Yet another Dak stat post

Established1971

fiveandcounting
Messages
5,505
Reaction score
4,107
I apologize in advance to the Dak lovers (not being sarcastic) for giving ammo to the "haters" I'm in the middle myself frankly and I just checked these numbers expecting them to be much better for Dak. I'm kind of shocked really. Anyway these numbers below represent the placing for each qb in qb rating in their first 4 years as a starter.

I see so many people quoting Dak's completion % but completion % just keeps getting better and better for the whole league, across the board. I am a believer in qb rating as it combines and weighs a variety of numbers. And yes, of course, winning is the best stat. I do believe Dak can bring us to the promised land. I personally hopes he signs soon and we can just move on and all root for him.

But that said :
Prescott 1st year (2016) 3rd, 2nd year 18th, 3rd 14th and last year 10th
Romo was 5,5,8 and 8
Wentz has been 5,4,7,13

I thought Dak's low int rate would mean he has been placing higher

I expect Dak to place much higher in 2020..... if we play
 

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,035
Reaction score
10,803
I apologize in advance to the Dak lovers (not being sarcastic) for giving ammo to the "haters" I'm in the middle myself frankly and I just checked these numbers expecting them to be much better for Dak. I'm kind of shocked really. Anyway these numbers below represent the placing for each qb in qb rating in their first 4 years as a starter.

I see so many people quoting Dak's completion % but completion % just keeps getting better and better for the whole league, across the board. I am a believer in qb rating as it combines and weighs a variety of numbers. And yes, of course, winning is the best stat. I do believe Dak can bring us to the promised land. I personally hopes he signs soon and we can just move on and all root for him.

But that said :
Prescott 1st year (2016) 3rd, 2nd year 18th, 3rd 14th and last year 10th
Romo was 5,5,8 and 8
Wentz has been 5,4,7,13

I thought Dak's low int rate would mean he has been placing higher

I expect Dak to place much higher in 2020..... if we play
Passer rating dislikes Dak for a couple reasons. One is that his TD% isn't that high, which is in part because he runs them in a lot (21 in four years). Another is that passer rating overrates completion %: Dak's is good but not great, but he throws the ball downfield more than many other QBs (I know there are people here who think he dinks-and-dunks, but he's really the opposite). Other measures, like Football Outsiders' DVOA and DYAR, like him much much more: he ranked 4th and 1st in those last year.
 

Typhus

Captain Catfish
Messages
19,558
Reaction score
22,450
I used to read every word of every post,, that's just me.. but does anyone else find them selves just glossing over new Dak threads these days?
No disrespect intended to the OP, Im sure its well thought out,, Im just asking...
 

Hawkeye0202

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,020
Reaction score
42,502
Somebody, anybody, please make it stop ..........


https://lh3.***BROKEN***/proxy/M_aFfCfNCwx0MwYfsS4IxFbKbHBpb-5SFWTcT0V84saQ1WPVU6Ao-3HosCLxjEp8gqJVI0_5NFUZQc4NKW2EKbKuyRZfmqFrihv3YksQDU6DR1rFrQQLpec7jyCSDoXuM-EH1q0
 

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,533
Reaction score
60,409
I apologize in advance to the Dak lovers (not being sarcastic) for giving ammo to the "haters" I'm in the middle myself frankly and I just checked these numbers expecting them to be much better for Dak. I'm kind of shocked really. Anyway these numbers below represent the placing for each qb in qb rating in their first 4 years as a starter.

I see so many people quoting Dak's completion % but completion % just keeps getting better and better for the whole league, across the board. I am a believer in qb rating as it combines and weighs a variety of numbers. And yes, of course, winning is the best stat. I do believe Dak can bring us to the promised land. I personally hopes he signs soon and we can just move on and all root for him.

