More McCarthy Mismanagement?

CarolinaFathead

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,887
Reaction score
2,334
Just watched the first 15 minutes of Get Up on ESPN and Corky got TORCHED by the panel....ask ANY Green Bay fan what they think of his game management skills, if you don't want to buy anything I'm saying.
Who gives a crap what media talking heads have to say lol?

It’s nothing but entertainment and often times their instant takes are just as stupid and irrational as anonymous message board posters.
 

DOUBLE WING

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,658
Reaction score
5,208
The timeout with 24 seconds left after Dak's 3rd and 25 completion to Lamb was Mike's most boneheaded move of the day.

It's forgotten about because they won, but in a playoff game against a team with an elite QB, you can't score and then leave them 24 seconds.
 

J12B

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,237
Reaction score
22,255
Nantz raised this during the game and it caught my eye too, but a Pats beat writer summarized it well:

“Mysteriously bad clock management by Dallas at the end of the first half. With the clock ticking down, the Cowboys used their final timeout just before Mac Jones knelt on third down. Had they waited till he knelt and then called timeout, they'd have forced New England, deep in their own end and without any timeouts of their own, to punt. Instead, the Patriots went into halftime with a 14-10 lead. The Cowboys cost themselves a chance at one last possession by doing this.”

I’ve never seen a coach consistently look more flustered and lost than McCarthy with game management; 1) to not understand the game situation and opportunity to give your team another shot with the ball; 2) to finally recognize the situation (late) and call a timeout, but at the wrong moment (i.e., called TO before he knelt).

And that's his one job smh
 

stiletto

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,003
Reaction score
12,941
Nantz raised this during the game and it caught my eye too, but a Pats beat writer summarized it well:

“Mysteriously bad clock management by Dallas at the end of the first half. With the clock ticking down, the Cowboys used their final timeout just before Mac Jones knelt on third down. Had they waited till he knelt and then called timeout, they'd have forced New England, deep in their own end and without any timeouts of their own, to punt. Instead, the Patriots went into halftime with a 14-10 lead. The Cowboys cost themselves a chance at one last possession by doing this.”

I’ve never seen a coach consistently look more flustered and lost than McCarthy with game management; 1) to not understand the game situation and opportunity to give your team another shot with the ball; 2) to finally recognize the situation (late) and call a timeout, but at the wrong moment (i.e., called TO before he knelt).

I never thought I'd see someone WORSE than Garrett at in game management. I have now and I find it amazing. It is like literally watching a train-wreck and somehow we are still winning. It is really bizzare.
 

G2

Taco Engineer
Messages
24,426
Reaction score
26,192
The timeout with 24 seconds left after Dak's 3rd and 25 completion to Lamb was Mike's most boneheaded move of the day.

It's forgotten about because they won, but in a playoff game against a team with an elite QB, you can't score and then leave them 24 seconds.
How do you know McCarthy was to blame? Is he calling all of the offense and defensive plays?
 

MMObserver

Well-Known Member
Messages
171
Reaction score
299
You know its crazy.....I like our staff....but I don't think Moore and Quinn can lead men as a head coach as well as McCarthy can.

I was around for the Jimmy years but I rarely remember them. My heyday are the grand Gailey, Campo, Garret, et. years lol.

This is just different. McCarthy isn't some big hard *** rah rah guy. He carries this team and himself like its "business as usual". They don't take themselves as serious as a Bellicheat team does but it doesn't feel as "forced" as a Garrett team does. I don't think Moore or Quinn can do what McCarthy does. Its just a perfect combination of everyone involved.

Agreed Mac is not a rah rah guy and that he is far from being a phony.

In fact, his biggest strength is he has no desire to be at the center of attention and he treats almost everyone the same way.

When you have a lot of talent, like the Cowboys do, it is actually a positive for a coach like Mac to mostly stay out of the way and let the talent shine.

Now, his continued inability to make blatantly obvious decisions such to when to go for it on 4th down, or go for 2, or to call TOs at the right time is also a hallmark of Mac's coaching.

