Sports myths

Bobhaze

Staff member
Messages
16,538
Reaction score
63,395
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
One of the definitions of a myth is a widely held but false belief or idea. We fans are all at least occasionally guilty of believing in sports myths- things that are based more on hope than reality for things we deeply want to believe. Sports myths often blind us as fans to sports reality.

Here are some commonly held fan sports myths we often see:
  • Popular former players with no coaching experience can immediately become an offensive or defensive coordinator or even head coach. Example: Tony Romo’s good work as a TV analyst doesn’t mean he is immediately qualified to be an offensive coordinator with zero coaching experience. Being an effective coordinator in the NFL is much harder than it looks. It’s requires at least some prior coaching experience.
  • Team friendly” contracts for players we want to see stay in Dallas for less money than they could get on the market. Examples: Dak Prescott should forego what the market says a QB is worth and settle for less money to help the team. Or any other Cowboys veteran who is about to need a new contract. Thinking a player should sacrifice their market value to stay with the home team is unfair to the players whose ability to make top sports dollars is extremely brief.
  • Great players can mentor or teach younger players how to be like them. Athletic greatness is very difficult to teach at this level. And great players rarely make great coaches. Many great coaches on the other hand were often not themselves among the greatest players. Probably because they had to work harder at being successful on the field, they are better at teaching that than those whose greatness was easier.
  • The refs and the rest of the NFL are out to get us every week as a part of a grand conspiracy- I will just leave it at that. It still amazes me how many people believe this. Sure we get bad calls. But bad calls are pretty much “equal opportunity” in the NFL.
What are some other sports myths commonly held?
 

Parcells4Life

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,498
Reaction score
9,346
One of the definitions of a myth is a widely held but false belief or idea. We fans are all at least occasionally guilty of believing in sports myths- things that are based more on hope than reality for things we deeply want to believe. Sports myths often blind us as fans to sports reality.

Here are some commonly held fan sports myths we often see:
  • Popular former players with no coaching experience can immediately become an offensive or defensive coordinator or even head coach. Example: Tony Romo’s good work as a TV analyst doesn’t mean he is immediately qualified to be an offensive coordinator with zero coaching experience. Being an effective coordinator in the NFL is much harder than it looks. It’s requires at least some prior coaching experience.
  • Team friendly” contracts for players we want to see stay in Dallas for less money than they could get on the market. Examples: Dak Prescott should forego what the market says a QB is worth and settle for less money to help the team. Or any other Cowboys veteran who is about to need a new contract. Thinking a player should sacrifice their market value to stay with the home team is unfair to the players whose ability to make top sports dollars is extremely brief.
  • Great players can mentor or teach younger players how to be like them. Athletic greatness is very difficult to teach at this level. And great players rarely make great coaches. Many great coaches on the other hand were often not themselves among the greatest players. Probably because they had to work harder at being successful on the field, they are better at teaching that than those whose greatness was easier.
  • The refs and the rest of the NFL are out to get us every week as a part of a grand conspiracy- I will just leave it at that. It still amazes me how many people believe this. Sure we get bad calls. But bad calls are pretty much “equal opportunity” in the NFL.
What are some other sports myths commonly held?
The Cowboys front office is trash at drafting - Drafted 13 pro bowlers in last 10 years. Average 1.3 per draft. Also have numerous guys like Hitchens, Lee, Crawford, Harris etc, that have played 8 years in the league.
 

Jipper

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,004
Reaction score
21,571
The Cowboys front office is trash at drafting - Drafted 13 pro bowlers in last 10 years. Average 1.3 per draft. Also have numerous guys like Hitchens, Lee, Crawford, Harris etc, that have played 8 years in the league.

hate to tell you but you have no idea what you are talking about here, Dallas has actually been one of the very best at extracting value out of where they draft...it’s not all about pro bowl it’s about getting the most you can with the draft capital you have...I will say we have been very bad with free agency though...check out the article below it might help you see a different pov

and btw...Dallas is 2nd in the most pro bowlers drafted in the last decade...

https://www.footballoutsiders.com/stat-analysis/2020/nfl-drafting-efficiency-2010-2019
 

Hawkeye0202

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,267
Reaction score
42,868
Good post OP!

One I might also add is popular or HOF players making being a good pregame analyst. Two examples that stand out are Joe Montana and Emmitt Smith.

BTW: Notice how rare great player and coach are used in the same sentence.
 

Parcells4Life

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,498
Reaction score
9,346
hate to tell you but you have no idea what you are talking about here, Dallas has actually been one of the very best at extracting value out of where they draft...it’s not all about pro bowl it’s about getting the most you can with the draft capital you have...I will say we have been very bad with free agency though...check out the article below it might help you see a different pov

and btw...Dallas is 2nd in the most pro bowlers drafted in the last decade...

https://www.footballoutsiders.com/stat-analysis/2020/nfl-drafting-efficiency-2010-2019
My point was the myth was they’re trash. They’re actually very good at it.
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,250
Reaction score
26,151
One of the definitions of a myth is a widely held but false belief or idea. We fans are all at least occasionally guilty of believing in sports myths- things that are based more on hope than reality for things we deeply want to believe. Sports myths often blind us as fans to sports reality.