But that said :
Prescott 1st year (2016) 3rd, 2nd year 18th, 3rd 14th and last year 10th
Romo was 5,5,8 and 8
Wentz has been 5,4,7,13

I thought Dak's low int rate would mean he has been placing higher

I expect Dak to place much higher in 2020..... if we play


I haven’t checked the rest of your post for accuracy. But there’s no way Carson Wentz was 5th in passer rating his first season.
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,065
Reaction score
80,004
Somebody, anybody, please make it stop ..........


https://lh3.***BROKEN***/proxy/M_aFfCfNCwx0MwYfsS4IxFbKbHBpb-5SFWTcT0V84saQ1WPVU6Ao-3HosCLxjEp8gqJVI0_5NFUZQc4NKW2EKbKuyRZfmqFrihv3YksQDU6DR1rFrQQLpec7jyCSDoXuM-EH1q0

i don’t recall being this bad during the Romo years
 

NotForLong

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,520
Reaction score
9,559
I used to read every word of every post,, that's just me.. but does anyone else find them selves just glossing over new Dak threads these days?
No disrespect intended to the OP, Im sure its well thought out,, Im just asking...
Me too but this OP post is on point. 1st time I saw a stat of Dak's in which i didn't come away scratching my head.

Amazing how long it took to find it's way to the Zone
 

mcmvp

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,135
Reaction score
2,057
I haven’t checked the rest of your post for accuracy. But there’s no way Carson Wentz was 5th in passer rating his first season.

Agree...he couldn’t have been. I think he was high 70s. Rookie year and the o line was terrible that year… Lane Johnson was suspended for 10 games
 

Typhus

Captain Catfish
Messages
19,558
Reaction score
22,450
Me too but this OP post is on point. 1st time I saw a stat of Dak's in which i didn't come away scratching my head.

Amazing how long it took to find it's way to the Zone
Dang, now you made me go back and re read every single word.
 

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,035
Reaction score
10,803
I haven’t checked the rest of your post for accuracy. But there’s no way Carson Wentz was 5th in passer rating his first season.
He was 25th. I think the other numbers are right, he just forgot the "2" in front of the 5 on that one.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
Somebody, anybody, please make it stop ..........


https://lh3.***BROKEN***/proxy/M_aFfCfNCwx0MwYfsS4IxFbKbHBpb-5SFWTcT0V84saQ1WPVU6Ao-3HosCLxjEp8gqJVI0_5NFUZQc4NKW2EKbKuyRZfmqFrihv3YksQDU6DR1rFrQQLpec7jyCSDoXuM-EH1q0

Its amazing how the board complains and complains but nobody does anything.
 

Verdict

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,961
Reaction score
20,118
I apologize in advance to the Dak lovers (not being sarcastic) for giving ammo to the "haters" I'm in the middle myself frankly and I just checked these numbers expecting them to be much better for Dak. I'm kind of shocked really. Anyway these numbers below represent the placing for each qb in qb rating in their first 4 years as a starter.

I see so many people quoting Dak's completion % but completion % just keeps getting better and better for the whole league, across the board. I am a believer in qb rating as it combines and weighs a variety of numbers. And yes, of course, winning is the best stat. I do believe Dak can bring us to the promised land. I personally hopes he signs soon and we can just move on and all root for him.

But that said :
Prescott 1st year (2016) 3rd, 2nd year 18th, 3rd 14th and last year 10th
Romo was 5,5,8 and 8
Wentz has been 5,4,7,13

I thought Dak's low int rate would mean he has been placing higher

I expect Dak to place much higher in 2020..... if we play
Thank goodness for helping us hit our Dak thread quota today.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,472
Reaction score
21,741
I apologize in advance to the Dak lovers (not being sarcastic) for giving ammo to the "haters" I'm in the middle myself frankly and I just checked these numbers expecting them to be much better for Dak. I'm kind of shocked really. Anyway these numbers below represent the placing for each qb in qb rating in their first 4 years as a starter.

