming.
 

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,474
Reaction score
20,153
I never called Dak elite. I said he’s good enough to win with. Did you read? Let’s see him with a new staff in place. You’ll have no choice, it’s coming.

Good enough to win WHAT? A playoff game? Who gives a freakin' crap? What does that give us, lower draft pick? It means absolutely nothing. You want mediocrity, and for someone who is a "pessimist", what a way to settle like that.

Again, it's just embarrassing. Push for better entertainment.
 

starcity214

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,028
Reaction score
2,066
I’m seeing something I haven’t seen in a while. the Cowboys haven’t had a losing SEASON yet with Dak. And 9-7 , 10-6 , 6-7 is not a 500 record. It also says a lot that at 24/25 years old Dak has a playoff win. He’s definitely good enough to win with. With a new staff in place and some fresh juice he can be really successful. Garrett has been here 10 years he is what he is. Don’t compare a HC to A QB. A better HC would have got the Cowboys to at least the NFC Championship game in 2016. Garrett was 1-11 without Romo. So no he’s not a good coach. He should have been fired then in 2015. Dak’s wins include @ GB @ Pittsburgh , he’s 5-1 vs the Eagles and beat Seattle in the playoffs. And he was a huge part in all those big wins.

I see you included that win against the Eagle's third string players in the season finale of 2017. Winz baby.

You can see it how you want to, all I know is, the front office doesn't have the same faith in your boy as you do.

How many times did you hear the Eagles or Rams say their QBs needed to take a team friendly deal? Remember, our front office was saying that before tbose 2 got their deals and keep in mind, both of those QBs had already made plenty of money.. it would make more sense for them to take a pay instead of Dak..

Speaks volumes.
 

basel90

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,909
Reaction score
4,287
Trubisky outplayed Dak , big time
Trubisky’s record as Chicago’s starter (22-16, .579) is now better than Dak’s (25-20, .556).

We said all along , Dak is average and is not a top 10 QB by any stretch... but no one wants to listen .
 

Retro88

Well-Known Member
Messages
307
Reaction score
339
Lmao. Top 10-15 QB but somehow not a franchise QB. This board is wild.
 

Swagger

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,974
Reaction score
7,693
Yes the defense got gutted last night but the offense left many plays on the field during the first three quarters including Prescott which also contributed to the loss.

It makes me laugh when people say that Prescott is clutch and brings it in the fourth quarter...you mean when defenses are gassed and/or playing soft coverage thus allowing completions and yards to be gained?

If Prescott was a franchise quarterback then he would bring it from the first whistle.

You can't just play well in the final quarter - like last night, the team will fall too far behind and it then turns in to garbage time and stat padding.

People who like their analytics will know that when Prescott has been faced with a good defense this season, he has played poorly in every game except the Vikings who are notoriously weaker away from home.

I gave him a pass for the Patriots game (weather, glove, Belichick etc) but the last two games have reinforced that he just isn't good enough if we want to win a Superbowl which is all I care about for this team.

There are many issues with this team but surely everyone is concerned with how Prescott played against good defenses (Bills, Bears, Patriots, Saints) plus the Packers and Jets. He looked a million dollars against the poor sides but then...every quarterback does!
 

Section446

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,885
Reaction score
11,524
How could anybody think this guy is even close to as good as Romo was?

His flaws as a qb are evident every single week. Raise your hand if you know when we get inside the 10, we have almost no chance at throwing for a TD...
I destroyed Romo for years, the guy just wasn't a Super Bowl caliber QB, but he was Tom Brady compared to Dak.
 

Hadenough

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,342
Reaction score
12,566
Im tired of him and his garbage time stat-padding


Get him and the head coach the hell out of here
Last couple weeks I have givin him the benefit of doubt since appears to have improved but all I got out of it was fools gold. Dak really does pad his stats in garbage time. Dak has the cold streaks that last way too long in critical situations. This is what you get when you go cheap at QB. Heck when is the last time Dak came out and shredded a decent opponent. People see the defense crumbling but they seem to be blind that Dak continually going 3 and out isnt helping matters.
This team will not win anything with Dak as the QB.
 
Top