Cowboys franchise Pollard next season?

Reid1boys · Nov 22, 2022

charron said:
Transition tag with a 2nd round offer maybe a 1st. And then just draft a replacement if he leaves.

Did you read my post above? Sure, while we are at it, why dont we just draft the next Mahomes in the 5th?

ThatJerryKid · Nov 22, 2022

Malhavoc said:
There is 0 chance that Pollard is not with this team next year. They will absolutely franchise him. He is this team’s best offensive player and it ain’t close. Zeke will either take a pay cut or he’ll be gone.

100% agree and I wouldn’t have said that at the beginning of the year. Watching Pollard the past few games has been remarkable. He’s only 25 years old and split carries in college and in the NFL so he’s not overworked. Sign him for 4 years and let him be the focal point of this offense.

charron · Nov 22, 2022

Reid1boys said:
Did you read my post above? Sure, while we are at it, why dont we just draft the next Mahomes in the 5th?

I didnt. But apparently you think pollard is mahomes so ill skip your opinion.

Bobhaze · Nov 22, 2022

Reid1boys said:
I dont disagree. But for those saying we simply cant pay Pollard we can just draft his replacement, I think they are sadly mistaken. I showed with my post that about 15 crappy backs are taken for each good 1.

For sure. I would be cautious though about signing Pollard to another 4 year deal with guarantees like Zeke had. Most teams are getting away from long term commitments to RBs and for good reason. It’s the riskiest position investment on an NFL roster IMO.

Reid1boys · Nov 22, 2022

charron said:
I didnt. But apparently you think pollard is mahomes so ill skip your opinion.

Well, that is what you get when you make assumptions and dont read.

manster4ever · Nov 22, 2022

Bobhaze said:
For sure. I would be cautious though about signing Pollard to another 4 year deal with guarantees like Zeke had. Most teams are getting away from long term commitments to RBs and for good reason. It’s the riskiest position investment on an NFL roster IMO.

...I agree, either sign him to a 3-4 year deal which is front loaded or tag him the next two years which would also necessitate Zeke taking a cut and if he won't then subsequently releasing him and drafting another bruising RB in the 3rd-5th round.

sacase · Nov 22, 2022

Stak78 said:
I would tag him and release Zeke. Replenish the stable with a couple mid round draft pics next draft. Malik Davis looks to be more than serviceable as well. After a year of Pollard taking the lead role then decide what to do with him.

So you are going to tie up 24 million in the RB position then.

charron · Nov 22, 2022

Reid1boys said:
Well, that is what you get when you make assumptions

You compared drafting pollard to drafting a mahomes in your reply to me. No need to read anything ekse you write. Thats not an assu.ption its what you wrote or do yiu not kbow the crap that you type?

Mr_437 · Nov 22, 2022

My take is I'm signing TP to a 4 year deal easy because he's a Playmaker/Offensive weapon.

Take the savings from letting Shultz go ($10M), and a Zeke paycut or release to sign TP anywhere from $10-12M. I think Tony is comparable to Aaron Jones and he's 3 years younger with less tread than most RBs.

Go get a workhorse RB in the draft or UFA for cheap, and let him and TP 1-2 punch it out on defenses.

manster4ever · Nov 22, 2022

Mr_437 said:
My take is I'm signing TP to a 4 year deal easy because he's a Playmaker/Offensive weapon.

Take the savings from letting Shultz go ($10M), and a Zeke paycut or release to sign TP anywhere from $10-12M. I think Tony is comparable to Aaron Jones and he's 3 years younger with less tread than most RBs.

Go get a workhorse RB in the draft or UFA for cheap, and let him and TP 1-2 punch it out on defenses.

..."stop making so much sense. It has no place in this organization".

Sincerely,

JJ & Jethro

Reid1boys · Nov 22, 2022

I made no comparison of Pollard to Mahomes. I was mocking your statement that we should just draft Pollard's replacement. Had you read my post above, like I commented on, youd see the proof that I posted that finding a back of Pollard's abilities had about a 90% or so fail rate by all the teams drafting backs in the first 4 rounds of 2018 and 2019. I then stated since we could so easily replace Pollard... why not just draft another Mahomes while we are at it.

Since you can not read between the lines, I was saying your comment was about as ignorant as the one I followed it up with.... you know, the part about just finding the next Mahomes...... since it is so easy, as you implied.

Beaker42 · Nov 22, 2022

RomoIsGod said:
Can't let him go yet with this kind of play.

If we draft a RB high that'll give you your answer if he hasn't been tagged at that point.

conner01 · Nov 22, 2022

Creeper said:
I would break my own rule about signing RBs and sign Pollard for the right price, but I have a feeling the price is going to be too high. Pollard will be gone next year because someone will offer him close to a Zeke-like contract. Pollard is a game changer. You can see he can score in the passing or running game. He is worth way more than Zeke. I hope the Cowboys can get something done with him, even if it means letting Zeke go. the thing you have to worry about though is RBs don't have long careers generally. But f you use them right they can last log enough.

