Prescott or Dalton: Who do you want starting

Nav22 · May 21, 2020

jnday said:
You don’t understand. You are not worth arguing with. If I respond as I should, I would get banned, so I just ignore you. You are not worth the time and I have become bored with the Dak discussions.

Thoroughly shamed into silence.
:lmao2:

Dak OWNS you. He can sell you if he so chooses. You’re not expensive.

Big_D · May 21, 2020

StuckMojo said:
That shoulder sure healed fast against the lousy Commanders a week later.

healed just in time to pad those stats and tack on a meaningless win!

HellCrowe · May 21, 2020

Is it July yet? Get this over with, it’s like nails to a blackboard. I just want the topic to change. I don’t even care if the debate is if Dak is under/over paid or under/over performed, release/traded/signed. Hate this limbo crap.

Brax · May 21, 2020

Denim Chicken said:
You mean the game he was injured?

but but but he was injured, come on just stop with the excuses......

Darkhound · May 21, 2020

I would like Dalton then if the universe goes well have Alex smith as a backup and then look for our QB for the future.. not this Dak dud bust

DFWJC · May 21, 2020

So...a little more than twice as many want Dak.
I'm betting that of those picking Dalton, 90% are doing it with cap in mind.
So straight up (which is unrealistic)....it's about 95% Dak.

DFWJC · May 21, 2020

cern said:
will there be a true and legitimate competition for the qb spot between Dalton and dak.

No
There wasn't with Tony and Dak either. now THAT was wrong.
But in this case, if they are paying a guy who just threw for 4900 yards and had a plus 19 turnover differential..AND paying a fortune to....basically no team would have an open competition.

SDCowboy · May 21, 2020

Is this thread for real? lol

darthseinfeld · May 21, 2020

SDCowboy said:
Is this thread for real? lol

I actually regret starting it.

It took less than a page

leeblair · May 21, 2020

Endzoneview said:
Do you actually watch games?

Yes, I do. I get to watch Dak choke when the big games come and he needs to lead the team.
I get to watch him run up his stats against weak teams and prevent defenses when the tough teams get way ahead because Dak has choked again.
I've seen enough of Dak and Jason Garrett. He should join Garrett in New York and they can pat each other's backs.

Denim Chicken · May 21, 2020

OmerV · May 21, 2020

I'm guessing a lot of those voting for Dalton are doing so outside the context of the question. I would bet some of those would rather have Dak starting, but put Dalton anyway because they are upset about Dak's contract situation.

OmerV · May 21, 2020

leeblair said:
Yes, I do. I get to watch Dak choke when the big games come and he needs to lead the team.
I get to watch him run up his stats against weak teams and prevent defenses when the tough teams get way ahead because Dak has choked again.
I've seen enough of Dak and Jason Garrett. He should join Garrett in New York and they can pat each other's backs.

lol - against some of the weak teams Dak was actually held back because the lead was so big the team went heavy on the running game to eat up clock. And while Dak didn't perform well in some of the losses, it's nonsense to suggest he choked in every "big game". I think you just find someone else saying these things and repeat them like a parrott. I also find it funny that 2016-2018 where we made the playoffs 2 out of 3 years gets ignored as if 2019 is the only season in Dak's career.

leeblair · May 21, 2020

OmerV said:
lol - against some of the weak teams Dak was actually held back because the lead was so big the team went heavy on the running game to eat up clock. And while Dak didn't perform well in some of the losses, it's nonsense to suggest he choked in every "big game". I think you just find someone else saying these things and repeat them like a parrott. I also find it funny that 2016-2018 where we made the playoffs 2 out of 3 years gets ignored as if 2019 is the only season in Dak's career.

I think it's sad that you "Dak supporters" always talk about how he made the playoffs- in the weakest division in the NFL- and he couldn't beat the Eagles or any other team in 2019 when only one more victory would have clinched the East.
The Cowboys would have lost to the Commanders at the end if the Commanders weren't trying to get a high draft spot.
Dak was so bad that the Commanders had to go out of their way to throw the game.

InTheZone · May 21, 2020

Trueboysfan said:
Easy...make it an open competition. Because honestly I want the best player to start.

hater

InTheZone · May 21, 2020

JBS said:
Nobody that has actually seen dalton play, thinks he's better than Dak. Every single person in here that argues for Dalton, I can promise you, has not seen him play in 2019.

I watched how 2017 and 2019 ended with Dak, I also saw more than enough than enough that I didn't like in 2018 so....

Manwiththeplan · May 21, 2020

Hawkeye0202 said:
All due respect, there shouldn't be one. I can't imagine a single poster who would rather see Dalton starting over Dak.

you’d be wrong...now if you said any posters that understand football, then you’d be correct

QuincyCarterEra · May 21, 2020

Anyone want to guess how many QBs have been to the playoffs more times than Dak has over the last four years?

JBS · May 21, 2020

InTheZone said:
I watched how 2017 and 2019 ended with Dak, I also saw more than enough than enough that I didn't like in 2018 so....

I have no doubts that you don't like dak lol. I'm not arguing against that

OmerV · May 21, 2020

leeblair said:
I think it's sad that you "Dak supporters" always talk about how he made the playoffs- in the weakest division in the NFL- and he couldn't beat the Eagles or any other team in 2019 when only one more victory would have clinched the East.
The Cowboys would have lost to the Commanders at the end if the Commanders weren't trying to get a high draft spot.
Dak was so bad that the Commanders had to go out of their way to throw the game.

He can only make the playoffs in the division he is in, but realistically if you look at 3 of the 4 AFC divisions they aren't even close to being notably better.

As for the "Dak supporter" comment (to your credit, at least you don't use the idiotic "Dak Lover" or Dak Slobberer" like some do), I completely recognize Dak has flaws and things to work on, and I also admitted he didn't play well in some of the losses. And, so you know, I don't elite like Mahomes, Rodgers etc …

But I expect fairness, and in fairness, if you are going to complain about his performance in "big games" in 2019 and how he had a chance to make the playoffs, you also have to recognize that at other times in his career that wasn't the case. You can't cherry pick and be fair.

Ultimately, an extreme view of Dak on the negative side is no better than someone who blindly supports Dak without seeing the flaws. Reality is almost never on the extremes.

Prescott or Dalton: Who do you want starting

Who do you want starting

Dak Prescott

Andy Dalton

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Groupthink Guru

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member