DiNucci Benched after one game!

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,039
Reaction score
46,528
So you think after one game with not a single pre season game you’ve seen what he can be?
Would you have liked this first game from him
17 of 35 (48.6 percent) for 180 yards, zero touchdowns, two interceptions, two sacks and a passer rating of 40.2.?
He clearly doesn't deserve to be starting. He got his opportunity, and he crapped the bed. He deserves to be benched and possibly not kept on the team if Gilbert or Rush show more.
 

conner01

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,926
Reaction score
25,831
He clearly doesn't deserve to be starting. He got his opportunity, and he crapped the bed. He deserves to be benched and possibly not kept on the team if Gilbert or Rush show more.
Those are Troy Aikmans first game
Ben wasn’t suppose to be starting
If he was ready to start in the nfl he wouldn’t have been there in the 7th round
 

OmerV

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,899
Reaction score
22,430
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
What a clown show....

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id...tt-gilbert-cooper-rush-qb-pittsburgh-steelers

"With the opponent we are playing, we need more experience," McCarthy said Wednesday.
How is it hard for you to imagine, and how do you find it unreasonable, that the Cowboys wouldn't want to continue with a 7th round rookie who clearly isn't ready for the big stage?

You act like DiNucci earned the starting position and the Cowboys are snatching it away after one game, but the reality is he was just the guy left standing after injuries to 2 other players, and the team never actually expected or wanted him to play this season.
 

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,039
Reaction score
46,528
Those are Troy Aikmans first game
Ben wasn’t suppose to be starting
If he was ready to start in the nfl he wouldn’t have been there in the 7th round
Dak was a late 4th round pick, yet he lit it up since his very first preseason game in 2016. Then continued such performance thereafter.
 

waving monkey

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,540
Reaction score
14,930
I think every body knows whats going down. There is no pressure and there shouldn't be.
 

Canada180

bannedontherun88
Messages
937
Reaction score
930
I just watched some clips of Gilbert. They were from college albeit but he looks like he has a good arm . Decent in the clips anyway.
 

TwistedL0g1k

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,026
Reaction score
3,086
How is it hard for you to imagine, and how do you find it unreasonable, that the Cowboys wouldn't want to continue with a 7th round rookie who clearly isn't ready for the big stage?

I don't "find it unreasonable". The decision to make a change now is understandable, and is not the subject of my criticism.

You act like DiNucci earned the starting position and the Cowboys are snatching it away after one game, but the reality is he was just the guy left standing after injuries to 2 other players, and the team never actually expected or wanted him to play this season.

I agree that the team probably never expected him to play this season. Yet, he was on the active roster, and deemed capable of playing. Often, teams have to resort to their 3rd string QB. The Cowboys have been lucky in recent years taking the very risky approach of keeping only 2 QB's. A player on the active roster should be capable of, well... actually PLAYING. I don't blame DiNucci, I blame a coaching staff that has mis-evaluated, and a GM that has underinvested.

Green Bay fields one of the league's best QB's (a first rounder), yet they used their recent first round pick on another QB. The Cowboys GM on the other hand, has invested a total of one late fourth round pick, and a seventh round pick, in the most important position on the team. Pretty clear which approach is more successful.
 

conner01

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,926
Reaction score
25,831
Dak was a late 4th round pick, yet he lit it up since his very first preseason game in 2016. Then continued such performance thereafter.
He also got a full training camp and off season
And he is the exception
I don’t know if Denucci can develope but writing off any player after one game is silly
By that Troy Aikman would have been sent packing his first game
 

cern

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,900
Reaction score
21,050
He's not being benched. He's being spared.
 

Blackrain

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,587
Reaction score
9,199
He clearly doesn't deserve to be starting. He got his opportunity, and he crapped the bed. He deserves to be benched and possibly not kept on the team if Gilbert or Rush show more.
Agreed AC this young man does not possess the very basics . Arm strength no Pocket awareness no internal time clock positively not . Strange throwing motion check . He is capable of handing the ball off but we need more than that LOL
 

Brax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,398
Reaction score
7,091
Far be it from me to defend the circus that is the Dallas Cowboys, but anyone who couldn't see that Dinucci is nowhere close to being ready to play in the NFL is blind.
Guess Jerry , MM, KM are all blind too.
 

Big_D

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,895
Reaction score
14,926
He had no business being out there. It was way too soon and he just isn't ready.
 

lostar2009

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,870
Reaction score
3,486
They should let him play another 2 games. Benching him then brining in bums from the street is not good.
 

RonnieT24

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,521
Reaction score
21,601
In which month were they able to see him during a game? Preseason? How many preseason games were there this year?

Yeah I don't know why people want to ignore that this was the first live bullets the kid has faced in the NFL. There is a long list of guys who can "sling it" in practice when they're not allowed to tackle you or playing 7 on 7. I bet I could go to an NFL practice and look halfway decent throwing in 7 on 7 with no rush. It's different when the defenders have a license to break you in half. And you cannot simulate it in practice no matter how hard you try.
When I was in high school we had full team scrimmage every Wednesday night. First team offense vs first team defense for what amounted to one quarter. About 15 minutes.. scoreboard clock.. chains, refs (the assistant coaches and trainers) the whole nine .. It was as spirited and competitive as you could get in practice..We loved it.. no.. we lived for it. College scouts frequently showed up at these scrimmages.. (21 guys that I played with in high school went on to play college ball 11 at D1 schools 6 more at 1-AA..). Two others turned down scholarships to join the military because they had too many kids by graduation.. Yeah.. apparently being a football star makes you popular with the ladies.. Who knew!?!? We were loaded.. and for most games the competition at practice was tougher than what we would see on Friday night. With all that though.. it still went up a notch or three come game time. That's just the way it is..
 
Top