It Wasn't the Dirty Dozen That Took the Cowboys to Super Bowl 10

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,489
Reaction score
16,099
In 1974 the cowboys went 8-6, missing the playoffs for the first time in 9 seasons. Analysts and pundits eagerly declared an end to the Cowboy dynasty. Most of the players from the late 60's and early 70's had retired. The ones left were extremely long in tooth.

The legend goes that the Cowboys rookie class of 75 was responsible for zero years of reconstruction, their combined contributions provided the boost that propelled the team from a rebuilding project to the Super Bowl in just one season.

It's a fun story and it was exciting to watch these rookies contribute something. However, their play did not dominate Cowboy opponents except for special teams and an occasional defensive takeaway.

In fact, of the 12, there was only one starter, that is, one rookie that started over half of the games. This was Guard Burton Lawless.

The offensive stars in that 1975 season included 30 year old Preston Pearson, a former Pittsburgh Steeler. Many believe he was waived by the Steelers because he was their outspoken player rep. Calvin Hill left the Cowboys to join the new league and Garrison retired after suffering a rodeo injury during the offseason so they signed Pearson.

Pearson and FB Robert Newhouse were a 1-2 punch at RB, combining for 1439 yards rushing in a 14 game season as well as over 600 yards in receptions.

The WR squad was led by two year veteran and former undrafted rookie Drew Pearson. During the previous season, 1974, Drew was 1st team All Pro.

The offensive line was anchored by 30 year old Rayfield Wright and 31 year old Ralph Neely.

The QB was future HOFer 33 year old Roger Staubach. he was the #1 ranked passer in two of his last four seasons.

The defensive line was anchored by 31 year old Jethro Pugh. The starting LBers were 36 year old Dave Edwards, 34 year old Lee Roy Jordan and 30 year old D.D. Lewis. The defensive line was impacted by young bookend DE's drafted the two previous seasons, Harvey Martin and Ed "Too Tall" Jones.

The secondary included HOFer 34 year old Mel Renfro. Waters and Harris, the safeties, were both 27.

It was the MLB Jordan who led the defense in INT's with 6. Renfro followed with 4.

Randy White, the #2 overall pick in the draft was given jersey #54 to honor Chuck Howley who had just retired and was expected to reach the HOF. Randy, who had played DT in college was being converted to MLB and backed up Jordan. That was a mistake the team soon rectified, but not in 1975.

The other 1st round pick LB Thomas (Hollywood) Henderson didn't become a starter until his 3rd season in 1977. However, he did provide some fireworks when he returned a kickoff 97 yards for a TD...a linebacker.

Bob Breunig, their 3rd round pick, became the eventual replacement for Lee Roy Jordan the following season.

Offensive linemen Pat Donovan and Herbert Scott became eventual starters on the next generation of the Cowboy dynasty, Donovan in 1977, Scott in 1976.

The 8th rounder, punter Mitch Hoopes did become their starter that season.

The 7th rounder LB Mike Hegman would eventually start after the Cowboys cut Hollywood Henderson after the '78 season.

Although 4th rounder DB Randy Hughes did not start a game in 1975 he did contribute two INT's and 2 fumble recoveries during the regular season.

The 14th round pick, FB Scott Laidlaw, had three carries for ten yards in 1975.

This draft regenerated a dynasty and played an integral part during the Cowboys next seven seasons in which they played in 5 conference championship games and 2 Super Bowls. That is what they should be remembered for. The credit for the Cowboy's "rebuilding" season of 1975 belongs to those veterans, although they would admit that the excitement generated by their rookies was an inspiration.

The playoffs that season was dominated by big plays led by veterans Preston Pearson, Roger Staubach, Drew Pearson, D.D. Lewis and Mel Renfro.

One group that is often forgotten but must be recognized for this special season is the coaches, particularly special teams coach Mike Ditka, offensive backfield coach Dan Reeves, and defensive backfield coach Gene Stallings.

.........which brings me to this season and the reason for this post......