Here are some commonly held fan sports myths we often see:
  • Popular former players with no coaching experience can immediately become an offensive or defensive coordinator or even head coach. Example: Tony Romo’s good work as a TV analyst doesn’t mean he is immediately qualified to be an offensive coordinator with zero coaching experience. Being an effective coordinator in the NFL is much harder than it looks. It’s requires at least some prior coaching experience.
  • Team friendly” contracts for players we want to see stay in Dallas for less money than they could get on the market. Examples: Dak Prescott should forego what the market says a QB is worth and settle for less money to help the team. Or any other Cowboys veteran who is about to need a new contract. Thinking a player should sacrifice their market value to stay with the home team is unfair to the players whose ability to make top sports dollars is extremely brief.
  • Great players can mentor or teach younger players how to be like them. Athletic greatness is very difficult to teach at this level. And great players rarely make great coaches. Many great coaches on the other hand were often not themselves among the greatest players. Probably because they had to work harder at being successful on the field, they are better at teaching that than those whose greatness was easier.
  • The refs and the rest of the NFL are out to get us every week as a part of a grand conspiracy- I will just leave it at that. It still amazes me how many people believe this. Sure we get bad calls. But bad calls are pretty much “equal opportunity” in the NFL.
What are some other sports myths commonly held?
I would look exclusively for quarterbacks who are married to supermodels who make more than them.

Then maybe they would take less salary and win all the time.

That's a big part of the "genius" up there in NE.

That's what Jerry figured he could coax Dak into lol.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
77,348
Reaction score
96,006
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
One of the definitions of a myth is a widely held but false belief or idea. We fans are all at least occasionally guilty of believing in sports myths- things that are based more on hope than reality for things we deeply want to believe. Sports myths often blind us as fans to sports reality.

Here are some commonly held fan sports myths we often see:
  • Popular former players with no coaching experience can immediately become an offensive or defensive coordinator or even head coach. Example: Tony Romo’s good work as a TV analyst doesn’t mean he is immediately qualified to be an offensive coordinator with zero coaching experience. Being an effective coordinator in the NFL is much harder than it looks. It’s requires at least some prior coaching experience.
  • Team friendly” contracts for players we want to see stay in Dallas for less money than they could get on the market. Examples: Dak Prescott should forego what the market says a QB is worth and settle for less money to help the team. Or any other Cowboys veteran who is about to need a new contract. Thinking a player should sacrifice their market value to stay with the home team is unfair to the players whose ability to make top sports dollars is extremely brief.
  • Great players can mentor or teach younger players how to be like them. Athletic greatness is very difficult to teach at this level. And great players rarely make great coaches. Many great coaches on the other hand were often not themselves among the greatest players. Probably because they had to work harder at being successful on the field, they are better at teaching that than those whose greatness was easier.
  • The refs and the rest of the NFL are out to get us every week as a part of a grand conspiracy- I will just leave it at that. It still amazes me how many people believe this. Sure we get bad calls. But bad calls are pretty much “equal opportunity” in the NFL.
What are some other sports myths commonly held?

I still say the refs are out to get us more so than others. You watch the games. We may get a game 1 out of 15 where we get a few calls.
Seems for years we have been on the short end of the stick and lost games way more that winning a game from bad calls.
Everyone knows it is true.

The first 3 points, spot on. I hope that many will realize come FA time in March.
They actually signed many top FA's names this past off-season. Many were happy they finally done so. But it did not work out, so they go back to Jerry bashing, not remembering they tried.
 

thunderpimp91

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,031
Reaction score
15,233
I'd argue the team friendly contracts one. I agree it doesn't happen very often, but didn't Cooper just take less money to stick in Dallas? It looks silly now, but even the Jayon Smith contract was considered a discount for the Cowboys at the time. I would never expect a player to take a discount, but Aside from that good list though.
 

thunderpimp91

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,031
Reaction score
15,233
I still say the refs are out to get us more so than others. You watch the games. We may get a game 1 out of 15 where we get a few calls.
Seems for years we have been on the short end of the stick and lost games way more that winning a game from bad calls.
Everyone knows it is true.

The first 3 points, spot on. I hope that many will realize come FA time in March.
They actually signed many top FA's names this past off-season. Many were happy they finally done so. But it did not work out, so they go back to Jerry bashing, not remembering they tried.

You could go on any teams forums and they will make the same argument against their team. I think it has more to do with how difficult the league has made the refs jobs than a bias against a team.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
77,348
Reaction score
96,006
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'd argue the team friendly contracts one. I agree it doesn't happen very often, but didn't Cooper just take less money to stick in Dallas? It looks silly now, but even the Jayon Smith contract was considered a discount for the Cowboys at the time. I would never expect a player to take a discount, but Aside from that good list though.

Unless you are Tom Brady and your wife makes more $$$ than you.
Plus the team funnels money to you in other ways, like contracting your company for services to circumvent the cap.
 

cern

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,900
Reaction score
21,050
you can mentor study habits. you can't mentor genetics. athletic ability is a product of genetics.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
77,348
Reaction score
96,006
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
You could go on any teams forums and they will make the same argument against their team. I think it has more to do with how difficult the league has made the refs jobs than a bias against a team.

True about the fans, but that will not convince me, GB and Pittsburgh get favored in calls and Dallas does not. You seen it.
Though I was very surprised Pittsburgh did not get any cals on that last drive Monday night. :laugh:
 
Top