And maybe not taking himself and his coaching staff "seriously" is why "Bellicheat" got to 7 SBs and won 5 with Brady while Mac has been to as many SBs as Lovie Smith and Ron Rivera did despite coaching Hall of Famers for 13 straight seasons in GB.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
No - he’s gonna cost us BIG TIME in a vital game because the clown keeps doing it. He’s totally freaking clueless.

M the dope M will cost us a game in the playoffs if he doesn’t learn how to coach on game day.
 

charron

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,366
Reaction score
13,726
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
McCarthy needs a clock management expert on staff. He seems too distracted at times.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
74,770
Reaction score
69,380
Agreed Mac is not a rah rah guy and that he is far from being a phony.

In fact, his biggest strength is he has no desire to be at the center of attention and he treats almost everyone the same way.

When you have a lot of talent, like the Cowboys do, it is actually a positive for a coach like Mac to mostly stay out of the way and let the talent shine.

Now, his continued inability to make blatantly obvious decisions such to when to go for it on 4th down, or go for 2, or to call TOs at the right time is also a hallmark of Mac's coaching.

And maybe not taking himself and his coaching staff "seriously" is why "Bellicheat" got to 7 SBs and won 5 with Brady while Mac has been to as many SBs as Lovie Smith and Ron Rivera did despite coaching Hall of Famers for 13 straight seasons in GB.
Perfectly said.
 

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,901
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
One thing you should know about analytics applied to the game of football, that has nothing to do with where the team is on the field. The guy that started this at Pulaski in Little Rock is emphatic that analytics actually disregards a lot of the elements that go into making decisions like where the team is on the field.

What do the analytics say about the best balanced team on offense with 1 yard to make to keep the ball? If you want to take that further, consider the team McC was coaching against. The Pats were averaging 19 ppg against the Cowboys at 34 ppg.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
OMG. Leave the man alone already. You really think this team would be where they're at w/Garrett?! No one knows what goes on at the sidelines.

There's not going to be perfect coaching. If you wish to analyze a coach, start a thread on Quinn with all those penalties his defense had. But "we" won't do that because there's no hate for Quinn. Some of this fanbase is never satisfied no matter what. Get over it. They won!

Ignore list is getting bigger & bigger!

Is it Quinn’s fault Williams can’t block without holding?
 

IceStar-D7

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,144
Reaction score
7,426
McCarthy makes no sense. He goes for a 4th and 1 four minutes into the game. Then later he has the same choice at the 40? and he goes for the field goal of which was missed. Then one while he should of been calling for a time out yet lets the clock run down. And IMO Moore is the same with his play calling in the redzone. We should be way more elite in this portion of our game plan. We'd be averaging near 50 points a game if this were more efficient.
 

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,035
Reaction score
10,803
Kicking a 51 yarder in an outdoor stadium when you have 4th & 1 was inexcusable. Moore is heralded as a great play caller ok let’s get one yard keep the chains moving and go deeper into Pats territory. The double QB sneaks when it’s first and goal at the one not good red zone strategy. Ultimately though the attempted 51 yarder is on the HC.
Why are double QB sneaks not good strategy? It's a very high percentage play, one of the highest there is. And of course, it was successful, except for the little-known rule that an opposing QB in Foxboro must have his entire body in the end zone to score.
 
Last edited:

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,035
Reaction score
10,803
The timeout with 24 seconds left after Dak's 3rd and 25 completion to Lamb was Mike's most boneheaded move of the day.

It's forgotten about because they won, but in a playoff game against a team with an elite QB, you can't score and then leave them 24 seconds.
I give him a tiny bit of slack on that one, because the officials did a terrible job of explaining the down situation there, and everyone, including Tony Romo and the Fox graphics folks, thought it was 3rd down, not 4th. It wasn't until today that I finally understood what happened there. So if the officials screwed up the explanation to the team as well, that could explain it.

But the time out at the end of the first half made no sense whatsoever.
 
Top