I'm seeing posts about what this year's rookie crop is going to bring to the Cowboys.....this season. It's possible. There could be a player that can just come in and dominate but it is highly unlikely. It just takes some time for players to acclimate to the NFL. I see Parsons and perhaps a D-lineman making some contributions as pass rushers. The 2022 season should be entirely different.

If the Cowboys are to succeed this season, it must come from the expected source. I'm talking about young players in their 2nd to 4th seasons. In 1975, it was the play of young guys like Drew Pearson, Robert Newhouse, Harvey Martin, Too Tall Jones, and Golden Richards.

We all have some high expectations from Cee Dee Lamb and rightfully so. Lamb must meet most of the reasonable expectations.

Biadasz must be a steady and dependable addition to the offensive line. He doesn't have to be great, just steady. Williams must continue to improve.

The passing game with Dak and the three receivers must dominate. Jarwin must contribute in addition to Schultz's steady improvement. Zeke has to realize that this season will define him.

One of the young DT's Gallimore or Hill must emerge. This is critical. I believe we will see Gallimore break out.

The LB's will be Smith and LVE, like it or not. They will not start Parsons at LB unless they do it later in the season. He is going to find out that his athleticism isn't enough in this league where everybody is fast. He must learn the position. As long as there is improvement by the DT's, these veteran LB's should rebound.

The same goes for all the rookie DB's. Starting guys who played little more than a dozen college games isn't going to happen but expect great things on special teams.

Just like 1975, this draft class is going to be special. It will provide quality defensive starters for many seasons, just not this one.

Finally, the coaches must teach. They have to devise thoughtful game plans, make great game time decisions. They must earn the respect of their team.
 

Jake

Beyond tired of Jerry
Messages
36,067
Reaction score
84,350
The 1974 Cowboys weren't as bad, or old, as their record suggested. The "Dirty Dozen" made for a nice story, but the core of the team was already in place.
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
35,535
Reaction score
31,011
Good post, I enjoyed reading it. I believe this coming season will be the learning curve that leads to a championship the following season.
 

Jake

Beyond tired of Jerry
Messages
36,067
Reaction score
84,350
Good post, I enjoyed reading it. I believe this coming season will be the learning curve that leads to a championship the following season.

Nothing in his post has anything to do with this season or next season. You and Rocky keep convincing yourselves that it's still the good old days, while an old oil man and his son play fantasy football with the Dallas Cowboys.

I believe this season will just be another of 25 years, and counting, of frustration. If only Booger & Son could channel the wisdom of Landry and Schramm.
 

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,489
Reaction score
16,099
The 1975 season was also assisted by an innovation devised by Tom Landry. The shotgun had been around for a while but Landry was the first to use the shotgun consistently on passing plays. He wanted to give Roger more time to assess the defense and increase his chances to escape the pass rush.

Staubach ran for over 300 yards that season.
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
35,535
Reaction score
31,011
Nothing in his post has anything to do with this season or next season. You and Rocky keep convincing yourselves that it's still the good old days, while an old oil man and his son play fantasy football with the Dallas Cowboys.

I believe this season will just be another of 25 years, and counting, of frustration. If only Booger & Son could channel the wisdom of Landry and Schramm.
The second half of the post was only about the current team. You would have us believe the following was never said...
.........which brings me to this season and the reason for this post......
So Jake, you have mud on your face for ignoring that. I believe the team is going in the right direction. Your issue with the Jones boys is exactly that... your issue. It extends no further than your own thick skull. Your frustration is unfortunate but as hard as you may try to infect others with it, it will not work. I'm excited about the coming season. I think the Cowboys will do very well in the next few years. So we can agree to disagree and leave that discussion alone.
 
Last edited:

StarBoyz83

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,278
Reaction score
11,838
Nothing in his post has anything to do with this season or next season. You and Rocky keep convincing yourselves that it's still the good old days, while an old oil man and his son play fantasy football with the Dallas Cowboys.

I believe this season will just be another of 25 years, and counting, of frustration. If only Booger & Son could channel the wisdom of Landry and Schramm.

