Dak, Troy, Romo, Roger-start 1, bench 2 and cut one 1

CowboysFaninHouston · May 28, 2020

Hawkeye0202 said:
What ya gonna do??????

Starting Staubach
bench = Akiman and Dak
Cutting Romo

Dak's younger with a proven higher ceiling based on his first four years IMO. But this is clearly a gut-wrenching decision that can go either way.

easy....

start roger, aikman and romo on the bench in that order. cut Dak.

Blackrain · May 28, 2020

Start Roger
Troy could back him up ,
Let the rest sit and watch the greatest player in Cowboy history and wish they could be half of what he meant to this franchise

GMO415 · May 28, 2020

Start Staubach

Bench Troy Dak

Cut Romo

DFWJC · May 28, 2020

OP probably needs to say at what stage in their career each is.
Sounds like he's just trying to stir the pot anyway....another way for him to be fluffer for Dak.
Makes those of us that like Dak, like him a little less at times, though no fault of Dak's.

Roger
Troy
Tony/Meredith/White
Dak/Morton

Maverick84 · May 28, 2020

DFWJC said:
OP probably needs to say at what stage in their career each is.
Sounds like he's just trying to stir the pot anyway....another way for him to be fluffer for Dak.
Makes those of us that like Dak, like him a little less at times, though no fault of Dak's.

Roger
Troy
Tony/Meredith/White
Dak/Morton

yeah he said he picked Dak because Dak is younger... well no ****, Romo is 40 years old smfh

Swanny · May 28, 2020

Hawkeye0202 said:
What ya gonna do??????

Starting Staubach
bench = Akiman and Dak
Cutting Romo

Dak's younger with a proven higher ceiling based on his first four years IMO. But this is clearly a gut-wrenching decision that can go either way.

Staubach starting
Romo and Aikman back up
Dak cut

Hardline · May 28, 2020

Start Staubach
Back up Aikman
These two win Super Bowls.

Romo next because he gives you the next best odds to get you to a Super Bowl

Dak Prescott used for trade bait or develop him on the practice squad and hope no one takes him.

Hawkeye0202 · May 28, 2020

DFWJC said:
OP probably needs to say at what stage in their career each is.
Sounds like he's just trying to stir the pot anyway....another way for him to be fluffer for Dak.
Makes those of us that like Dak, like him a little less at times, though no fault of Dak's.

Roger
Troy
Tony/Meredith/White
Dak/Morton

LOL.......could only use Dak's first four years. I think I said that......

Dak's younger with a proven higher ceiling based on his first four years IMO. But this is clearly a gut-wrenching decision that can go either way.

Kevinicus · May 28, 2020

I guess start Staubach (again, he's before my time, and I can only do so much research).
Bench Romo and Troy
Cut Dak

The only question for me was Staubach/Romo and who should start.

Hawkeye0202 · May 28, 2020

Maverick84 said:
yeah he said he picked Dak because Dak is younger... well no ****, Romo is 40 years old smfh

This is why I chose Dak but as stated, it could go either way ......just my take

Dak's younger with a proven higher ceiling based on his first four years IMO. But this is clearly a gut-wrenching decision that can go either way.

johneric8 · May 28, 2020

Hawkeye0202 said:
What ya gonna do??????

Starting Staubach
bench = Akiman and Dak
Cutting Romo

Dak's younger with a proven higher ceiling based on his first four years IMO. But this is clearly a gut-wrenching decision that can go either way.

Agree 100%

Irvin88_4life · May 28, 2020

BlueNSilver88 said:
The romo disrespect is crazy. All yall are tripping. Dak is not good.

Start Romo.
Bench Aikman/Staubach

CUT DAK

Romo isn't even close to Aikman or Staubach.

If you did start Romo either he would get hurt or couldn't get out of the divisional round of the playoffs that's if he didn't go 8-8 and lose the win and you're in

BrassCowboy · May 28, 2020

Not sure this is even close. Obviously you start Roger, bench Aikman and Romo, and cut Dak.

Look I am not bashing Dak here at all, but I cannot in clear conscience say he is at Romo's level yet. Romo was better when he came back from that injury and played in the eagles game his last year than Dak has ever been. Only reason, even with the season Dak was having, Romo lost his job for good was his age and injury history caught up to him. Again, not a knock on Dak, just truth.

Does that mean Dak can't reach and or beat Romo with more time, no he may. If that says anything about the dilemma in signing Dak to such a huge contract at this point, it may be what most people are thinking.

BigD_95 · May 28, 2020

Hawkeye0202 said:
What ya gonna do??????

Starting Staubach
bench = Akiman and Dak
Cutting Romo

Dak's younger with a proven higher ceiling based on his first four years IMO. But this is clearly a gut-wrenching decision that can go either way.

First anyone that says Dak isnt the one to get cut is either just being funny or doesnt know football.

The starter is hard. I probably go with Aikman if its a good team with good O-line. But if the O-line is weak I think Staubach or Romo can make more plays and are more elusive.

mrmojo · May 28, 2020

Start Roger, backup Danny.....it worked in the 70s

Hennessy_King · May 28, 2020

America's Cowboy said:
I will follow the recent (February 2020) opinion rank from the greatest Dallas Cowboys scout and one of the best ever in NFL history...

Hall Of Famer, Gil Brandt's tweet says it all as to who to trade/cut.

Gil knows a lot more than the dumb dumbs on here so this makes sense.

Dallasfann · May 28, 2020

Are we playing with coaching and talent that both Roger and Aikman had? I take the most talented QB of the 4 and it's actually an easy answer... Romo. We playing with thecoaching and talent Romo had around him? Well ****...we ain't gonna do much then anyway and I never got to see Staubach play so I'll choose Roger just so I can watch him play. Being that Roger will be stuck with Garrett as coach and a ****** defense his whole career, I think he might be able to squeak out 1 or 2 more playoff wins. MAYBE. Wouldn't hold my breath.

Williamsboys · May 28, 2020

Dany Don Meredith's ASHES are better than some quarterbacks out there today.

CATCH17 · May 28, 2020

1. Romo starts

2. Roger Bench

3. Aikman bench

4. Dak cut

Romo starts because of how football evolved and the game suits him.

Roger would eventually start over Romo if he could adapt to todays game. He had the physical traits to do it from the highlights I have seen.

Aikman was great but statue QB's are becoming a thing of the past.

HellCrowe · May 28, 2020

Do we have to consider contract talks? That’s a deal breaker for me dawg

Dak, Troy, Romo, Roger-start 1, bench 2 and cut one 1

CowboysFaninDC

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

1st Round Pick

Well-Known Member