News: PFT: Competition committee: PI replay results: "Not great"

WoodysGirl · Feb 25, 2020

Competition committee: PI replay results: "Not great" - ProFootballTalk

Members of the NFL's competition committee have a firm grasp of the obvious, but they lack an obvious solution for what to do with replay for pass interference. Via Kevin Seifert of ESPN.com, members of the committee still aren't sure how to proceed, following a season in which it was made clear to coaches that [more]

Read Full Story

Because it was poorly thought out and implemented.

CATCH17 · Feb 25, 2020

Get rid of it..

They don’t want it and the last thing we need is another reason for the game to stop and throw a million commercials at us.

JoeKing · Feb 25, 2020

Who didn't see this coming?

Vanilla2 · Feb 25, 2020

CATCH17 said:
Get rid of it..

They don’t want it and the last thing we need is another reason for the game to stop and throw a million commercials at us.

they’ll keep it just for the commercials

jazzcat22 · Feb 25, 2020

Let's see...remove the stupid rule and game stoppage...add more commercials and make more money....make more money is the answer.
They next question...how do we speed up the game to offset this....answer, let's create some stupid game clock rules like the clock runs after the ball is set for an incompletion, and eliminate the clock stoppage rules in the last 2 minutes of the 1st half and last 5 minutes of the game.
10 second runoff for clock stoppage for every inured player that causes more than 30 seconds to get them off the field. At least they may try that is PS games first.

CouchCoach · Feb 25, 2020

They reacted instead of responded to an egregious error by a ref. And one thing you can bet on, if it happens in a playoff game it will mushroom quickly. That's how we got instant replay even though the play that caused that would not have been overturned as the evidence was inconclusive.

This "Ok, we're on it" posture of the NFL when something goes awry is really amusing to watch.

John813 · Feb 25, 2020

Problem with pass interference and holding(offense and defense) is that different crews allow differing amounts of leeway before throwing the flag.

It's not like a false start, offsides or facemask(to a certain degree). There's grey area and refs may miss something from their view that may be obvious not not obvious from a 180 degree view.

There won't ever be a day where all the crews call games exactly like one another. What is maddening though is when refs change their interpretation of PI during the same game.

MrPhil · Feb 25, 2020

I am impressed with how efficient the XFL has been with the replays. The NFL could learn a thing or three from the XFL and this is one of them. I am sure the administrative bureaucracy of the NFL is hard to overcome but man, the XFL is running circles around them in that regard.

Ranched · Feb 25, 2020

"Replay has been the most successful when you’re dealing with objective information,” Murphy said.

But somehow the league worth millions (CFL) has figured it out while the league worth billions (NFL) struggles with it. Every time I see one of these articles, I shake my head in disbelief.

Runwildboys · Feb 25, 2020

WoodysGirl said:
Competition committee: PI replay results: "Not great" - ProFootballTalk

Members of the NFL's competition committee have a firm grasp of the obvious, but they lack an obvious solution for what to do with replay for pass interference. Via Kevin Seifert of ESPN.com, members of the committee still aren't sure how to proceed, following a season in which it was made clear to coaches that [more]

Read Full Story

Because it was poorly thought out and implemented.

According to the article almost 1/4 of the reviews were turned over. That's a lot more than it seemed like.

CouchCoach · Feb 25, 2020

Runwildboys said:
According to the article almost 1/4 of the reviews were turned over. That's a lot more than it seemed like.

That is a lot higher than I heard quoted throughout the season by talking heads.

Runwildboys · Feb 25, 2020

I'm sure New York is watching every game in real time. Maybe they should just leave it up to them to call and stop the game when there's a questionable call. Or better yet, have the commentators call for a review. They usually have a pretty good eye for bad calls.

aikemirv · Feb 25, 2020

CATCH17 said:
Get rid of it..

They don’t want it and the last thing we need is another reason for the game to stop and throw a million commercials at us.

Just save it for Playoffs and last 3 minutes of half or game

shabazz · Feb 25, 2020

Runwildboys said:
According to the article almost 1/4 of the reviews were turned over. That's a lot more than it seemed like.

Agree. Judging by some of the blatant non-reversals, I thought they were trying to get rid of it themselves

WoodysGirl · Feb 25, 2020

shabazz said:
Agree. Judging by some of the blatant non-reversals, I thought they were trying to get rid of it themselves

That's what got me. There were some that definitely should've been overturned and were not. It makes it difficult to trust the spirit of the rule.

DallasEast · Feb 25, 2020

Several hurdles must be defeated before things improve significantly:

CPanther95 · Feb 25, 2020

Something's not right. Don't remember the stats they were quoting, but the impression that remains in my head from last season that it wasn't even 1 in 20.

.... or I got Old People Problems.

EST_1986 · Feb 25, 2020

shabazz said:
Agree. Judging by some of the blatant non-reversals, I thought they were trying to get rid of it themselves

the NFL was set out to kill it before it even began.

foofighters · Feb 25, 2020

CouchCoach said:
They reacted instead of responded to an egregious error by a ref. And one thing you can bet on, if it happens in a playoff game it will mushroom quickly. That's how we got instant replay even though the play that caused that would not have been overturned as the evidence was inconclusive.

This "Ok, we're on it" posture of the NFL when something goes awry is really amusing to watch.

Nice way to put it. What should have been done is instead of pushing the game and fans with a slow process, they should be having a system in place to hold refs accountable.

RoboQB · Feb 26, 2020

CPanther95 said:
Something's not right. Don't remember the stats they were quoting, but the impression that remains in my head from last season that it wasn't even 1 in 20.

.... or I got Old People Problems.

I seem to remember exactly one reversal in week one and zero
in at least the following 6 weeks. They overturned several in the final few weeks
to pad the stats, imo.

We're getting old, I agree. So maybe I just dreamed it... lol

News: PFT: Competition committee: PI replay results: "Not great"

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y

CATCH17

1st Round Pick

JoeKing

Diehard

Vanilla2

Well-Known Member

jazzcat22

CouchCoach

John813

Well-Known Member

MrPhil

Well-Known Member

Ranched

"We Are Penn State"

Runwildboys

Confused about stuff

CouchCoach

Runwildboys

Confused about stuff

aikemirv

Well-Known Member

shabazz

Well-Known Member

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365

CPanther95

Well-Known Member

EST_1986

Well-Known Member

foofighters

Well-Known Member

RoboQB

Well-Known Member