Dallas hasn't been a contender since 07 and it's not changing soon. Maybe they can actually make changes but don't see it happening. Daks already had better teams than Romo and those teams are already gone for dak.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
In 1974 the cowboys went 8-6, missing the playoffs for the first time in 9 seasons. Analysts and pundits eagerly declared an end to the Cowboy dynasty. Most of the players from the late 60's and early 70's had retired. The ones left were extremely long in tooth.

The legend goes that the Cowboys rookie class of 75 was responsible for zero years of reconstruction, their combined contributions provided the boost that propelled the team from a rebuilding project to the Super Bowl in just one season.

It's a fun story and it was exciting to watch these rookies contribute something. However, their play did not dominate Cowboy opponents except for special teams and an occasional defensive takeaway.

In fact, of the 12, there was only one starter, that is, one rookie that started over half of the games. This was Guard Burton Lawless.

The offensive stars in that 1975 season included 30 year old Preston Pearson, a former Pittsburgh Steeler. Many believe he was waived by the Steelers because he was their outspoken player rep. Calvin Hill left the Cowboys to join the new league and Garrison retired after suffering a rodeo injury during the offseason so they signed Pearson.

Pearson and FB Robert Newhouse were a 1-2 punch at RB, combining for 1439 yards rushing in a 14 game season as well as over 600 yards in receptions.

The WR squad was led by two year veteran and former undrafted rookie Drew Pearson. During the previous season, 1974, Drew was 1st team All Pro.

The offensive line was anchored by 30 year old Rayfield Wright and 31 year old Ralph Neely.

The QB was future HOFer 33 year old Roger Staubach. he was the #1 ranked passer in two of his last four seasons.

The defensive line was anchored by 31 year old Jethro Pugh. The starting LBers were 36 year old Dave Edwards, 34 year old Lee Roy Jordan and 30 year old D.D. Lewis. The defensive line was impacted by young bookend DE's drafted the two previous seasons, Harvey Martin and Ed "Too Tall" Jones.

The secondary included HOFer 34 year old Mel Renfro. Waters and Harris, the safeties, were both 27.

It was the MLB Jordan who led the defense in INT's with 6. Renfro followed with 4.

Randy White, the #2 overall pick in the draft was given jersey #54 to honor Chuck Howley who had just retired and was expected to reach the HOF. Randy, who had played DT in college was being converted to MLB and backed up Jordan. That was a mistake the team soon rectified, but not in 1975.

The other 1st round pick LB Thomas (Hollywood) Henderson didn't become a starter until his 3rd season in 1977. However, he did provide some fireworks when he returned a kickoff 97 yards for a TD...a linebacker.

Bob Breunig, their 3rd round pick, became the eventual replacement for Lee Roy Jordan the following season.

Offensive linemen Pat Donovan and Herbert Scott became eventual starters on the next generation of the Cowboy dynasty, Donovan in 1977, Scott in 1976.

The 8th rounder, punter Mitch Hoopes did become their starter that season.

The 7th rounder LB Mike Hegman would eventually start after the Cowboys cut Hollywood Henderson after the '78 season.

Although 4th rounder DB Randy Hughes did not start a game in 1975 he did contribute two INT's and 2 fumble recoveries during the regular season.

The 14th round pick, FB Scott Laidlaw, had three carries for ten yards in 1975.

This draft regenerated a dynasty and played an integral part during the Cowboys next seven seasons in which they played in 5 conference championship games and 2 Super Bowls. That is what they should be remembered for. The credit for the Cowboy's "rebuilding" season of 1975 belongs to those veterans, although they would admit that the excitement generated by their rookies was an inspiration.

The playoffs that season was dominated by big plays led by veterans Preston Pearson, Roger Staubach, Drew Pearson, D.D. Lewis and Mel Renfro.

One group that is often forgotten but must be recognized for this special season is the coaches, particularly special teams coach Mike Ditka, offensive backfield coach Dan Reeves, and defensive backfield coach Gene Stallings.

.........which brings me to this season and the reason for this post......

