....right so less than HHCD based on AAV and roughly the same guarantees, you didn't prove a point at all.
Joseph has been plagued by injuries and is now healthy and in line to start while HH was just cut.
You wanted safeties in his price range who would have been better options and I gave you them, you can take them or leave them. Idc.
That's your view for Poe, that isn't backed by fact at all just opinion. Hell you can go to the HHCD signing thread and see what you're saying isn't true.. The contracts also speak for themselves.
But yes, fresh crow is definitely in order!
You are talking hindsight, and ignoring what the team may have felt about the 2 players at the time. As far as proving a point, I did prove you wrong about Phillips, and all I said about Joseph is the team may have felt he was a lesser player than Dix. No, I can’t prove that - didn’t suggest I could, so your argument doesn’t make sense. You can’t disprove it either. The point is we can’t speak for the teams thoughts - neither of us can.
As for saying I am expressing my opinion on Poe, what the hell did you think I meant when I said “I view” him differently? I told you it was my view, so again, your argument makes no sense. Surely you are aware opinions are allowed and frequently expressed on this site.
You dont seem to understand that everything is not measure numerically. How people view a player, or what the team or fans expect from a player, is not the same as AAV and not strictly based on a formula.
You also don’t seem to understand that not team has a perfect record on free agents, so while disappointing Dix didn’t pan out, this isn’t the major source of embarrassment you imagine. The Cowboys didn’t tout him as a cure all, or a star who would elevate the team to new heights, he was a one year veteran presence they hoped would do a good job for, again one year
