What Kind of Start Would it Take to bench the QB?

G2 · May 19, 2022

basel90 said:
wish dak was close to romo . at least romo pulled off some game wins despite bad OL and DL, and Romo can read coverages and make plays. Dak is so robotic and has wasted 5 years and counting. The team is not great next year but the last 4 years a top tier QB takes this team to the CCG at least. Heck, Foles won a super bowl with worse talent.

I'm not sure you were watching Romo. He put up fantastic team statistics but also single-handedly threw win or go home games away routinely. And that's without any excuses.

CTcowboy203 · May 19, 2022

Lol at people thinking we’d bench dak if he went 0-3

CouchCoach · May 19, 2022

Of the QB’s on this team, which one gives them the best chance of winning?

Only injury benches Prescott.

tyke1doe · May 19, 2022

Yall love torturing yourselves don't you? :laugh:

basel90 · May 19, 2022

G2 said:
I'm not sure you were watching Romo. He put up fantastic team statistics but also single-handedly threw win or go home games away routinely. And that's without any excuses.

agree, he had some desperation tendencies and risks. but defenses feared him more than they fear dak , which created more running game room . With dak , the field is compressed . 3 targets to Cee Dee against the 49eres??? Amari gone due to lack of targets all season , etc.

CouchCoach · May 19, 2022

G2 said:
I'm not sure you were watching Romo. He put up fantastic team statistics but also single-handedly threw win or go home games away routinely. And that's without any excuses.

No doubt about it, he'd go back to pass, it was hold your breath time. I do not have any stats to prove this but I saw him throw more picks that were made easy for the DB than any other QB. Not as bad as O'Donnell to Brown but they didn't have to move much.

There has never been an edge of your seat QB like him with the Cowboys.

G2 · May 19, 2022

CouchCoach said:
No doubt about it, he'd go back to pass, it was hold your breath time. I do not have any stats to prove this but I saw him throw more picks that were made easy for the DB than any other QB. Not as bad as O'Donnell to Brown but they didn't have to move much.

There has never been an edge of your seat QB like him with the Cowboys.

I have all the stats you need, but to some he's some Unicorn after retirement.
There's a list of games he broke hearts in and the team was done for the season. A couple of those games we had the lead, he just blew it.

G2 · May 19, 2022

basel90 said:
agree, he had some desperation tendencies and risks. but defenses feared him more than they fear dak , which created more running game room . With dak , the field is compressed . 3 targets to Cee Dee against the 49eres??? Amari gone due to lack of targets all season , etc.

Prescott scored all the TDs vs. the 9ers, including a dime to Amari where he read blitz. "Compressed" lmao.

erod · May 19, 2022

It would be a more interesting question if there was a legitimate backup here like Baker Mayfield or someone.

KJJ · May 19, 2022

Any team that would bench their starting QB after the first few games of the season will be looking for a new QB the following season. With the added game the regular season has become even more of a marathon. If you’re benching you’re starting QB after a bad start to the regular season you’re giving up on them and the season.

KJJ · May 19, 2022

erod said:
It would be a more interesting question if there was a legitimate backup here like Baker Mayfield or someone.

It wouldn’t even be a question if Baker Mayfield was our backup. No team is going to bench a $40 million per season QB for an up and down, mediocre QB with a losing record.

Nexx · May 19, 2022

as much as I would like a viable alternative to Dak, there isn't one. he isn't getting benched until there is one.

basel90 · May 20, 2022

G2 said:
Prescott scored all the TDs vs. the 9ers, including a dime to Amari where he read blitz. "Compressed" lmao.

one Touchdown the whole game . Not enough these days to win anything.
Dak has 43 throws , only completing half . You cannot win like that .

Mannix · May 20, 2022

Pass2Run said:
I see some people missed the hypothetical part.

Oh well.

Some people for whatever reason CANNOT grasp the concept of hypotheticals...its very strange.

G2 · May 20, 2022

basel90 said:
one Touchdown the whole game . Not enough these days to win anything.
Dak has 43 throws , only completing half . You cannot win like that .

Maybe go watch the game.
Prescott scored 2 TDs. One pass to Cooper and he ran one in. Dak had half the rushing yards too. My statement was accurate, you're just not being honest. Prescott could have played better for sure, but he's literally the last ONE player I'd point the finger at. I'd point out the 5 sacks, a dozen penalties and over a dozen pressures but you'll ignore it in hopes of trolling another day.

Flamma · May 20, 2022

DanA said:
Not really…it’s uncomfortable but not unheard for a quarterback and something the Cowboys can consider if his form creators. The price for the low 20m cap hits in 2021 and 2022 is that 40m of cap damage is shifted to future years.

So if we cut him post June 1st 2024 we still have to pay that 40m but it’d be an 18m cap hit in 2024 and 22m in 2025. Essentially if Dak isn’t worthy of a starting QB who earninng a 29m base salary we can and should cut him post June 1st 2024.

The no trade/franchise clause does kill any leverage and the potential of getting draft picks though which makes it a pretty horrible deal IMO.

The likely strategy being tank 2024, clear cap space and get a rookie QB in the top 5 of the 2025 draft.

I'm not so sure about that. I think the dead cap for 2024 does not include the void years. I'm not positive. Are those dead caps including the void years?

Dak Prescott Contract Breakdowns, Salary Cap Figures, Salaries, Bonuses | Spotrac

Flamma · May 20, 2022

G2 said:
Maybe go watch the game.
Prescott scored 2 TDs. One pass to Cooper and he ran one in. Dak had half the rushing yards too. My statement was accurate, you're just not being honest. Prescott could have played better for sure, but he's literally the last ONE player I'd point the finger at. I'd point out the 5 sacks, a dozen penalties and over a dozen pressures but you'll ignore it in hopes of trolling another day.

Ever since the league shifted to pass heavy you see more and more people talking about quarterbacks like they're pitchers in baseball. You hear it all the time. Wins and losses. How many times you hear Matt Stafford never won anything? With no regard to the team around them.

KJJ · May 20, 2022

Some of you knuckleheads can keep hoping he gets benched but it’s not going to happen! Enjoy the 2022 season pulling against him.

phildadon86 · May 20, 2022

Pass2Run said:
This is purely hypothetical. And for us, we think, at least, worst case scenario.

I think there could be some discussion about it if the Cowboys happen to start 0-3.

But what kind of start would it take for the Cowboys to bench Dakota?

Do you think it's possible that he loses three games in a row, to start, and then remains a starter?

They played an injured Zeke over pollard because Jerry wants his money on the field. Dak would need to be in a body cast not to play.

lukin2006 · May 20, 2022

Dak will start no matter the start. I like the tough start we have…

What Kind of Start Would it Take to bench the QB?

G2

Taco Engineer

CTcowboy203

Well-Known Member

CouchCoach

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member

basel90

Well-Known Member

CouchCoach

G2

Taco Engineer

G2

Taco Engineer

erod

Well-Known Member

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind

Nexx

Well-Known Member

basel90

Well-Known Member

Mannix

Well-Known Member

G2

Taco Engineer

Flamma

Well-Known Member

Flamma

Well-Known Member

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind

phildadon86

Well-Known Member

lukin2006

Well-Known Member