Do you as a fan want Gilbert or Dalton to start the next game?

Buzzbait · Nov 16, 2020

cowboyec said:
Gilbert.
he seems to have a better arm and release to me.
let him finish the remainder.

Agree, I do think Gilbert appears to have a better arm, but I also saw him throw maybe 3 incomplete passes into a crowd, could easily have been picked Course the same could be said for Dalton about the picks.
Gilbert was more exciting to watch.

buybuydandavis · Nov 16, 2020

DandyDon52 said:
I for one want Gilbert to start, it would be more interesting and fun, whether they win or lose.
With Dalton, just hard to get up for that at all. And it wont be fun to watch at all.

I'm playing for next year.

Play Gibert. He's with the team next year. Dalton might win an extra game or two and cost us big in the draft.

ghst187 · Nov 16, 2020

Gilbert. Dalton showed me nothing thus far. He might be a tinge better than Gilbert but Gilbert can still get better and might prove to be a decent backup moving forward and now he’d have starting experience

InTheZone · Nov 17, 2020

would prefer to see Dalton, think he can still do good with half decent blocking.

Hoofbite · Nov 17, 2020

Anyone but Dalton, I guess.

I know the team has to play the "best chance to win" nonsense, but let's get serious for a second. The entire NFCE should be a race to the bottom just so you don't have to be the poor soul that gets absolutely embarrassed in the 1st round.

I don't know if Dalton is best or worst for winning or losing at this point. What I can say say is that I'm confident he'll just check everything down because he's seasoned enough to do it when a WR isn't wide open. With a lack of a skill available, I'll roll with a youthful lack of experience just because things will likely be less boring. One of the other randos might be dumb enough to let it fly.

America's Cowboy · Nov 17, 2020

JoeKing · Nov 17, 2020

Garrett Gilbert is Dak's backup next season. I think they should be giving him the starts now so he can be getting valuable experience.

Cowboys22 · Nov 17, 2020

This is what Dalton was signed for so it should be him for a few more games. If he doesn't play well then they should go to Gilbert as he looks like he could be a very good backup QB to hang on to for several years.

foofighters · Nov 17, 2020

DandyDon52 said:
I for one want Gilbert to start, it would be more interesting and fun, whether they win or lose.
With Dalton, just hard to get up for that at all. And it wont be fun to watch at all.

So just wondering if anyone else wants Gilbert to start, and did he make the game more fun and exciting to watch for you?
I cant do a poll, so maybe someone else could do that.

Here's how I look at it. I am in Iowa City for the weekend to see our daughter. We are traveling home Sunday afternoon. If Gilbert is starting, my wife is driving and I am watching the game on my iPad. If Dalton is starting, I am driving and listening to music all the way home and I'll check the scores when I get home.

blueblood70 · Nov 17, 2020

why does this matter so much? it does NOT MATTER whos playing qb if it isnt dak!

so insane the veracity in which those want a one game nfl starter who was a bust until now over a proven veteran yet fans all over the zone go out of their way to rip players like Zeke and Jaylon..right pull for backup QB yet go out of your way to start posts and destroy players on this team that have been drafted and worn the Star and had big time success in this league including the coaches..right pull for Gilbert rip the real cowboys..

par for the course in the zone.. :facepalm:

we live in opposite land the black mirror is 2020 ughh :thumbdown:

Frozen700 · Nov 17, 2020

CATCH17 said:
Denucci. Not joking.

This....

I want to lose out.

#DontpayDak

DandyDon52 · Nov 17, 2020

blueblood70 said:
why does this matter so much? it does NOT MATTER whos playing qb if it isnt dak!

so insane the veracity in which those want a one game nfl starter who was a bust until now over a proven veteran yet fans all over the zone go out of their way to rip players like Zeke and Jaylon..right pull for backup QB yet go out of your way to start posts and destroy players on this team that have been drafted and worn the Star and had big time success in this league including the coaches..right pull for Gilbert rip the real cowboys..

par for the course in the zone..

we live in opposite land the black mirror is 2020 ughh

it evidently matters to you lol. Or you wouldnt come into this thread and post the above.
people like/dislike different things, can you not grasp that concept?

blueblood70 · Nov 17, 2020

DandyDon52 said:
it evidently matters to you lol. Or you wouldnt come into this thread and post the above.
people like/dislike different things, can you not grasp that concept?

it doesnt matter but im going with the coaches they are real ACTUAL NFL coaches, not fake gm coach zone posters who believe they know what best for the team..

so theres that..lmao

BourbonBalz · Nov 17, 2020

Gilbert. We need to see if he can be the long term backup. At this point, playing Dalton does nothing for us. He won’t be here next year.

Cowfan75 · Nov 17, 2020

You play the guy who gives you the best chance to win. Unless you are Jerry Jones, in which case you play whoever is making more money. The team responded to Gilbert. There isn't one player who looked like they wanted to be out there in Andy's last game. I know desire doesn't necessarily equal talent, but they played like a team against Pitt, and if we hadn't gotten Jaylon'd again, we may very well win the game.

EST_1986 · Nov 17, 2020

need a better draft pick so Dalton

Ranched · Nov 17, 2020

Hard to believe Dalton is such a bust. Everyone (including myself)
thought he was the best backup available.

Hennessy_King · Nov 17, 2020

Gilbert. Play the young guy maybe we can keep him longer on the cheap as a backup. Dalton is gone after this year

LovinItAll · Nov 24, 2020

CordovaRaider said:
Gilbert played as good as Dak would have played against the Steelers; if you let him take a couple more games to see if the Steelers game was a fluke (or not), it might end up saving you $40M worth of cap space and then you could go draft you either Fields or Lawrence to backup Gilbert next year while you rebuild the o-line and defense. It makes too much sense for Jerry to do this but I’m giving GG 2-3 more games.

21/38 for 243, 1/1. Not sure why you think that's as good as Dak would have played against the Steelers. Dak was averaging well over 300/game before he was hurt, with a better than 2:1 TD/Int ratio (I know that's not great, but it's better than 1:1).

Nobody can say how any player might have played in a particular game, so the only thing we can look at is past performance. Based on that, Dak would've played much better than Gilbert.

McKDaddy · Nov 24, 2020

Dalton should get a chance for revenge. Goes against my desire for better draft picks but it is what it is.

Bigger issue is that the team should look up Mr. Bostic and make an example out of him. Then you have a team playing together and sending a message that they can hand out "fines" too.

Do you as a fan want Gilbert or Dalton to start the next game?

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Diehard

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Star4Ever

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

"We Are Penn State"

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member