I'm seeing posts about what this year's rookie crop is going to bring to the Cowboys.....this season. It's possible. There could be a player that can just come in and dominate but it is highly unlikely. It just takes some time for players to acclimate to the NFL. I see Parsons and perhaps a D-lineman making some contributions as pass rushers. The 2022 season should be entirely different.

If the Cowboys are to succeed this season, it must come from the expected source. I'm talking about young players in their 2nd to 4th seasons. In 1975, it was the play of young guys like Drew Pearson, Robert Newhouse, Harvey Martin, Too Tall Jones, and Golden Richards.

We all have some high expectations from Cee Dee Lamb and rightfully so. Lamb must meet most of the reasonable expectations.

Biadasz must be a steady and dependable addition to the offensive line. He doesn't have to be great, just steady. Williams must continue to improve.

The passing game with Dak and the three receivers must dominate. Jarwin must contribute in addition to Schultz's steady improvement. Zeke has to realize that this season will define him.

One of the young DT's Gallimore or Hill must emerge. This is critical. I believe we will see Gallimore break out.

The LB's will be Smith and LVE, like it or not. They will not start Parsons at LB unless they do it later in the season. He is going to find out that his athleticism isn't enough in this league where everybody is fast. He must learn the position. As long as there is improvement by the DT's, these veteran LB's should rebound.

The same goes for all the rookie DB's. Starting guys who played little more than a dozen college games isn't going to happen but expect great things on special teams.

Just like 1975, this draft class is going to be special. It will provide quality defensive starters for many seasons, just not this one.

Finally, the coaches must teach. They have to devise thoughtful game plans, make great game time decisions. They must earn the respect of their team.

Great post, but I disagree about Parsons. Think he starts from day #1 and makes an impact. I would also bet that Joseph is starting by at least the 2nd half of the season.
 

john van brocklin

Captain Comeback
Messages
38,320
Reaction score
43,199
In 1974 the cowboys went 8-6, missing the playoffs for the first time in 9 seasons. Analysts and pundits eagerly declared an end to the Cowboy dynasty. Most of the players from the late 60's and early 70's had retired. The ones left were extremely long in tooth.

The legend goes that the Cowboys rookie class of 75 was responsible for zero years of reconstruction, their combined contributions provided the boost that propelled the team from a rebuilding project to the Super Bowl in just one season.

It's a fun story and it was exciting to watch these rookies contribute something. However, their play did not dominate Cowboy opponents except for special teams and an occasional defensive takeaway.

In fact, of the 12, there was only one starter, that is, one rookie that started over half of the games. This was Guard Burton Lawless.

The offensive stars in that 1975 season included 30 year old Preston Pearson, a former Pittsburgh Steeler. Many believe he was waived by the Steelers because he was their outspoken player rep. Calvin Hill left the Cowboys to join the new league and Garrison retired after suffering a rodeo injury during the offseason so they signed Pearson.

Pearson and FB Robert Newhouse were a 1-2 punch at RB, combining for 1439 yards rushing in a 14 game season as well as over 600 yards in receptions.

The WR squad was led by two year veteran and former undrafted rookie Drew Pearson. During the previous season, 1974, Drew was 1st team All Pro.

The offensive line was anchored by 30 year old Rayfield Wright and 31 year old Ralph Neely.

The QB was future HOFer 33 year old Roger Staubach. he was the #1 ranked passer in two of his last four seasons.

The defensive line was anchored by 31 year old Jethro Pugh. The starting LBers were 36 year old Dave Edwards, 34 year old Lee Roy Jordan and 30 year old D.D. Lewis. The defensive line was impacted by young bookend DE's drafted the two previous seasons, Harvey Martin and Ed "Too Tall" Jones.

The secondary included HOFer 34 year old Mel Renfro. Waters and Harris, the safeties, were both 27.

It was the MLB Jordan who led the defense in INT's with 6. Renfro followed with 4.

Randy White, the #2 overall pick in the draft was given jersey #54 to honor Chuck Howley who had just retired and was expected to reach the HOF. Randy, who had played DT in college was being converted to MLB and backed up Jordan. That was a mistake the team soon rectified, but not in 1975.

