Is Mike McCarthy worse than Jason Garrett?

UncleOscar

Well-Known Member
Messages
756
Reaction score
1,303
I don't know if McCarthy and his staff are worse than Garrett and his staff, but so far they look very bad and incompetent.

From allowing Moore to continue to run the Garrett offense, idiotic special team decisions, hiring an old retread like Nolan who looks like a disaster, MM is beginning to look like a complete failure.
 

Darkhound

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,428
Reaction score
2,317
I dont think ANYONE is worse than Garret.. I think MM is just OVER eager to prove himself to the NFL family, to JJ and to himself by going for risky calls etc. I do think we will be ok with this coach
 

kumizi

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,210
Reaction score
5,612
He is an exact copy of Jason Garrett.

He knows nothing about defense.

He knows nothing about special teams.

His expertise is supposed to be on offense but he doesn't call the plays.

He has been criticized for being an awful game manager. He has been criticized for running a boring and predictable offense without much movement pre snap. Ask any Packers fan. They were ecstatic to get rid of him for the same reasons we were ecstatic to get rid of JG.

The thing about sports in this country is that if you win one title you go overnight from being a bum to a stud. The only reason McCarthy has a job is because of that one super bowl on his resume.
 

MojaveJT

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,138
Reaction score
6,334
100% prefer MM.

I like seeing aggressive play calling. Last year, this team would’ve just rolled over and died.

Going aggressive can really swing the momentum in your favor if it works. If it doesn’t, it sucks but I like seeing chances being taken and not sitting back and waiting.
 

Oz-of-Cowboy-Country

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,259
Reaction score
17,077
Splain it to me, lucy. One questionable call last week. But it could have gone either way. Today, brown, smith, collins, lve, lee and jarwin not playing. 3 fumbles early. Two rookie tackles. And he still coaches us to a win. What dumb decisions? I don't get it. Please, splain it to me Lucy.
I think he's going for it the way he is because he's trying to establish a mentally with this team. They are going to need a couple of these games to go their way, so they can start building trust with and believing in one another, as players.
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
55,143
Reaction score
36,328
2 horrible 4th down calls. And an awful decision going for 2 point conversion too early leaving us 2 scores down.

If not for Falcons unbelievably not falling on onside kick we’d be reeling at 0-2.

We didn’t win this game. Atlanta gave it away.
 

Ranching

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,802
Reaction score
107,041
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
2 games in....and I'm already ready to move on. Some of the dumbest decisions I can recall. I seriously don't know who is in charge. We should be 0-2. Not gonna say I miss Garrett...because change had to be made.....but come on man...this wasn't what I had in mind. There had to be over a dozen questionable decisions in this game.

Comments? :popcorn:
MM is wearing his SB ring on his middle finger just to show it to you.
 

MaineBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,005
Reaction score
1,904
Splain it to me, lucy. One questionable call last week. But it could have gone either way. Today, brown, smith, collins, lve, lee and jarwin not playing. 3 fumbles early. Two rookie tackles. And he still coaches us to a win. What dumb decisions? I don't get it. Please, splain it to me Lucy.

I’ll Splain it to you. We won in spite of MM. if just one of the Falcons had fallen on the ball this was a loss. We won because the players kept making plays and the falcons made a mistake you will probably never see in the nfl for the next 50 years. MM ? For his part he made at least 2 stupid coaching calls that should have cost us the game: giving them 3 points off of that stupid last fake punt that was so predictable and desperate, and the moronic call to go for two and leave them 9 points behind at the end instead of being able to tie with our last touchdown. Those were amazingly dumb decisions the Falcons saved us from.
 

cern

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,900
Reaction score
21,050
2 horrible 4th down calls. And an awful decision going for 2 point conversion too early leaving us 2 scores down.

If not for Falcons unbelievably not falling on onside kick we’d be reeling at 0-2.

We didn’t win this game. Atlanta gave it away.
Doesn't seem to matter the thread. You show up and start trolling. Las herramientas pertenecen al cobertizo.
 

JayFord

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,526
Reaction score
21,218
Garrett is gone

and No McCarthy isnt worse...hes been here two games with an abbreviated offseason

And I disagree with alot of his decision making but hes trying to win i can deal with it
 

Floatyworm

The Labeled One
Messages
21,297
Reaction score
19,285
2 horrible 4th down calls. And an awful decision going for 2 point conversion too early leaving us 2 scores down.

If not for Falcons unbelievably not falling on onside kick we’d be reeling at 0-2.

We didn’t win this game. Atlanta gave it away.

:hammer:
 

cern

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,900
Reaction score
21,050
I’ll Splain it to you. We won in spite of MM. if just one of the Falcons had fallen on the ball this was a loss. We won because the players kept making plays and the falcons made a mistake you will probably never see in the nfl for the next 50 years. MM ? For his part he made at least 2 stupid coaching calls that should have cost us the game: giving them 3 points off of that stupid last fake punt that was so predictable and desperate, and the moronic call to go for two and leave them 9 points behind at the end instead of being able to tie with our last touchdown. Those were amazingly dumb decisions the Falcons saved us from.
And the fact he kept the players heads in the game and won count as for nothing. Both starting tackles out. Two starting lb's out. Starting cb out. Starting te gone for year. Counts for nothing? Ay dios mio.
 

visionary

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,432
Reaction score
31,767
2 games in....and I'm already ready to move on. Some of the dumbest decisions I can recall. I seriously don't know who is in charge. We should be 0-2. Not gonna say I miss Garrett...because change had to be made.....but come on man...this wasn't what I had in mind. There had to be over a dozen questionable decisions in this game.

Comments? :popcorn:

LOL :facepalm:
 
Top