Not so fast on the Mccarthy love

G2 · Oct 19, 2021

5-1 is 5-1, period.

RoyalCowboy · Oct 19, 2021

Another McCarthy post, these are starting to get old. But to comment, this team hasn't been this focused and disciplined in a very long time. Great sign of a great culture. Yet, of course, someone will always complain. It's easy to complain, takes no effort.

CATCH17 · Oct 19, 2021

Soth said:
This. I could never stand Garrett. I am so glad he is gone that I am willing to overlook MMs flaws. I am not going to say I have full confidence in him but I don't hate him like most posters here. We are 5-1 with him and that is all that matters right now.

The fact he allows modern day schemes to be ran makes him a huge upgrade.

Hawkeye0202 · Oct 19, 2021

Diehardblues said:
No doubt. He should get his chance. And he got a pass last year, deservedly so.

But the hype for this team is moving up quickly and I doubt anything less than a championship appearance will suffice.

Depending how we fizzle out should provide another shot. Unless of course Jethro has to choose between him and Moore. How the season ends is critical.

Agree 100%.......

TwoDeep3 · Oct 19, 2021

CowboysFever1973 said:
I'm not confident that Mccarthy is that guy yet. If I remember right, JG once went 5-1 with a rookie dak.

What will change my mind? A nfccg birth. I don't want to settle for playoffs or 8-8 anymore. I want to taste success once again.

Who here is with me?

Not me.

The strawman argument of the NFC Championship game sets a standard we don't know can be met with any head coach because of the unknown. We saw last year what one play can do to an offense that was putting up record numbers.

So when you base your position on future results, and if it is not met then the head coach stinks, you exclude so many possibilities which could influence the outcome of this season in a negative way beyond control of the head coach.

I agree with the wanting to taste success. But at this juncture, it truly is one game at a time. And you setting a criteria so far in the future for what you will accept as success is patently unfair since McCarthy could well call a perfect play-off series of games, and one play, one bad call (Minnesota/New Orleans) could steal the team and head coach's destiny.

We all just witnessed a bad call nearly changing the outcome of the game against the Patriots.

Diehardblues · Oct 19, 2021

cowboyec said:
who said we're gonna lose in the play-offs?
we're only at the bye week.
but if this team keeps playing like it is...
nobody wants to play us.
we have a real shot...first in a LONG time.

I agree . But just saying . The fact we have a better shot will be even a tougher pill to swallow.

TwoDeep3 · Oct 19, 2021

RoyalCowboy said:
Another McCarthy post, these are starting to get old. But to comment, this team hasn't been this focused and disciplined in a very long time. Great sign of a great culture. Yet, of course, someone will always complain. It's easy to complain, takes no effort.

Pretty much the title tells you the content inside.

Don't read them.

CalPolyTechnique · Oct 19, 2021

CATCH17 said:
Nobody is confident in McCarthy besides a few homers but I’ll say this about the guy. He’s miles better than Garrett.

Garrett's approval rating was sky high in 2016.

I'm not shocked folks are letting 5-1 color their perspective.

Ranched · Oct 19, 2021

MEANWHILE....

CATCH17 said:
I complain about him but please believe after 10 years of Jason Garrett I’m just happy it’s not him and I’m very thankful but my gosh McCarthy can turn a game into a circus.

By turning a once dead squad into super heroes!

G2 · Oct 19, 2021

A couple plays away from being undefeated. We've played some solid teams and they find ways to win. The attitude is completely different that recent past teams.

Risen Star · Oct 19, 2021

I believe some day when teams win the Super Bowl they will hoist the McCarthy Trophy.

HungryLion · Oct 19, 2021

Risen Star said:
I believe some day when teams win the Super Bowl they will hoist the McCarthy Trophy.

A McCarthy trophy sounds like it would be too heavy for anyone to hoist

CowboyStar88 · Oct 19, 2021

I’m a “homer” because I’m rooting for the guy to succeed and we’re 5-1

This forum man…

And nah I ain’t “with ya”.

tunahelper · Oct 19, 2021

CowboysFever1973 said:
Its okay to be happy with 5-1 imo and I get the love.

I just think its way too early to call him better than Parcells (which I saw happen on this forum)

Never thought anyone would go there, but sure enough. M&M cannot shine Parcells shoes.

CarolinaFathead · Oct 19, 2021

CowboysFever1973 said:
I'm not confident that Mccarthy is that guy yet. If I remember right, JG once went 5-1 with a rookie dak.

What will change my mind? A nfccg birth. I don't want to settle for playoffs or 8-8 anymore. I want to taste success once again.

Who here is with me?

No coach is safe. Hell, if Tom Landry can be fired and Andy Reid can be run out of Philly, then MM certainly isn’t sitting on some golden throne as an emperor. So yeah, he’s still got to earn his keep, just like all coaches.

Dallasfann · Oct 19, 2021

Hawkeye0202 said:
I think the "few homers" ( yes I'm one ) are simply saying give the guy a chance. As with most coaches, he got a pass for 2020 but I haven't seen/heard one poster that hasn't said no excuses for 2021. He's 5-1 so far, in my book that's a great start. If supporting him the rest of this season makes me a homer, I'll take it. (LOL)

Some people who post here get so pissed when people here root for the Cowboys. Pretty comical haha.

johneric8 · Oct 19, 2021

CowboysFever1973 said:
I'm not confident that Mccarthy is that guy yet. If I remember right, JG once went 5-1 with a rookie dak.

What will change my mind? A nfccg birth. I don't want to settle for playoffs or 8-8 anymore. I want to taste success once again.

Who here is with me?

Yeah that makes perfect sense.. so lets compare the freckled puppet to a super bowl winning coach who has the highest percentages of wins in post season play in Green Bay history... My son's needs a tutor you available?

john van brocklin · Oct 19, 2021

CowboysFever1973 said:
Its okay to be happy with 5-1 imo and I get the love.

I just think its way too early to call him better than Parcells (which I saw happen on this forum)

True

Diehardblues · Oct 19, 2021

Risen Star said:
I believe some day when teams win the Super Bowl they will hoist the McCarthy Trophy.[/QUOTE

CowboyStar88 · Oct 19, 2021

Diehardblues said:

Can’t wait for this to happen

Not so fast on the Mccarthy love

Taco Engineer

Well-Known Member

1st Round Pick

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

"We Are Penn State"

Taco Engineer

Likes Collector

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Captain Comeback

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member