The other 1st round pick LB Thomas (Hollywood) Henderson didn't become a starter until his 3rd season in 1977. However, he did provide some fireworks when he returned a kickoff 97 yards for a TD...a linebacker.

Bob Breunig, their 3rd round pick, became the eventual replacement for Lee Roy Jordan the following season.

Offensive linemen Pat Donovan and Herbert Scott became eventual starters on the next generation of the Cowboy dynasty, Donovan in 1977, Scott in 1976.

The 8th rounder, punter Mitch Hoopes did become their starter that season.

The 7th rounder LB Mike Hegman would eventually start after the Cowboys cut Hollywood Henderson after the '78 season.

Although 4th rounder DB Randy Hughes did not start a game in 1975 he did contribute two INT's and 2 fumble recoveries during the regular season.

The 14th round pick, FB Scott Laidlaw, had three carries for ten yards in 1975.

This draft regenerated a dynasty and played an integral part during the Cowboys next seven seasons in which they played in 5 conference championship games and 2 Super Bowls. That is what they should be remembered for. The credit for the Cowboy's "rebuilding" season of 1975 belongs to those veterans, although they would admit that the excitement generated by their rookies was an inspiration.

The playoffs that season was dominated by big plays led by veterans Preston Pearson, Roger Staubach, Drew Pearson, D.D. Lewis and Mel Renfro.

One group that is often forgotten but must be recognized for this special season is the coaches, particularly special teams coach Mike Ditka, offensive backfield coach Dan Reeves, and defensive backfield coach Gene Stallings.

.........which brings me to this season and the reason for this post......

I'm seeing posts about what this year's rookie crop is going to bring to the Cowboys.....this season. It's possible. There could be a player that can just come in and dominate but it is highly unlikely. It just takes some time for players to acclimate to the NFL. I see Parsons and perhaps a D-lineman making some contributions as pass rushers. The 2022 season should be entirely different.

If the Cowboys are to succeed this season, it must come from the expected source. I'm talking about young players in their 2nd to 4th seasons. In 1975, it was the play of young guys like Drew Pearson, Robert Newhouse, Harvey Martin, Too Tall Jones, and Golden Richards.

We all have some high expectations from Cee Dee Lamb and rightfully so. Lamb must meet most of the reasonable expectations.

Biadasz must be a steady and dependable addition to the offensive line. He doesn't have to be great, just steady. Williams must continue to improve.

The passing game with Dak and the three receivers must dominate. Jarwin must contribute in addition to Schultz's steady improvement. Zeke has to realize that this season will define him.

One of the young DT's Gallimore or Hill must emerge. This is critical. I believe we will see Gallimore break out.

The LB's will be Smith and LVE, like it or not. They will not start Parsons at LB unless they do it later in the season. He is going to find out that his athleticism isn't enough in this league where everybody is fast. He must learn the position. As long as there is improvement by the DT's, these veteran LB's should rebound.

The same goes for all the rookie DB's. Starting guys who played little more than a dozen college games isn't going to happen but expect great things on special teams.

Just like 1975, this draft class is going to be special. It will provide quality defensive starters for many seasons, just not this one.

Finally, the coaches must teach. They have to devise thoughtful game plans, make great game time decisions. They must earn the respect of their team.
It was a great team and enjoyable to watch.
My first season as a Cowboy fan.
 

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,489
Reaction score
16,099
Great post, but I disagree about Parsons. Think he starts from day #1 and makes an impact. I would also bet that Joseph is starting by at least the 2nd half of the season.
I would love to be proven wrong on this issue. My concerns are mostly around him playing just two college seasons and neither of them in 2020.

His scouting reports say the usual things you would find in a very athletic but raw linebacker. He sometimes overshoots the play. He will sometimes use his speed in an attempt to sidestep a lead block. He can't catch, missed on some easy INT's.

