Alarming stat downplays Dak Prescott's passing ability

Star Guard_31 said:

What's more alarming to me is the number of dropped interceptions that Dak benefited from. Dak could have just as easily thrown 27 picks last year, also per PFF. 30 TDs against 27 INTs wouldn't have made for nearly as impressive of a stat line.

Jameis Winston is the only QB in the league that had more would be INTs dropped by DBs, which is a scary thought considering how many INTs Winston still managed to throw.

Click to expand...

So number 2 and 3 are on our team.. Lol. Winston would have thrown 50 picks. Lol.

Point-of-the-Star said:

I edited

Click to expand...

My deepest apologies bro. Total misinterpretation on my part. I feel like crap. Those attackers got me on edge. Thanks for the PM.

buybuydandavis said:

Other QBs get drops too.

Dak had 6.2% drops. The league median is about 5%. With median drops he gets a fifth of the drop yards back, say 80 yards. He'll get more from YAC. That estimate is left as an exercise for the interested reader.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2019/passing_advanced.htm

Click to expand...

Exactly. This argument is idiotic. All teams have drops- its part of the game.

TexasHillbilly said:

Again, BS and only trolls spout the crap that comes out of your posts.

Click to expand...

No not BS



and imagine defending another man so passionately


It must be code of honor for the elderly

daboyzruleperiod said:

And a great guy too.
Time for TexasHillbilly to use that ignore option to avoid all that troll nonsense.

Click to expand...

Done.

Canada180 said:

Winston had a lot of yards . Hmmm where is he playin this year?

Click to expand...

New Orleans.

What do I win?

Clarkson said:

i've never, ever seen a fanbase so vehemently opposed to their own objectively very good QB. it's so bizarre.
you would think Dak had NOTHING to do with Gallup having a great season. like, Gallup was a 2nd year guy. not like he's some known elite commodity. Dak is part of the reason he had a great season.

Click to expand...

this is on response to "well he had a great supporting cast! anyone would succeed!"
no.
in the Cowboys blowout wins, it was Dak slinging the ball all over the field and Zeke coming in to close out the games. i think there was ONE game where Zeke kind of got the team going from the start. one.
and this amazing supporting cast? sure, Cooper is very good. tho apparently not good enough to do Derek Carr any big favors his last year and a half in Oakland.
but Cooper is a very, very good WR. Gallup is good too. how good? we honestly still don't know. but Gallup didn't have a great season while an average or bad QB was throwing to him. they helped each other succeed, no doubt. same thing with Randall Cobb. people now want to talk like Cobb was an amazing slot WR. the Cowboys picked him up for basically nothing. he had been unproductive for years in Green Bay. he comes to Dallas, has a solid season (with LOTS of drops, by the way) and suddenly he's extremely good and Dak was super lucky to have him? HUH? y'all are weird and terribly inconsistent.
line is very good and obviously so is Zeke. but there's no threat at the TE position. most teams are utilizing a good or great pass-catching TE and they are often safety blankets for the QB(COUGH CARSON WENTZ COUGH COUGH COUGH). Dak didn't really have that, and IMO this offense under-utilized Zeke and especially Pollard in the short pass game.

the stain of Garrett being washed away from this offense will be amazing.
Mahomes is an amazing QB but also has an absolutely incredible amount of talent around him, along with maybe the best QB coach in the game in Andy Reid. we can still acknowledge that Mahomes is VERY good, anyway. having a good supporting cast does not take away from good QB play. oftentimes, it's a necessity for it.

Rockport said:

I keep hearing this argument but then I see over and over WR's on other teams making acrobatic catches.

Click to expand...

If we had Hopkins in place of ANY of our receivers we make the playoffs and win a game . He is that much better then what we had last year.

America's Cowboy said:

If you can't tell the difference between Dak and Winston, there is not much to help you. I say go watch some film on Winston. YouTube has most game film on him.

Click to expand...

have you also seen Dak's meltdowns at the most imporant games ?
I still prefer Dak way over Winston , but not not anywhere near the price dak is asking . He just has proven nothing to deserve that type of a paycheck.

The only stat I care about is wins. Dak needs at least 11 wins in the reg season and at least 2 wins in the playoffs to satisfy me.

CowboyRoy said:

So why is Winston so unwanted and Dak is getting offered highest QB money?

Lets see if you can even answer this one correctly? Since you are such a QB guru.

Tick tock, tick tock...………..………………...

Click to expand...

Ok Genius. Winston had a lot of yards. Where is that getting him. Dak had a lot of yards and you think its Ok to shove the most Qb money at him because of his yardage! Yards schmards. Show me wins . Thanks for playin Einstein.

I really hope Dak throws for 5000 yds and we win a Super Bowl. But to say he deserves the most money as a Qb just because of the yards is a fools errand. Im fine with a competitve amount but am leary of a huge contract that hasnt yet been earned.

big dog cowboy said:

New Orleans.

What do I win?

Click to expand...

Lol You sir have my respect! Not sure what thats worth.

Trendnet said:

Do the quarterbacks on this list get the benefit of "air yards lost" due to drops or does only Dak get the benefit of imaginary stats?

Click to expand...

just dak

basel90 said:

false selective stats. meaningless . otherwise why is winston out of a job . he has 5109 yards

Click to expand...

exactly, most stats are meaningless, it is one reason why aikman made his own stat system to take into account some variables
other stats did not.

Stats are what the media uses to "hype" the game and players.

Irvin88_4life said:

But those same folks brag on Dalton with his 1 TD and 6 INTs in the playoffs and well below 8-8 record for multiple years on top of having 16 TDs and 14 INTs last year.......

Click to expand...

Dalton was not motivated to play for cin , and knew his time was going to be up soon, and I think he wanted out.
if he had played great, they would not have let him go now would they?
Sometimes you have to play poorly just to get away from a team.
I think tannehill wanted out of miami, and look at his turnaround when playing for new team.

I would like to see dalton with mostly starters in PS and see how he does.

America's Cowboy said:

(1 yard shy of tying Tony Romo's franchise single season passing yards record...and 2 yards shy of breaking it)

Click to expand...

That line cracked me up.... I know math is hard lol.

It was like some SEO guys said, listen you need at least 400 words in this article for the search engines lol.

DandyDon52 said:

I would like to see dalton with mostly starters in PS and see how he does.

Click to expand...

You probably won't... They seem to never put any QBs in with starting talent in Dallas.

zerofill said:

That line cracked me up.... I know math is hard lol.

It was like some SEO guys said, listen you need at least 400 words in this article for the search engines lol.

Click to expand...

Wanted to make sure short bus riders understood. lol

America's Cowboy said:

Agreed, except I don't care about those other QBs since their WRs drops were much less than Dak's WRs. The article writer did his work mentioning Dak's lost passing yards (almost 400 yards more) which I felt such a high number was too important not to talk about. This article is for Cowboys fans interested in seeing what more potential was left on the field since so many supposed Cowboys fans like to bash and diminish Dak's potential on this forum daily.

Click to expand...

I do agree with that. I didn't mean for my comment to come across as an attack.

I'm just ready for some football.

Scotman said:

I do agree with that. I didn't mean for my comment to come across as an attack.

I'm just ready for some football.

Click to expand...

I hear you bro. It's been a long and stressful offseason.