Who was the absolute worst most hopeless player to ever play for the Dallas Cowboys

Rayman70 · Apr 23, 2022

recently? Chazzy Green . In the distant Past? Hmm..Phil Pozderac. He was AWFUL.

RonWashington · Apr 23, 2022

The Kelvin Joseph “bossman tweed” gotta have Nashon Wright duo are right on the cusp of infamy those two could turn out like lemons at the car lot .

To think Anthony Brown was a 6th rounder who people gripe about the Joseph & Wright pair drafted much higher .

Let’s not forget Josh Ball and Fehoko . Love Parsons obviously but last year is looking scary …..

CoachD · Apr 23, 2022

RS12 said:
Phil Pozdarek, Phil Costa, Clay Shiver, Shante Carver, Duane Goodrich. How much time ya got. I got more names.

Yup there certainly are a **** load of um from False Start Phil to Bobby "the Finess Linebacker" Carpenter to I can't cover for **** Duane Goodrich to Mr 09 special teams draft sensation Jayson Williams. The list goes on and on and let's not forget Taco Tuesday Carlton and my God can you do anything on the field Danny Noonan.

goshann · Apr 23, 2022

ICP said:
Jaylon Smith
Quincy Carter

Neither were close to being the worse players. Both starters and both had flashes of good play

Reverend Conehead · Apr 23, 2022

KJJ said:
He was actually an excellent place kicker but had a serious off the field issue. I think the OP is looking for who was the most hopeless as a player.

Septien was framed in his off-the-field issue. Then he had a lousy lawyer who urged him not to fight it.

Reverend Conehead · Apr 23, 2022

Kareem Larimore.

Reverend Conehead · Apr 23, 2022

Rayman70 said:
recently? Chazzy Green . In the distant Past? Hmm..Phil Pozderac. He was AWFUL.

Pozderac was the biggest reason why the 1986 Cowboys crashed and burned after starting 6 and 2. He was Mr. Hold or Mr. False Start, take your pick, maybe Mr. Holdfalsestart.

Bullflop · Apr 23, 2022

Anyone who didn't make the team -- there's nothing more hopeless than being absent. :grin:

KeepinTime · Apr 23, 2022

Stash said:
Joseph Randle has to be right up there. After Demarco Murray left in free agency, that guy was handed the keys to the kingdom. He was set up to be ‘the guy’, running behind the best line in the league at that time.

He squandered the opportunity so badly that I think he’s currently in prison.

Probably modeling that stolen underwear for his cell mate.

stuckindc · Apr 23, 2022

Hawkeye0202 said:
For me Roy Williams.....I know some may ask which one. Actually, BOTH considering what they cost us

https://cowboyscoffeetalk.com/a-tale-of-two-roys/

We could have traded down , got an extra pick and taken Ed Reed. No big deal there.

RonWashington · Apr 23, 2022

And like I said Anthony Brown at 6 has been a steal , try understanding a post before you reply .

ColoradoCowboy · Apr 23, 2022

Anthony ef fin Fasano

I will NEVER forgive him for taking the play off on the "Game Winning" FG in Seattle. I will bear unnatural man-hatred for him until the day that I die.

DallasDW00ds0n · Apr 23, 2022

RS12 said:
Phil Pozdarek, Phil Costa, Clay Shiver, Shante Carver, Duane Goodrich. How much time ya got. I got more names.

That’s a great list.

It really could be Goodrich.

Some other honorable mentions, Wane McGarity, Jeff Odgen, Chris Brazzell, Clint Stoerner

kskboys · Apr 23, 2022

MarionBarberThe4th said:
You’re over thinking it. Sometimes guys who are clearly world class athletes like cate yet and reeves just are in over their head and played too many snaps wherein they hurt the teams chances of winning and as fans watching we knew it.

Of course, but that's not what this thread is about. It's about absolutely awful players. Not serviceable players.

Tussinman · Apr 23, 2022

Aerolithe_Lion said:
Trysten Hill has had some injury problems, but he’s been in the NFL for 3 years now and has 2 career tackles for loss. That’s unfathomable.

Yeah he's a good choice. Especially when you consider not only was he a 2nd rounder but he was drafted at a position that the team was weak at and he still can't do squat

3 years and all he's known for is being a healthy scratch, falling asleep during a team meeting, and punching someone after a game.

Embarassing, gotta love these 2nd round project picks ("uhh we can fix/save him").

ICP · Apr 23, 2022

goshann said:
Neither were close to being the worse players. Both starters and both had flashes of good play[/QUOTE

goshann said:
Neither were close to being the worse players. Both starters and both had flashes of good play

Jaylon was a JAG and and was comical on the field, just about any player can have 'Flashes' but in his last couple if years I have rarely seen a player looked as clueless as he did.

SexyDexy52 · Apr 24, 2022

I'm going to have to go with the two top picks of the 2009 draft.
1. Jason Williams LB
2. Robert Brewster OT
There is a reason Williams wasn't even invited to the combine. But his test results at his proday were excellent, just couldn't play football. And Brewster liked eating much more than he liked playing ball.

csirl · Apr 24, 2022

leeblair said:
The radio announcer now- served as backup to Aikman until he had to actually play when Aikman went down to a knee injury-
Babe Laufenberg.
It was hard to watch.
I still don't know how he made Jimmy Johnson's roster.
He was like a scared Jr Varsity qb from high school when he had to play.

I've heard it said that he was on the roster to help build team spirit. Was a good guy to be around and a prolific practical joker - which helped build team unity. Given that he sat behind 2 x 1st round QBs, nobody thought he'd ever be needed on the field.

terra · Apr 24, 2022

ICP said:
Jaylon was a JAG and and was comical on the field, just about any player can have 'Flashes' but in his last couple if years I have rarely seen a player looked as clueless as he did.

This is business, its not personal Sonny.

You need to separate your personal feelings from reality. Jaylon was a good LB for that one year; why he fell apart after that no one knows. To to try and claim otherwise is just flat out stupid.

CalPolyTechnique · Apr 24, 2022

Jaylon Smith.

Who was the absolute worst most hopeless player to ever play for the Dallas Cowboys

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Cowboys Diehard

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member