These will be couched out and his athleticism is going to do some great things for the Cowboys in the future but Parsons lacks some basic fundamental skills at linebacker. Now, as far as pass rushing, I think he will be impactful this season once he acclimates to the NFL speed of a regular season game. However, it's going to take at least another year before we can trust him in the running game.
 

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,489
Reaction score
16,099
Dallas hasn't been a contender since 07 and it's not changing soon. Maybe they can actually make changes but don't see it happening. Daks already had better teams than Romo and those teams are already gone for dak.
Dak has already had better teams than Tony Romo? What criteria are you going by, team stats and rankings? I'm not saying Dak had better teams but if he did I would suggest that the greatest difference between those teams was their quarterback.

I'm not saying Dak is better than Romo but I am saying he was better than 75% Romo, 25% Romo's backup.

Better teams?

Romo had three perennial Pro Bowlers on his offensive line just like Dak had. Romo had Gurode, Adams, and Davis. Another great veteran was Marc Colombo.

Sure, Dak has some great receivers now. However, You can't snub your nose at TO, Miles Austin, and pre-Contract Dez. Romo had weapons.

Where is Dak's dependable All Pro, future HOFer at TE. Where is his Jason Witten? Would that be Dalton Schultz or the feeble over-the.hill version of Witten?

Which RB set the all time Cowboys record in rushing yards for a season?

Defense? The Pro Bowl studded defensive draft of 2005 is what we are hoping this year's draft will be like in the future but they haven't played a single down on a team quarterbacked by Dak. That 2005 draft class, however....

Dak had a defense that was top ten in yardage for three consecutive seasons, 2017 through 2019. Ditto for Romo, 2007 through 2009.

The Cowboys went 13-3 in 2007. In all, 12 Cowboys were Pro Bowl selections that season and 3 of them were 1st team All Pro. What team did Dak have that was better than that?
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
I would love to be proven wrong on this issue. My concerns are mostly around him playing just two college seasons and neither of them in 2020.

His scouting reports say the usual things you would find in a very athletic but raw linebacker. He sometimes overshoots the play. He will sometimes use his speed in an attempt to sidestep a lead block. He can't catch, missed on some easy INT's.

These will be couched out and his athleticism is going to do some great things for the Cowboys in the future but Parsons lacks some basic fundamental skills at linebacker. Now, as far as pass rushing, I think he will be impactful this season once he acclimates to the NFL speed of a regular season game. However, it's going to take at least another year before we can trust him in the running game.

Agreed he is a somewhat raw but they will live with those mistakes early and play him anyway.
 

Zekeats

theranchsucks
Messages
12,829
Reaction score
15,207
Good post, I enjoyed reading it. I believe this coming season will be the learning curve that leads to a championship the following season.
The usual delusional cowboy fan thinks the same year after year.
 

dwmyers

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,373
Reaction score
522
Randy White, the #2 overall pick in the draft was given jersey #54 to honor Chuck Howley who had just retired and was expected to reach the HOF. Randy, who had played DT in college was being converted to MLB and backed up Jordan. That was a mistake the team soon rectified, but not in 1975.

This is a little misleading. They were letting RW rush in obvious passing downs. I know, I was an active fan in 75. That said, he was really awkward as a MLB.

D-
 

Flamma

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,060
Reaction score
18,852
Good post, I enjoyed reading it. I believe this coming season will be the learning curve that leads to a championship the following season.

I like your enthusiasm. But going by the salary cap and players I think we'll be losing, 2022 is going to be a setback.
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
35,535
Reaction score
31,011
I like your enthusiasm. But going by the salary cap and players I think we'll be losing, 2022 is going to be a setback.
We all believe what we believe. I see this team going in the right direction. I expect my suspicions to be reaffirmed soon.
 

Flamma

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,060
Reaction score
18,852
We all believe what we believe. I see this team going in the right direction. I expect my suspicions to be reaffirmed soon.

Dude, I hope you're right. When it comes to this kind of stuff I am a negative piece of floating garbage in the south river. I just can't help but to focus on the negative and ignore the positive. I remember being absolutely certain the Cowboys would win 4-6 games in 2014.
 
Top