How good could Jimmy Smith have been for the 1993-2000 team?

Red Dragon · Jul 3, 2022

The Cowboys treated Jimmy Smith like trash, including not taking him seriously during a medical ailment that came close to killing him, and penny-pinching him even after that episode. JSmith then went on to become the Jacksonville Jaguars' best-ever wide receiver.

With JSmith, Harper and Irvin healthy and playing to max potential in 1994, the Cowboys would have had the league's best trio that year, and even with Harper gone, a JSmith-Irvin duo would still be formidable during 1995-2000 - and if Jerry picks Randy Moss in 1998, oh my......

Thoughts? Does a healthy and happy JSmith make Dallas go deeper in the playoffs in 1994 and 1996-1999?

Longboysfan · Jul 3, 2022

Yes Easily

America's Cowboy · Jul 3, 2022

One of the few times Jimmy Johnson (and Jerry Jones) messed up for the 90s Cowboys.

Majic · Jul 3, 2022

A huge mis-judgement by the Cowboys

TheMarathonContinues · Jul 3, 2022

Some guys have to leave their current team to be the best version of themselves. Leaving here is probably why he became the guy he did. Same goes for Chris Carter with the Vikings.

xwalker · Jul 3, 2022

Red Dragon said:
The Cowboys treated Jimmy Smith like trash, including not taking him seriously during a medical ailment that came close to killing him, and penny-pinching him even after that episode. JSmith then went on to become the Jacksonville Jaguars' best-ever wide receiver.

With JSmith, Harper and Irvin healthy and playing to max potential in 1994, the Cowboys would have had the league's best trio that year, and even with Harper gone, a JSmith-Irvin duo would still be formidable during 1995-2000 - and if Jerry picks Randy Moss in 1998, oh my......

Thoughts? Does a healthy and happy JSmith make Dallas go deeper in the playoffs in 1994 and 1996-1999?

He didn't play in 1994.

It took a long time before he became a fulltime starter.

Drafted in 1992.
Full Time starter 1997.

erod · Jul 3, 2022

Nobody's fault.

Glad it eventually worked out for him.

jazzcat22 · Jul 3, 2022

Lost me after the ..trash...word.
There is more to the events of what occurred.

CalPolyTechnique · Jul 3, 2022

Jimmy Smith put up HOF numbers as they are. Imagine where he would have ranked if he actually played his first three seasons (1992-1994): 7 games (0 starts), 0 catches.

How good could Jimmy Smith have been for the 1993-2000 team?

Red Dragon

Well-Known Member

Longboysfan

hipfake08

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member

Majic

Well-Known Member

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member

xwalker

Well-Known Member

erod

Well-Known Member

jazzcat22

CalPolyTechnique

Well-Known Member