Yeah, I don't know about that. The amount of defensiveness here in calling up Williams for the defense of Allen had me going back into the stat book. Now it's not perfect without looking at all the game tape but in 10 games they faced each other where each was listed as a started in their respective positions, White had 6 sacks, or the equivalent of roughly 9.5 sacks over a 16 game season.
Since people are saying Williams was at his best before the accident, they faced each other 5 times with the same parameters in '92 and '93 and White notched 3 sacks, or roughly the same 9.5 sacks over a 16 game season. In 1992 when Williams won that NFC Offensive Player of the Week Award in a game against White, Reggie still had 3 sacks in the 2 other games they played that year. In 1993 Williams shut White out for the 2 games they played then.
I wonder if this legend has something to do with John Madden highlighting Williams in that one game (which probably helped with that award) and people extrapolating it out to forever.