Is McCarthy the right coach?

He had his team ready to play.

His clock management skills kinda stink.

AmericanCowboy said:

Yesterday was our best performance against a really good team in a long time. If the ref calls the obvious PI call this is a different conversation.

Give kudos to MM for having the team ready to play.

Click to expand...

well said....

kevm3 said:

We went toe to toe with the Superbowl champs. He might not be the solution long term, but give him a shot.

Click to expand...

He will because it will take 4 to 5 years before his seat would get hot.

SoBlue128 said:

The FG attempt before half makes me question his in game decision making process.

Click to expand...

Did he not try a Hail Mary because of concern with Dak’s shoulder. Also if he made that kick, which he has done before, we possibly win that game!

And to think two years ago....we were begging for ANYONE....a squirrel or chipmunk.....to take over.

basel90 said:

Do you think he is like top tier coaches like beliceck for example ? Does he make a difference or just a bus driver ? The dallas Cowboys are the most valuable franchise in the world . Is MM the best option out there ? Or is this the type Jerry wants .

Click to expand...

no

WillieBeamen said:

I want Lincoln Riley

Click to expand...

no you don’t

Im not mad. They had the game but he has these guys ready to play as soon as the ball was kicked. The defense and offense never gave up the special teams let them down IMO. I'm not ready to jump ship on MM

Austin 3-16 said:

I stand corrected.

Click to expand...

Hey Austin 3-16, I understand your frustration though. But at least the BUCS didn't steamroll us.

the answer is NO he is not the right coach

basel90 said:

What did we see tonight , ? Not sure he is a difference maker coach or just a glorified bus driver with Kellen managing the offense and Quinn the defense, is MM a factor ?or is this how Jerry want it ?

Click to expand...

dude give it rest!!!!

yes hes the rights coach, hes our coache right now..so that the right one..nothig you say will change that and he will coach 2022 get used to it.,.hes in rebuilding mode or retooling mode with this team..

you do realize most NFL HCs are walk around hcs they dont call plays but they do run the team all week , practices, go into all the rooms for game planning and other strategic meetings and 100% makes changes to those..

i promise you Moores allegedly play calling was monitored and changed by MM, what oi saw this game vs 2019 was a lot of plays from a WCO, the integration that didnt happen last season with no offseason happened this offseason.. MM has huge input in the offensive and defensive game plans and sorry in your head you believe and feel what you see on Game day and from hard knocks is a reflection on McCarthy's lack of a job..thats plucking ridiculous..that would go for most of the hcs who dont call plays..many who have called plays in the past have given it up as the hc responsibility's are so overwhelming its hard to do both.

fans are insane as they sit back and make accusations as if MM just comes in and stands around..he puts in 90hrs week to this team behind the ces and anyone who thingks hes just eating and talki g are INSNARE and frankly ignorant//i mean other organizations have walk around HC if you do nothig then why have them? fire them all

Base proclaims that all Hcs do nothing and let the coordinators who they hired run the entire show..

right all walk around hcs just collect paychecks and owners dont mind paying them for doing nothing..

seriously do you hear yourselves, its insane..

what the flick to you do? huh? i bet you couldn't last week flowing around MM or any HC for that matters. do you have cameras following you around all day and then have some lowly little piss ant judge you from afar? i doubt it

Bob-Lillys-War said:

Its either McCarthy or Kellen Moore .

Welcome to Jerry world . You have to pick between two horrid options …

Click to expand...

I think we probably got the best coach we are going to get as long as Jerry decides such things. Sadly I do not see any indication that the son is any better.

WillieBeamen said:

I want Lincoln Riley

Click to expand...

the Guy who barely beat Tulane, didnt look prepared for that game, cant beat Bama, no national titles is all of sudden a lock for nfl greatness. Thats laughable.., ? right boy genius whos never took snap ,Saban how did he do in the nfl?chip kelley? Patrino? that just to name few howd they do in the nfl?

Meh. I thought he had the team ready to play. They were competitive all night and almost won. Could have been a better use of the clock at the end of the game. Remember, Dak never played a preseason snap and was spot on. I will see as the season goes on...Fortunately, our division is weak...

He's one of 500 people who could have coached the Cowboys last night.

I thought surely McCarthy would be atleast on par with Garrett perhaps even better but that's not what we've seen from him. Fassel is a better coach than what we had under Garrett, but his affinity for zeurline holds them back. Quinn might be the best DC we've had in years but its a bit early to tell.

cowboyed said:

Hey Austin 3-16, I understand your frustration though. But at least the BUCS didn't steamroll us.

Click to expand...

I'm not as frustrated as I appear. Stockholm syndrome anyone?

I have deep concerns about Big Mike’s decision making and clock management.

I am impressed with Kellen Moore, and Dan Quinn looks like an upgrade.

cowboyblue22 said:

the answer is NO he is not the right coach

Click to expand...

This.