I see so many people quoting Dak's completion % but completion % just keeps getting better and better for the whole league, across the board. I am a believer in qb rating as it combines and weighs a variety of numbers. And yes, of course, winning is the best stat. I do believe Dak can bring us to the promised land. I personally hopes he signs soon and we can just move on and all root for him.

But that said :
Prescott 1st year (2016) 3rd, 2nd year 18th, 3rd 14th and last year 10th
Romo was 5,5,8 and 8
Wentz has been 5,4,7,13

I thought Dak's low int rate would mean he has been placing higher

I expect Dak to place much higher in 2020..... if we play

His focus is starting to return...we'll see how sharp he is now. His window for maximum growth levels, is about a three year deal starting now.
 

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,533
Reaction score
60,409
Passer rating dislikes Dak for a couple reasons. One is that his TD% isn't that high, which is in part because he runs them in a lot (21 in four years). Another is that passer rating overrates completion %: Dak's is good but not great, but he throws the ball downfield more than many other QBs (I know there are people here who think he dinks-and-dunks, but he's really the opposite). Other measures, like Football Outsiders' DVOA and DYAR, like him much much more: he ranked 4th and 1st in those last year.

He’s also one of the best in EPA and QBR as well.
 

AmericanCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,538
Reaction score
5,292
How about we also account for awful scheme where our receivers ran the same 5 routes all game?

No misdirection. Little motion. Almost no screens. Old man Witten trying to get open.
 

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,810
Reaction score
46,304
I apologize in advance to the Dak lovers (not being sarcastic) for giving ammo to the "haters" I'm in the middle myself frankly and I just checked these numbers expecting them to be much better for Dak. I'm kind of shocked really. Anyway these numbers below represent the placing for each qb in qb rating in their first 4 years as a starter.

I see so many people quoting Dak's completion % but completion % just keeps getting better and better for the whole league, across the board. I am a believer in qb rating as it combines and weighs a variety of numbers. And yes, of course, winning is the best stat. I do believe Dak can bring us to the promised land. I personally hopes he signs soon and we can just move on and all root for him.

But that said :
Prescott 1st year (2016) 3rd, 2nd year 18th, 3rd 14th and last year 10th
Romo was 5,5,8 and 8
Wentz has been 5,4,7,13

I thought Dak's low int rate would mean he has been placing higher

I expect Dak to place much higher in 2020..... if we play
Another disingenuous anti-Dak thread.

Why didn't you post Dak's yearly passer ratings and compare them to Romo's? It's because it would destroy your Dak bashing narrative.

Here, I'll do it for you...

Dak's first 4 years passer ratings...along with the total average passer rating at the very bottom.
Screenshot-20200506-212252-Sports.jpg


Tony Romo's career years passer ratings (plus his first 4 years)...plus his overall career passer rating average.
Screenshot-20200507-212312-Chrome.jpg


As you can see, Dak has put up much better passer ratings his first 4 years than Romo did his first 4 years in comparison.
 

Established1971

fiveandcounting
Messages
5,505
Reaction score
4,107
Another disingenuous anti-Dak thread.

Why didn't you post Dak's yearly passer ratings and compare them to Romo's? It's because it would destroy your Dak bashing narrative.

Here, I'll do it for you...

Dak's first 4 years passer ratings...along with the total average passer rating at the very bottom.
Screenshot-20200506-212252-Sports.jpg


Tony Romo's career years passer ratings (plus his first 4 years)...plus his overall career passer rating average.
Screenshot-20200507-212312-Chrome.jpg


As you can see, Dak has put up much better passer ratings his first 4 years than Romo did his first 4 years in comparison.
lol youre reading skills are not very good. Your post is just an angry reactionary post. If you read my post it was fair and full of qualifiers. You accuse me of cherry picking stats and then do exactly the same in response. Difference is I admit it was one example of many stats and explained why I thought qb rating was good to discuss and how I havent seen it in other threads. Enjoy your anger
 
Top