Do we win that game with JG?

snadler · Sep 20, 2020

Today was such a horribly coached game, and this isn’t a compliment to this staff, but just curious what everyone thinks would have happened if JG was coach..based on been there done that, under JG there were several awful performances followed by great comebacks always fo fall short with the moral victory nonsense

JayFord · Sep 20, 2020

No.....

TheMarathonContinues · Sep 20, 2020

Nope. Not at all. JG isn't losing the turnover battle and winning a game. No way.

ShortRound · Sep 20, 2020

lol, I can't

Jake · Sep 20, 2020

snadler said:
Today was such a horribly coached game, and this isn’t a compliment to this staff, but just curious what everyone thinks would have happened if JG was coach..based on been there done that, under JG there were several awful performances followed by great comebacks always fo fall short with the moral victory nonsense

The Cowboys overcame a 21 point deficit to beat the Rams 34-31 in 2014. Guess who was the coach then.

McCarthy made as many dumb decisions today as JG ever made. The players won in spite of them rather than because of him.

ChronicCowboy · Sep 20, 2020

JG had plenty of comeback wins here....his issue was making the team consistent. So far MM is having the same issue.

CATCH17 · Sep 20, 2020

Lol who knows.

It’s not like good coaching won us the game today.

cowboyec · Sep 20, 2020

Zman5 · Sep 20, 2020

I doubt it. JG had hard time winning games with key starters out. We had 3 starters on offense out in this game.

JoeyBoy718 · Sep 20, 2020

What did McCarthy do that was so brilliant that Garrett couldn't have done?

big dog cowboy · Sep 20, 2020

cowboyec · Sep 20, 2020

this team has mounting injuries and did exactly what we've been asking them to do...find a way and win.
they did.
hats off to'm.

cowboyec · Sep 20, 2020

JoeyBoy718 said:
What did McCarthy do that was so brilliant that Garrett couldn't have done?

survive and advance.

Gangsta Spanksta · Sep 20, 2020

Yes we would. Atlanta gave us that win, not any player on our team or the coaching.

cern · Sep 20, 2020

No way Garrett wins.

CowboyRoy · Sep 20, 2020

Jake said:
The Cowboys overcame a 21 point deficit to beat the Rams 34-31 in 2014. Guess who was the coach then.

McCarthy made as many dumb decisions today as JG ever made. The players won in spite of them rather than because of him.

true but in the end it was Zuerlein and the onside kick idea that won the game. Garrett would have never prioritized Zuerlein and our special teams coach would have stayed the same.

snadler · Sep 20, 2020

JoeyBoy718 said:
What did McCarthy do that was so brilliant that Garrett couldn't have done?

If you read my post, I never actually gave credit to the coaching staff for anything, flat out said they were terrible..my question was would they have won the game with JG as coach, seemed like there were many comebacks with him as coach but something would always back fire at the end to still get the L, that didn’t happen today..

cityochamps · Sep 20, 2020

I wise individual said this after JG's firing:

Garrett’s inability to adjust doomed him
Garrett was great at devising game plans to suit the pieces he had. But when dynamic variables were added to the mix, his effectiveness nosedived. The often robotic head coach struggled to deviate from his blueprints when opponents presented unforeseen challenges that forced him into uncomfortable situations.

and..

I would simply add JG would have folded like a

visionary · Sep 20, 2020

Hell NO

Aven8 · Sep 20, 2020

Lol, no......JG won’t take chances....at least Mike Will right or wrong.

Do we win that game with JG?

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Beyond tired of Jerry

Well-Known Member

1st Round Pick

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

THE BIG DOG

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

What Just Happened Here

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member