I think the price is around 10 and I don’t think that’s too high if you move on from Zeke
You can structure it cheap the first year and there after it’s no more expensive than what we have scheduled to pay Zeke. Actually a little cheaper
It’s much easier to replace what Zeke brings to the game than what pollard brings
Pollard can be what McCaffery or Deebo bring

charron · Nov 22, 2022

Reid1boys said:
I made no comparison of Pollard to Mahomes. I was mocking your statement that we should just draft Pollard's replacement. Had you read my post above, like I commented on, youd see the proof that I posted that finding a back of Pollard's abilities had about a 90% or so fail rate by all the teams drafting backs in the first 4 rounds of 2018 and 2019. I then stated since we could so easily replace Pollard... why not just draft another Mahomes while we are at it.

Since you can not read between the lines, I was saying your comment was about as ignorant as the one I followed it up with.... you know, the part about just finding the next Mahomes...... since it is so easy, as you implied.

You absolutely compared tgem aee your iwn post and pollard is proof it can be done. Literal proof.

Reid1boys · Nov 22, 2022

charron said:
You absolutely compared tgem aee your iwn post and pollard is proof it can be done. Literal proof.

Holy crap....... dman, can you comprehend? Sure it can be done, but teams FAIL miserably at doing it. I can also win the lottery... it can be done! Not very likely. So sure, you can find a Pollard in rd 7.... but not liekly. So just saying go draft another Pollard, while possible, is far more likely we fall on our face and replace Pollard with a garbage player. But again, you obviously failed to look at my post that showed all of the FAILURES teams drafted vs the very few successes.

mattjames2010 · Nov 22, 2022

Mr_437 said:
My take is I'm signing TP to a 4 year deal easy because he's a Playmaker/Offensive weapon.

Take the savings from letting Shultz go ($10M), and a Zeke paycut or release to sign TP anywhere from $10-12M. I think Tony is comparable to Aaron Jones and he's 3 years younger with less tread than most RBs.

Go get a workhorse RB in the draft or UFA for cheap, and let him and TP 1-2 punch it out on defenses.

You can put money like that at, I don't know, safety or DT maybe? That's a hefty amount for a player who is only having a stretch of games so far.

buybuydandavis · Nov 23, 2022

KJJ said:
They had no choice but to pay Schultz for one season because they couldn’t afford to lose him, along with Amari Cooper and Cedrick Wilson. That would have literally wiped out our entire starting receiving group, except for CeeDee. Schultz tied for the team lead along with Cooper with 8 TD catches. Plus Schultz has been Dak’s security blanket. I find it hard to believe the Cowboys would turn around and pay a complementary back 12 million per for one season. He’s a very good player, but he does have some liabilities.

Keep Cooper and lose Schulz and Gallup, getting comp picks for them next year.
That was the choice they had. They chose wrong.

charron · Nov 23, 2022

Reid1boys said:
Holy crap....... dman, can you comprehend? Sure it can be done, but teams FAIL miserably at doing it. I can also win the lottery... it can be done! Not very likely. So sure, you can find a Pollard in rd 7.... but not liekly. So just saying go draft another Pollard, while possible, is far more likely we fall on our face and replace Pollard with a garbage player. But again, you obviously failed to look at my post that showed all of the FAILURES teams drafted vs the very few successes.

Already told you im not looking at your previous post try comprehending that. Youve already been proven wrong. While all teams have busts this one has done a dam good job drafting players. Maybe you forget.

They drafted
Zeke who was a leading rusher
They drafted pollard late even though you dont think it can be done
Tyron smith will be HOF, thats hall of fame player
Zach martin will be a HOF player
Travis fredrick would be HOF player if not for his disease
Micah Parsons has potential to be a HOF player

All unprobable, all really happened, all fairly recently being 3 of 4 soon to be HOF players on this team. Their drafting track record is way better than your opinion.

Stak78 · Nov 23, 2022

sacase said:
So you are going to tie up 24 million in the RB position then.

Zeke would be a June 1st cut to save as much cap space as possible. I didn’t sign Zeke to his ridiculous contract. What is the alternative? Let Pollard walk and just roll Zeke out again?

Reid1boys · Nov 23, 2022

charron said:
Already told you im not looking at your previous post try comprehending that. Youve already been proven wrong. While all teams have busts this one has done a dam good job drafting players. Maybe you forget.

They drafted
Zeke who was a leading rusher
They drafted pollard late even though you dont think it can be done
Tyron smith will be HOF, thats hall of fame player
Zach martin will be a HOF player
Travis fredrick would be HOF player if not for his disease
Micah Parsons has potential to be a HOF player

All unprobable, all really happened, all fairly recently being 3 of 4 soon to be HOF players on this team. Their drafting track record is way better than your opinion.

Jaylen Tolbert

Cowboys franchise Pollard next season?

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member

ThatJerryKid

cowboys31

charron

Well-Known Member

Bobhaze

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member

manster4ever

Well-Known Member

sacase

Well-Known Member

charron

Well-Known Member

Mr_437

Well-Known Member

manster4ever

Well-Known Member

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member

Beaker42

Well-Known Member

conner01

Well-Known Member

charron

Well-Known Member

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member

buybuydandavis

Well-Known Member

charron

Well-Known Member

Stak78

Well-Known Member

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member