It’s time to move on from Tyron Smith

Irvin88_4life said:

So you use Garrett as an excuse with Romo but not Dak even though Romo had multiple coaches besides Garrett....

You are special Haha

Click to expand...

When was Garrett play caller here? How’s Garrett doing with the Giants as actually play caller?

I know math may be hard for you..

grgnfg420 said:

this guy has become way too unreliable in the last couple of years. I don’t remember him ever having a season where he played all 16 games, not to mention he’s guaranteed at least 2 penalties a game. There’s no doubt we need to address the Oline in the next draft and I think it’s time to start looking for smiths replacement...

Thoughts?

Click to expand...

we have said that for several year. he is great when healthy, but as everyone says hasn't been healthy lately. so I don't disagree that we should find his replacement. however, there is only so much capital (money and picks) to go around. where would tackle be in our priorities? we needed CBs, TEs, LBs, Saftey, DT, DEs and Tackles..... where is the priority? where do you spend your capital. where do you spend prized capital (1,2, 3 round picks). should we have not drafted CD and draft a tackle? should we have not drafted Diggs? this is not just add tackle to the list and go shopping, there is alternatives to consider. and part of the consideration is if we don't draft a tackle, then what do we do (we have smith and collins). if we draft a tackle (lets say in second round) and we need CB what do we do....and then of course there is the cap. should we have signed Jones? then perhaps there was no Cooper (without knowing we would get CD)

no doubt, we should look for Smith eventual replacement. but there were other needs IMHO that needed to be addresses with far worse alternatives.

Yeaaah no

khiladi said:

Wow.. 1 game... Why not tally his whole record, including how he absolutely blew against the Jets for example last year. When he sucks, then everybody else is blamed, including Smith not playing, except for Dak..

and he did in the ‘second half’ when Dallas went up tempo and he was making 1 read throws, in time of desperation.. yippee.. “Desperate Dak” back at it again..

Click to expand...

Doin alright today too

OldCoach said:

The time to move on is in the draft. Not right now

Click to expand...

That’s what I said in the draft we need to find his replacement

grgnfg420 said:

Doin alright today too

Click to expand...

Yeah, the pass blocking is good... What’s your point?

khiladi said:

Yeah, the pass blocking is good... What’s your point?

Click to expand...

That Smith has to go

grgnfg420 said:

That Smith has to go

Click to expand...

So you think multiple years of dominance should be thrown away because of some decent pass blocking the last two weeks?

What just happened the last play?

khiladi said:

So you think multiple years of dominance should be thrown away because of some decent pass blocking the last two weeks? What just happened the last play?

Click to expand...

lol I don’t know I’m having s cigarette was it blindside sack?

grgnfg420 said:

this guy has become way too unreliable in the last couple of years. I don’t remember him ever having a season where he played all 16 games, not to mention he’s guaranteed at least 2 penalties a game. There’s no doubt we need to address the Oline in the next draft and I think it’s time to start looking for smiths replacement...

Thoughts?

Click to expand...

LOL.

If he comes back this year for 10,11 games at his usual level I don’t think it’s the dumbest idea to see what he could get on the market.....not actively shop him but listen if another team calls and asks.

you’re not going to find a player as good as him but if you can get good value for him I don’t think it’s a terrible idea to move on esrlier than later. His body is breaking down

grgnfg420 said:

this guy has become way too unreliable in the last couple of years. I don’t remember him ever having a season where he played all 16 games, not to mention he’s guaranteed at least 2 penalties a game. There’s no doubt we need to address the Oline in the next draft and I think it’s time to start looking for smiths replacement...

Thoughts?

Click to expand...

Honestly there are several players they need to move on from. I personally think Tank Lawrence is not even close to his contract worth. They need to retire Sean Lee and make Vander fragile a rotational backup. They need to move Jaylon Smith to MLB and draft two OLB. The secondary really needs to be re-built completely. The only piece I like is Diggs the rest I dont care about. The other weakness that actually use to be our strength is OL. We need two OL and retool this OL. Personally this season I want to see Badass in there at Center more than Looney. We need to see if he is one of our new starters or not. Looney is on borrowed time anyway.

He is the Sean Lee of the offensive line.

The time to move on is when you have a replacement. I don't see one on the roster.....

Agree with OP