Philly radio coaching rank

TheMarathonContinues

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
75,026
Reaction score
69,518
cowboyec said:
he's benefited almost his entire career from being in a horrible division.
easiest path of any one else.
yet the mighty undefeated unscored upon aaron rodgers has a .500 play off record post super bowl win and is 0-4 in conference title games?
and catches no heat for that?
not even on the cowboys fan message board?
no one.
not one single media mouth said after his super bowl win...well...thats it.
no more for the rest of his career.
they ALL proclaimed a brady like title run was coming.
and it didnt....despite year in and year out one of the best rosters in his conference.
brady accomplished more with less.
and rodgers catches a pass.
ALWAYS somebody elses fault.
Click to expand...
I agree with you 100%. Crazy the pass he gets...meanwhile, McCarthy has to live with Aaron being the only reason he has a SB ring. I'd love to see him get one here that would dead that talk.
 
J_Allen

J_Allen

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,885
Reaction score
5,667
Not impressed, especially when he hired his friend to coach defense.

You hire people because they can do the job and Mike Nolan has proven time and time again that he can't do the job. McCarthy should be on a very short leash after that stunt.
 
DandyDon52

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,412
Reaction score
15,461
blueblood70 said:
really!?!

Rivera wins the division with 7 wins against the Cowboys one of the most injury devastated teams in the league and Philly not far behind and the Gnats well are the giants BY ONE GAME and thats good?!,

lmao..get out of here with that mess.. Rivera got fired as well and hasn't done squat in five years one great season doesnt make either coach..they both have a lot to prove

the fact MM won 6 games with this mess even with some mistakes, i get it, is ridiculous to say he was terrible, a one game difference..

Its not like Rivera won 10 games he was 7-9 MM 6-10 and we had by far twice the injuries they had..thats good and MM is bad..???

dude park the hate in another spot, common sense they are about even all said and done and when they go head to head with an even roster we will have that tie broken.. Rivera should not be heralded for winning one more game then us, thats a negative man , common sense says open your blind eye and se they should have ran away with this division and took monumental injury list to the division for him to squeak out one more win.seriously??!

SMH

Ill say this, none ore the best..all have something to prove, period..the division was way down last year and no one had distinct coaching advantage..

all 5 teams were an embarrassment to the nfl last season , WFDT by default one game better at 7-9 is nothing to brag about, thats for sure..
Click to expand...
Well anyone can come up with excuses, but the bottom line is wash one the div not dallas, and they beat dallas twice.
They also played tampa better than anyone else did in playoffs.
Every team had the same conditions, and injury's are something a team has to deal with any season.

MM did one game better than JG when he lost romo for season, and his in game calls and game mgmt are what I look at more than losses.
player mgmt game plans, all that was awful for most of the games.
He was bad regardless of what the other coaches did last year, and I am only looking at last year, not what they did in the past on other teams.

Rivera was the best coach in the east last year, not saying he will be again this year, new year things change.
They all start off even.
 

kumizi

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,217
Reaction score
5,616
It'll take about 5 years before Cowboys fans figure out he sucks like it did for Garrett.
 
DandyDon52

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,412
Reaction score
15,461
Shake_Tiller said:
Objectively, McCarthy is the best until proven otherwise. He has the skin on the wall, and he has multiple playoff appearances.

Maybe one of these other coaches -- or more than one -- will surpass McCarthy. But we deal in the known rather than the unknown.

I like Rivera a lot. But I think he has become a bit overrated. He is a fine coach. I'm not sure you can say he maximized his opportunities.
Click to expand...
McCarthy is the best until proven otherwise. He has the skin on the wall, and he has multiple playoff appearances........only because he had Rodgers,
it was Rodgers doing all the winning, he is still winning and going to playoffs without mm.
Without Rodgers, MM would have been run out of GB long time ago.
 
DandyDon52

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,412
Reaction score
15,461
jterrell said:
lol.....

Mike McCarthy is easily the division's most proven Head Coach.
He's won 60% of his games and 10 playoff games.

Ron Rivera 54% of his games and 3 playoff games.

Philly doesn't even have a Head Coach. They hired a dude from the cheesesteak shop.
Giants have a ST Coach newly elevated.
Click to expand...
I think philly coach is going to surprise many people.
judd in NY, it was his first year, lost his main O weapon in barkley, so going to judge him by this coming season.
Had wash lost the last game, he would have won the div after beating our cowboys and the great MM.
 
blueblood70

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,456
Reaction score
26,911
DandyDon52 said:
Well anyone can come up with excuses, but the bottom line is wash one the div not dallas, and they beat dallas twice.
They also played tampa better than anyone else did in playoffs.
Every team had the same conditions, and injury's are something a team has to deal with any season.

MM did one game better than JG when he lost romo for season, and his in game calls and game mgmt are what I look at more than losses.
player mgmt game plans, all that was awful for most of the games.
He was bad regardless of what the other coaches did last year, and I am only looking at last year, not what they did in the past on other teams.

Rivera was the best coach in the east last year, not saying he will be again this year, new year things change.
They all start off even.
Click to expand...

excuse??! its an actual bonified fact,

losing all your front line starters all year and 4 qbs is not roster you expect to win with they didnt in philly, SF and other teams with the same devastation.. get it? excuse my arse bro, those are valid facts..yet you give some validity to rival a hated rival thats one one freaking game more and somehow that coach is miracle worker?? ..nah you have it backwards they got gift and thats all they did was 7-9..

when golden state lost most of their splash brothers they became lottery pick, odd isnt it? lmao you fabs who luv to whione and lay down false narratives are the issue..if you cnt see the logic in my statements, you are blind by natural hate for the jonses and the DC team of the last decade or two and really do not belong masquerading as fan because no matter what , you will be talking down the team..

:facepalm::angry::thumbdown::oldcouple:
 
blueblood70

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,456
Reaction score
26,911
Irvin88_4life said:
McCarthy only HC in the division with Superbowl ring
Click to expand...
and two NFCCG appearances

what has Rivera done the last 4 seasons or more in carolina? didnt he do nothing but lose before and after that sb LOSS? he did get fired IN SEASON did he not..odd fans somehow believe hes better coach..he only managed one game better then MM last season and MM played with a 3rd string roster..lmao..right rivera is king , king of terds!

Garett had better record and win% then rivera in the nFL, chew on that a bit then get back to me :)
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,943
Reaction score
91,587
Honestly, I'd go Rivera, McCarthy, Judge and Sirianni.

I thought Judge did a pretty good job last year but he's not ready to supplant the other two. Rivera was a guy the moment he was fired that I thought might be a good fit here but Washington snapped him up pretty early.
 
ChronicCowboy

ChronicCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,844
Reaction score
14,310
He’s a bad coach but I’d put him 2nd in the division by default. Judge and Sirianni haven’t proven anything.
 
Irvin88_4life

Irvin88_4life

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,445
Reaction score
26,294
blueblood70 said:
and two NFCCG appearances

what has Rivera done the last 4 seasons or more in carolina? didnt he do nothing but lose before and after that sb LOSS? he did get fired IN SEASON did he not..odd fans somehow believe hes better coach..he only managed one game better then MM last season and MM played with a 3rd string roster..lmao..right rivera is king , king of terds!

Garett had better record and win% then rivera in the nFL, chew on that a bit then get back to me :)
Click to expand...
Just like before the season started I watched YouTube have creators from all 4 division teams and they ranked Wentz, Haskins and Danny Jones ahead of Dak...... I have McCarthy as best HC followed by Ron. The other 2 have a ton to prove first before they get ranked higher.

You're absolutely right in what you said
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top